Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by ggcdn

  1. ggcdn

    NBCC 2020 Climatic Data

    Not exactly what you're looking for, but if you provide the values I can add them to my db here: https://calcs.app/general/seismic-and-climate-data
  2. ggcdn

    SE Exam New format April 2024

    I wrote and passed the CBT lateral and vertical breadth exams several weeks ago. Since the exam format was new I decided to 'wing it' without putting in much studying effort, just worked on practice problems leading up to the exam, and got lucky. I had previously written the CBT California...
  3. ggcdn

    General Discussion on Skyscraper Drift

    In the 'medium-tall' design space (45-60 stories) wind design basically amounts to making the LFRS stiff enough to limit drifts (H/500 for instance), strong enough for the equivalent static loads, and then limiting accelerations to levels deemed acceptable for the occupancy. This is usually done...
  4. ggcdn

    BC, Canada, Code changes to Boost Highrise Construction

    I cant help but feel all the exuberance around mass timber high-rises is premature. Not my specialty, but from what I understand, its basically the wild west out there with regards to things like connection detailing. Are we setting ourselves up for a Northridge-style lesson to be learned?
  5. ggcdn

    ETABS Earthquake Core wall Transferring causing very unexpected shear distribution

    You really need to be modelling the L1 and ground floor slabs out of plane behavior, including all gravity columns. There isn't a complete load path without them, and more importantly, the stiffness of the discontinuous walls is not correctly captured. Garbage in, garbage out. You should...
  6. ggcdn

    Transfer of Canadian P.eng license to US P.E process

    For California, I had to write the FE, PE, Seismic, Surveying, and Ethics exams. They didn't seem to care about a P.Eng other then it counting for something on work experience. The FE and PE could be done immediately through NCEES. Then you submit an application to the board, which includes...
  7. ggcdn

    ASCE 7-16 12.4.2.2: Vertical Seismic Exception - Mat Slab Foundation

    My understanding is that Ev can be excluded from only the ASD combinations, which you would only be using for checking soil demands. The concrete design would be using USD combinations which then need to include Ev. This can lead to a bit of inconsistency for things like checking uplift and...
  8. ggcdn

    Performance-Based Design "Philosophy"

    Josh touched on retrofit uses, but on new builds PBD in the US is largely done to get around the 240ft height limit on special concrete wall systems without having to go to a dual system. One of the side effects of that, when compared to code based design, is you generally need much more shear...
  9. ggcdn

    Is subgrade modulus still used by structural engineers?

    I use it for large combined footings / raft foundations / core footings which require analysis by FEM. I'm not sure how you could reasonably design a large raft without it. The results are quite sensitive to it on softer soils. Once you get above 200psi/in or so with typical building footings...
  10. ggcdn

    Elevator Openings In Concrete Core Walls

    I normally make the returns/ that side a nonstructural wall. It’s both designed and built as a c shape wall.
  11. ggcdn

    Elevator Openings In Concrete Core Walls

    Its common in North America to not include the returns and just design a three-sided / C-shaped wall. Usually they need the largest opening at or near the ground floor for installing the cabs.
  12. ggcdn

    Cold Joint

    MSL, We usually get asked by contractors if they can use StayForm in this situation.
  13. ggcdn

    A win for open access to building codes

    US Court of Appeals upholds that building codes and standards incorporated into US law can be freely disseminated. https://www.eff.org/press/releases/appeals-court-upholds-publicresourceorgs-right-post-public-laws-and-regulations
  14. ggcdn

    US PE License for Canadian Engineer

    Torchman, I cant speak to NY, but in CA the application for license required either a SSN or an ITIN. It did not explicitly require proof of legal authorization to work in the US, like a green card, nor does it grant such authorization. Getting the ITIN from the IRS was difficult...
  15. ggcdn

    Slide Rule Era

    FYI, I've started creating a list of historical references that were external links rather than hosted PDFs (eg, links to archive.org documents). So far I've added Building Codes and Steel Manuals. I also added a few that weren't on SRE's site, like NBC, historical state codes, etc. Some of...

Part and Inventory Search