Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations KootK on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Search results for query: *

  1. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    the problem was solved, and i have pasted the issue above. If you start trying this new software you might run into this issue.
  2. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    and not so far off are ETABS result as well.
  3. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    So here is the solution to this problem for anyone else starting off with Tekla Structural Designer, First of all, TSD is a not new in the game of structural analysis softwares, it is evolved from a very respectable old software Orion which was being maintained CSC, after buyout by Tekla, it...
  4. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    They explained it that it is because of modification factors in setting, I am trying to work my way for a solution , i ll post it for every one, once solved.
  5. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    @Klaus : Good suggestion, did it and ETABS is correct. @Trenno It is fairly straight forward question, Complete information is there, even the models are there , as for deflected shape you ask for ETABS does not make a deflected shape diagram on model with VALUES, the above plot i posted is...
  6. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    This thread gets me soul searching advisory :) answers, i am 17 years in this business, i know what to do , the problem right now is mismatch in two softwares, doesnt matter practical models or not ! it is not a problem of typology, i can model most nonsense structures, but the RESULTS SHOULD...
  7. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    its a theoretical model not a practical building with oversized members,
  8. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    yes i tried few buildings, the inconsistency is same
  9. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    Its written on diagrams, floor/story displacements
  10. Al Jazari

    warehouse

    You can use STAADpro or Bentley Elements. they both are very easy i design PEBs every 3rd of my life, use RAM elements or STAADpro. Can you upload the picture of the frame here, i can quickly analyze it for you, i Have Tapframe, specialized plugin for STAAD for Tapered PEB frames.
  11. Al Jazari

    Huge Difference in ETABS vs Tekal Structural Designer

    I have been using ETABS for ages, and the results are always books perfect. I was introduced to Tekla Structural Designer, i like the interface and many aspects about it, but one thing is amazing me, The huge difference in deflections between ETABS and TSD, am i doing something wrong ? or is TSD...

Part and Inventory Search