Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations KootK on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Search results for query: *

  1. NewbieInSE

    A or B type joint in RCC Joint Shear calculation if top column is steel and bottom one is RCC?

    Hello Dear Engineers, Looking for your valuable response. This is important for me to determine the Gamma factor as shown below. Thanks.
  2. NewbieInSE

    Punching shear check of mat when thickness changes away from column

    Thanks lexpatrie and JoshPlumSE. I think I'll check a problem of flat slab with drop panel. You are right. Please note that the data I mentioned are not mathematically based on the figure I posted.
  3. NewbieInSE

    Punching shear check of mat when thickness changes away from column

    The thickened portion is sized for two considerations 1. Make punching shear ok at d/2 distance away from colukn face 2. Make flexural reinforcement reasonable. Let's say the shear force is 800 kips. when the punching perimeter is at d/2 from column face into the thickned portion,the punching...
  4. NewbieInSE

    Punching shear check of mat when thickness changes away from column

    Hello Dear Engineers, Would you check the mat punching shear and one way shear (if governs) at the locations where thickness becomes the minimum? Pls see the attached figure for understanding my question. The figure is taken from previous projects. Thanks a lot.
  5. NewbieInSE

    How much thickness makes "thick member" in punching shear resistance to drop to 2sqrt(f'c)

    Also the Seismic Design of Reinforced Concrete Mat Foundations, NIST GCR 12-917-22 has been written based on ACI 318-11 as CDLD indicated. That's why they left it to open guess using judgements probably.
  6. NewbieInSE

    How much thickness makes "thick member" in punching shear resistance to drop to 2sqrt(f'c)

    Thanks lexpatrie for the link of the research paper. Thanks HTURKAK & CDLD. I was checking ACI 318-11 and didn't find anything. But ACI 318-19 has incorporated it well. Wow. Thanks HTURKAK & CDLD.
  7. NewbieInSE

    How much thickness makes "thick member" in punching shear resistance to drop to 2sqrt(f'c)

    Hello dear Engineers, It would be great to know your understanding on how much thickness makes a "thick member" in punching shear resistance to drop to 2sqrt(f'c)b.d? Also what is meant by low reinforcement ratios? Is it flexural reinf. ratio? The following snippet is taken from Seismic Design...
  8. NewbieInSE

    Is it possible to splice a beam only on its web?

    Is it possible to weld a plate with top flanges and bottom flanges each? This way, tension or compression transfer from one flange to other would be possible, if practicable. Is autodesk robot using the input moment in calculating the connection capacity? You may check output calculations to...
  9. NewbieInSE

    Outrigger beam modelling as shell or frame in ETABS

    The diaphragm is considered rigid. Would u pls explain why semirigid should be assigned? I once read diaphragm can be considered rigid for span to depth ratio less than 3. here it is less than 3. However, for better model response, I'll consider semirigid and check the results.
  10. NewbieInSE

    Outrigger beam modelling as shell or frame in ETABS

    Span/depth ratio surely exceeds 3 or 4. As centodollar mentioned about shell modelling, is it logical to take the benefit of continuous depth connection of the outrigger beam with wall.
  11. NewbieInSE

    Outrigger beam modelling as shell or frame in ETABS

    The building floor plan looks like this. Couldn't post the CAD layout as I'm not on the PC having those files.
  12. NewbieInSE

    Outrigger beam modelling as shell or frame in ETABS

    Thanks centondollar. Which one is more realistic in ptactice? To me I feel like shell modelling captures the whole force transfer interaction between the shear wall and columns. Because while shells are modelled, column axial forces increase indicating that they are making a couple with the wall...
  13. NewbieInSE

    Outrigger beam modelling as shell or frame in ETABS

    Thanks HTURKAK for your participation. The comparison is based on cracked section models, however I know that wind drift check is for 1.4 times of strength model's cracked section properties. In one model with outrigger as frame, beams have 0.35 effective stiffness value for moment of inertia...
  14. NewbieInSE

    Outrigger beam modelling as shell or frame in ETABS

    Dear Engineers, As metioned by Taranath in his book, outriggers can be of shallower depth (rather than one or two storied deep) when used in each floor. That's how we did in a project. The building is 25 storied. Outriggers usually engage the perimeter frames in bending with core walls. Now, I...
  15. NewbieInSE

    Determining framing system of a building from drawings

    The RC column bases are not fixed at base, most of the columns have single pile supporting them. However, the columns are tied by foundation beams. So the columns have some bending stiffness at base, I think. The columns are not precast. So what does the framing system look like? Is it like...
  16. NewbieInSE

    Determining framing system of a building from drawings

    Thank you Lomarandil. Does the steel roof need to comply detailing requirements of any framing system? Say of any project specific moment frame or other.
  17. NewbieInSE

    Determining framing system of a building from drawings

    Hello Dear Engineers, I have attached some figures below. Would you pls think and say what framing system is it from ASCE Seismic Lateral Framing Systems? FYI, my understanding is RCC portion is Special Moment Frame, and Steel is not a particular framing system because it is just a roof and...
  18. NewbieInSE

    Column unbraced length question when the concerned beam falls on beam just 6" far from column face

    SO in this case, I need to find 2% of column Pu probably, and then apply it laterally (shear in the minor axis) which will produce shear force and some bending moment considering the stud length 6" supported one end continuous. I need to show the stub ok for these load effects. Is that correct?
  19. NewbieInSE

    Column unbraced length question when the concerned beam falls on beam just 6" far from column face

    Ok. But why not Ψ = Σ(EI /lc)/ (JG/lb) by EI/lb, do you mean the bending stiffness of the beam which rests on the stub?

Part and Inventory Search