Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations LittleInch on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by Geoff13

  1. Geoff13

    Formula for Calculating Basic Allowable Stresses in ASME B31.3

    Are you looking for Clause 302.3.2?
  2. Geoff13

    Loads/Units shown on drawings

    I'm afraid that I'm one who insists on a space between the value and the unit. I would use a non-breaking space when the program may re-flow the text. Most of the world should follow BIPM SI Brochure 9th Edition (2019) clause 5.4.3, which can be found here ...
  3. Geoff13

    Unity check in saddle

    Based on the zero information you've given, my answer is "make it stronger". Applicable code, vessel size, saddle dimensions, which check is failing, etc, etc, etc ??? Sketches or drawings are always best.
  4. Geoff13

    Fully supported flanged tank bottom according to EN 14015

    In API 650 a flanged bottom in only permitted on an Annex J shop assembled tank. However your tank is quite small so shop assembly might be possible. Assuming EN 14015 is similar to API 650, you could check your copy to see if there's something similar to Annex J.
  5. Geoff13

    According to ASME Section II Part D, the size limit for SA-193 B7M is 100mm in SI units and 2.5 inches in US units. Are there any other reasons?

    I have the 2015 Editions of II-D (USC and SI) and 64 mm is used throughout for the SA193 B7M size limit.
  6. Geoff13

    Equivalent "Responsible Charge" requirements in Canada?

    I have been licensed in five or six of the provinces over the years. I seem to remember they all have something to say about this, but they are quite varied. I suspect the more recent the revision to their guidelines the closer they read like this NSPE statement. I would advise looking up the...
  7. Geoff13

    API 650_Polygon shape for Bottom plate

    Sketch plates usually have a radiused edge. I've never seen anything else.
  8. Geoff13

    Strength of laminated steel plates vs. solid section

    While your dimensions are very close to 24" Sch 100 pipe, I'm not sure who would have a 3' length laying around. If you have fabricators that can roll 0.75", have you asked if they can roll 1.5"? It's much harder to roll, but the short length will make it easier. I'd find a fabricator with...
  9. Geoff13

    BPVC Div 1 Thread Allowable (UG-43)

    Oops, I didn't think carefully enough about you saying "pressure sensor". This will of course require a through hole. Let me start fresh. I'm used to see small flanged nozzles labelled as pressure sensors. Presumably these sensors come with standard B16.5 bolted flange for attachment. The...
  10. Geoff13

    BPVC Div 1 Thread Allowable (UG-43)

    The Code addresses pressure retaining components. Thus a nozzle that is threaded into the vessel wall would have to meet UG-43, since the neck would be pressure retaining. If I understand your description you just want to have a partial depth threaded hole for attaching a sensor. I would say...
  11. Geoff13

    Codeware COMPRESSS Nozzle FEA Error

    Next time you might want to post a question about Compress in the dedicated forum : https://www.eng-tips.com/forums/codeware-compress.1259/
  12. Geoff13

    ratline design

    Also never heard of a ratline. Where does this term come from? Do not multiply the two safety factors. 5 is greater than 2, so it meets the OSHA requirement. Due to the shallow angles the HLL takes at arrest you may have trouble staying within the SF=5 safe load listed by the manufacturer...
  13. Geoff13

    Load Rating of a structure

    Many good answers already, so I take a different direction. Here's some quick gut check questions I ask myself when looking at fall protection anchor points. What location would you be willing to hang your car off? My answer would be nowhere in those pictures. Handrail is required to support...
  14. Geoff13

    Is there a connection like UW-13 for direct connection of Body flange to spherical heads?

    The Code Committee has a limited amount of time and resources, so they only include rules and sketches for "common" details. They could expand the Code to be ten times longer and still not cover every unique detail that someone might want to use. The Committee recognizes this and thus includes...
  15. Geoff13

    Annular plate thickness

    It's almost like the software is following the USC code rules, but then reporting in SI units. For instance 12.7 mm does not exist in Table 5.1a. It only exits in Table 5.1b as 1/2" (exactly 12.7 mm). This was the clue that got me thinking about this idea. The 39 mm is 1.535", which would...

Part and Inventory Search