Fair enough. I submitted a "Report" requesting that this thread be moved to the Forensic Engineering forum. That is the closest thing I could find to the topic of the thread. Thanks.
Yeah... I think the issue I had is that if you look at a document like UL 2218A (Outline of Investigation for Impact Resistance of Roofing Systems), for example, the "acceptance criteria" reports that "The roofing system exposed surface shall show no evidence of tearing, fracturing, cracking...
The attached document is a study on the durability of TPO roofing.
Page 15 of the document describes how “hailstones larger than 3/4 inch in diameter were among those that impacted” one of the roof membranes (the one in Texas). This roof was sampled at some of the impact locations and examined...
Engineering calculations, whether handwritten, on a spreadsheet, or on a commercial computer program, shouldn't significantly obscure the formulas or logic used. When mentoring new EI's, and having them develop their own spreadsheets for some custom calculation, I always have them write out the...
This doesn't make sense. Your roof is probably hot, generically speaking, because of heat from the sun... not "because of insufficient insulation or no insulation".
In all seriousness, additional detail should be provided. For example...
- Is the building entirely enclosed, or is it open to...
The "Structural engineering other technical topics" forum is not really the correct place for this post. Something closer to correct might have been the "Geotechnical engineering other topics" forum (http://www.eng-tips.com/threadminder.cfm?pid=274).
It may be a good idea to think about this in terms of issues other than differential settlement as well. This is kind of what I was getting at in my previous post when I said "for a number of reasons".
So... now that we've connected the buildings with a bridge, how good of a job did the...
Have to agree with Archie264. 24" on center stud spacing is generally not a good idea. You also begin to run into other issues such as potentially excessive (or even just undesirable) flexibility of the applied finishes when out-of-plane loads are applied. With a single 2x4 stud at 24" on...
Depending on the specifics of what's being done, I would probably avoid connecting the two buildings altogether (let alone "rigidly"), for a number of reasons, and have the bridge structure be independently supported, both vertically and laterally. I am guessing this won't be too popular with...
Your question is fairly broad. There are lot of ways to skin the cat... and you can take this whichever direction you want, so please keep that in mind when reading my response. My advice below also assumes you are working in the US.
The first question is... where do you think you want to end...
The "bolted"/attached wood sill plate is the most common solution I've seen in this instance. It allows for relative flexibility with (lateral; along the support) rafter placement in a way that stationary hurricane ties can't. The Simpson "Strong-Drive TB WOOD-TO-STEEL Screw" is a good fastener...
In the course of investigating my question, I found the following information regarding interviews in forensic engineering investigations (search for terms such as "interview", "eyewitness", etc.). Of course, these don't specify whether these are "under oath" or "on the record". I have more than...
Nick,
Thanks for your response.
Of course I have my opinions, but I was hoping not to (potentially) bias the responses, one way or the other (at least not initially), by providing them, or by providing evidence supporting one opinion over others. I also have a genuine desire to hear what...
