Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by Stephen Max

  1. Stephen Max

    What FEA analysis is needed for Division 1 certification?

    Thank you gentlemen for your replies. The vessel is indeed being fabricated by a machine shop with a certificate. Actually, I asked them the same question after posting this, they gave me the same answer. I should have asked him first but didn't think to. Again, thanks!
  2. Stephen Max

    What FEA analysis is needed for Division 1 certification?

    I am working on a pressure vessel for laboratory use that is designed per Division 1 rules. I have been doing extensive FEA on the design per Division 2 guidelines, but I am not clear what is required for ASME certification under Division 1 rules. If the PV is based on Div 1 design by rule...
  3. Stephen Max

    pressure vessel interanl pressure

    Gauge pressure is the same as absolute pressure on the moon, so you can still design according to gauge pressure.
  4. Stephen Max

    pressure vessel interanl pressure

    Use gage pressure, since it is the differential between internal and external pressure that creates stress.
  5. Stephen Max

    recommendation for anti-seize?

    I am designing a pressure vessel that will be using Inconel 718 bolts due its strength retention at the design operating temperature of 550C. Preliminary testing has shown a problem with galling when torquing the bolts with dry threads, so I am considering using anti-seize to prevent galling...
  6. Stephen Max

    When is an unfired steam boiler not a heat exchanger?

    Thank you, gentlemen, for your replies. I have a device that heats water in a tube by means of external electric resistance heating and heat conduction through a metal matrix surrounding the tube (and not by having the heaters directly immersed in the water) to generate steam. The...
  7. Stephen Max

    When is an unfired steam boiler not a heat exchanger?

    In the preamble to Section I, there is this verbage: "Unfired pressure vessels in which steam is generated shall be classed as unfired steam boilers with the following exceptions: (a) vessels known as evaporators or heat exchangers" What is the difference between a device classified as an...
  8. Stephen Max

    Is a rupture (or burst) disk considered a pressure relief valve in Section I

    Thank you for your reply. If the customer actually desires a rupture disk rather than a pressure relief valve, does Section I allow it? I'm not seeing any indication that it does in part PG.
  9. Stephen Max

    Is a rupture (or burst) disk considered a pressure relief valve in Section I

    Hmmm. In Section VIII either a pressure relief valve or a rupture disk can be used for overpressure control, mentioning both specifically. Section I speaks only of pressure relief valves in part PG and says nothing about rupture disks except in part PVG, which is not applicable to me.
  10. Stephen Max

    Is a rupture (or burst) disk considered a pressure relief valve in Section I

    I can't find anywhere in Section I where it actually states that, and I don't want to assume anything. I am designing a forced-flow steam generator with no fixed steam and waterline for laboratory research use. Thx.
  11. Stephen Max

    Inconel 625 approved for superheater but not boiler?

    The lab will be unmanned during operation, so no safety hazard. But I think I will stick to the approved list for the proof-of-concept prototype and deal with the increased iron content problem later.
  12. Stephen Max

    Inconel 625 approved for superheater but not boiler?

    First of all thanks to all of you for your replies, I appreciate every one. I was beginning to suspect something like a stress corrosion problem. Thanks for pointing that out, metengr. This will not be a problem with the initial research system, but the final production model will have to...
  13. Stephen Max

    Inconel 625 approved for superheater but not boiler?

    Thank you for your feedback. Apparently this sounds like a sketchy idea to you guys. This boiler system will be used to provide superheated steam at 70 bar for a research project I am not at liberty to discuss. The tubing in the system will have a pressure rating of over fourteen times the...
  14. Stephen Max

    Inconel 625 approved for superheater but not boiler?

    Hello all, I am designing a small boiler/superheater system that will use heaters having inconel 625 tubing cast into an aluminum matrix that has an electric heater embedded in it. This is an off the shelf item. I will use three in series, the first to boil the water, the second to raise the...
  15. Stephen Max

    Minimum thickness of a cover with bolt holes that do not fully penetrate

    Thank you! That is exactly what I was looking for.

Part and Inventory Search