Sort of an S7, or high Cr 4140.
With a good low temp temper, say 450C, you should have 1200.
If you made hardness then you made tensile, my hunch is that you didn't get a good test because the material has so little ductility. Any twist, misalignment, or roughness of the test specimen will throw off the readings.
Looking at data for similar alloys shows that these properties are reachable.
Look at your heat treat and testing methods.
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Plymouth Tube