Alright, that was kind of my plan. Thank you Lyrl and dbooker for the help!
I'll be sure and post any conclusions I come to here for future similar issues.
I saw this thread and was looking for additional detail. I am currently a studying metallurgical engineer interning at a plant where this is sometimes the common practice. They try to reach a case depth of >50Rc at .050 inches, and <40 at .100 inches. Occasionally a part will be over hardened...