Yes it can be, there many factors, torsional stress, resulting from high torque and rpm, shock, and moment to the box. Like a helicopter gear box.
Or gear box connected to a turbo prop, turbine generator, with extreme torque and rpm.
So an audit of the process planning and all the operation is required. Operators and inspector stamps and which machines were used. The cutting fluids and any process used.eg heat treat, passivation, liquid penetrant, stress relief. Etc, until the source can be found.
I too in the past delt with...
Gear rim , in this case rib is added for extra strength for the gear. Thickness of the rim and rib can not enough can result in abnormal vibration and wear to the gear. And the gear box assembly
OP
It's upto the contractor to spend the money and time to obtain certification.
A qualified quality engineer with qualification experience would be required
OP
method used was a paste applied with a tube. Like it is done with rtv sealant. I should have mentioned this earlier, those pictures you took look terrible. Those are a mess. Oven brazing should be very clean with capillary action sucks all paste between the details. Details need to be a...
3d Dave very good.
OP
The answer is complex. I will try to give examples.
Keep ot simple, give tolerances of ÷/- 010 and +/- .005. In general. True position .010 and .005 when possible.
My specialty is gears. Gear shafts.
On shafts manufactureers like between centers, and datum at each end...
OP
The standard is experience.
It all depends on the product and application.
Eg ground shafts, gears, critical complex details, sheet metal details, rough castings forgings,
Op
This will not resolve this issue.. Re posting it will not fix it.
Hire a consultant with shaft experience. How to set up and machine shafts and how to inspect them.
Not correct, gears ,spur, bevel, helical have to inspected and certified to a standard. The gear box has to be tested by the manufacture , depending on the industry. Or its function.
Op
Have them send a copy of their process planing for review.
Did they take pictures After opening the container.
Were the parts cleaned and passivated after machining