Follow your loads! Take a look at an anchor head setup - the tieback load is being transfered into a hex nut or anchor head, which then sits on the bearing plate. Your load is distributed in a donut shape onto the bearing plate. Modeling this as a simply supported beam with a concentrated load in the center will give you much higher moments! (What did your initial analysis come up with anyway?)
There are many variations on this setup, so you will need to know the span, diameter of the center hole and diameter of the anchor head (these will vary greatly depending on whether you use strand or bar anchors).
Another factor to consider is whether you design around the anchor design load or test load (typically 1.33*DL). This will depend on the type of jack chair you use while testing. You also may be allowed to use a 20% overstress in the steel depending on if this is a temporary or permanent wall.
Many of these details vary by contractor preference, which is why most of them design their own work to fit with their methods.