@YuJie_PV
Good discussion.
Why do you believe that this is fraud? I believe you agree that welders might be employees from other companies, and you mentioned that this is common.
If not the welders and welding, what may we think ASME requires from applicants regarding their manufacturing...
@YuJie_PV
Your explanations are correct, but they differ from my perspective.
The relevant argument is UW-26(d), not UG-11. UG-11 addresses "Parts" only.
Let me bluntly explain how others have obtained ASME Certification without any manufacturing capability:
1. Find a cooperative...
In this situation, the stamp holder clearly and inevitably lacks any rights or responsibilities to control the resources of the manufacturer, such as personnel or machinery.
Obviously, they will say, "It's possible, we have done that".
The stamp holder does not pay the salaries or incentives of...
@YuJie_PV
@TGS4
Dear all,
As far as I know, some companies don't have manufacturing ability. The key is QCS and whether the QCS effectively meets all of ASME's requirements.
Even though the manufacturing is performed by others, not the Stamp Holder, if the Holder's QCS perfectly works for the...
On the other hand, can a company that only has sales, design, and quality abilities and no manufacturing capability acquire the ASME VIII-1 U Stamp Certificate?
"S" Company, an ASME U Stamp Holder, owns both the office building and the factory as real estate assets. While the company comprises sales, engineering, quality, and management support, the factory is mostly used to store measuring instruments and surplus materials; it is not used for actual...
