Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Differences: B31.3 versus B31.12 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

iainuts

Mechanical
Sep 24, 2003
552
0
0
US
Last year (2008), ASME B31.12 "Hydrogen Piping and Pipelines" was released. Prior to this pipe spec, ASME B31.3 was generally the go-by for hydrogen piping systems in the US.

The purpose of this thread is to identify differences between B31.3 and B31.12 to help bring folks like myself up to speed on B31.12. If your job is anything like mine, you don't have time to sit down and spend days going through the spec - so having a discussion around the differences, especially in the area of design and test would be extremely helpful.

There's a good overview of the basic conceptual differences posted here:
This goes over a few very high level features of the code as a starting point for anyone not familiar with the development of this code.

It might be easiest to point out just one or two differences, referencing paragraphs in the codes. Trying to enumerate all the differences at once will be an eye-lid slammer. Also, any references to internet sites that discuss differences would be appreciated.
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Lou's presentation dates back to 2005.

The B31.12-2008 has 3 parts because this one Code will cover piping and pipelines. But the 3 parts are different that the 2005 presentation predicted. Part GR is General Requirements that apply to the entire document. Part IP applies to Industrial Piping – typically above ground piping and its support system. Part PL addresses pipelines. The commercial rules will be added in future editions.

The committee is trying to “fill the gap” between various existing piping Codes as they can be applied to hydrogen piping service. It might be useful for you to read the Forward of this Code. That being the case I have uploaded that.

Regards, John
 
 http://files.engineering.com/getfile.aspx?folder=26013c43-7b19-4277-8bea-89f4409ec85b&file=B31.12_Forward.doc
Many of the presentations that can be found on the Internet predicted that commercial hydrogen piping would be included in the 2008 first edition. However it did not make it for 2008 and will be included in future editions. With that caveat:







This one from NASA Glenn research is good

Old specifications like this still referred to B31.3 as the min go-to but it is important to note that B31.12 ALSO DOES refer to B31.3


State of New Jersey

More from NASA

This one is a bibliography of applicable guides and standards


There is a lot out there for he who Googles.

Regards, John.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top