Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations LittleInch on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by milkshakelake

  1. milkshakelake

    Guide to the Design of Common Irregularities in Buildings

    I have the 2012 SEAOSC one. It's not very detailed either. It's one of those things where it's better than nothing. The visual examples do help, but it's not very in-depth.
  2. milkshakelake

    Are keys pretty common for basement wall footings?

    Agreed with @Eng16080 . It's a non-issue when all those factors are at play.
  3. milkshakelake

    Storey Shear Strength

    I'm also not familiar with NBCC. But your shear walls are not less stiff, and you're not creating a weak story condition. They're just having less load applied. If I can reference a similar code, ASCE 7-16 commentary shows some irregularities including soft story, and you don't have these...
  4. milkshakelake

    How often are y’all doing any calcs for single-family residential?

    I am not confident in my wood abilities, so I end up calculating a lot of it in terms of gravity (I'm a bit more confident in lateral, having done like 250 apartments in a past job and spending a ton of time on it). I'm far more confident in concrete and cold-formed steel, for which I've made...
  5. milkshakelake

    Axial Shortening - Multi Storey building

    I'll be the first to admit that I don't actually do this, because core walls are very long and are subject to much lower axial stress from non-transient loading. It's kind of a spray-and-pray situation. I focus on equalizing the columns. It is simply impossible to do the same for core walls due...
  6. milkshakelake

    Axial Shortening - Multi Storey building

    I don't work with tall buildings myself, but in the 4-14 story range, we proportion the columns so that they have similar axial stress. Same with footings.
  7. milkshakelake

    Seismic drift - moment of inertia to use for shear walls?

    @haynewp Yes, I'm using the 1.4 factor for wind serviceability. Still hard to make it work, but that's life.
  8. milkshakelake

    Shuddering/deflection of upper storey bedrooms in 2 storey framed house due to wind

    I highly doubt it! Though I haven't seen issues so far, and yeah, the sheetrock is probably doing lateral work.
  9. milkshakelake

    exposed footing due to incorrect soil levels.

    Can you backfill and level out that slope a lot and add rip rap to protect it and do a lot of other things? I'm asking nicely, but like, you have to do it. This is a disaster in the making.
  10. milkshakelake

    Shuddering/deflection of upper storey bedrooms in 2 storey framed house due to wind

    To limit deflection and vibrations in steel stud walls, you can use either plywood, X-bracing straps, or steel sheets. The X-bracing with flat straps is commonly used, but it's also the least stiff. But it definitely works for a 2 story building if you can get enough of them. It relies on the...
  11. milkshakelake

    Seismic drift - moment of inertia to use for shear walls?

    @bookowski I haven't come across that situation about wall in front of elevator, but I'll keep an eye out for it. Thanks for the tip. Will see where it's going when I speak to the contractor. Regarding wind drift, yeah, I got seismic under control but wind drift is giving me a lot of problems...
  12. milkshakelake

    Overstrength factor for hat truss?

    Hello @HTURKAK , thank you for your opinion. I believe that there is no in-plane discontinuity because the overturning demand is subject to a lateral system that has equal stiffness on all floors. The outrigger system uses the column as part of its stiffness, and it is not more stiff at the top...
  13. milkshakelake

    Overstrength factor for hat truss?

    @KootK Thanks so much! The document answers my concerns fully, and it's pretty much what I thought. It definitely helps to have it in a publication. For anyone coming across this a hundred years in the future, after I have expired (hopefully not) and my outriggers are still functional, this is...
  14. milkshakelake

    Overstrength factor for hat truss?

    Do I need to consider hat truss with overstrength factor? Sketch below. This one is a vierendeel truss. I'm not sure what to make of it, if it creates soft story/vertical irregularity or not. I'm inclined to think that it doesn't, because the stiffness of the lateral system is a collective unit...
  15. milkshakelake

    Seismic drift - moment of inertia to use for shear walls?

    @W460x68 I would love to, but that is discontinuous at the base due to a storefront. I didn't want to get into a vertical irregularity or weak story situation.

Part and Inventory Search