Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

ASME Section VIII Div 2, 2007 Edition

Status
Not open for further replies.

deckie1026

Mechanical
Nov 17, 2006
16
Will the 2007 Edition still require an RPE for the MDR ? I have heard rumors to the contrary.
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Yes and no. An RPE is one option for certifying a Manufacturer's Design Report.

Please note that the entire 2007 edition of Div 2 has been re-written, so I would recommend that you take a wait and see approach to it.
 
Interesting assessment TGS4,

What is the other option for certifying the MDR?

Cheers,
gr2vessels
 
According to the information that I have seen, the options are an RPE (from Canada or the US) or someone who is:
"An Engineer experienced in pressure vessel design who meets all required qualifications to perform engineering work and any supplemental requirements stipulated by the user. The Engineer shall identify the location under which he has received the authority to perform engineering work stipulated by the user in the Design Specification.", although ti should be noted that:
"The Engineer certifying the Manufacturer’s Design Report shall comply with the requirements of the location to practice engineering where that Report is prepared unless the jurisdiction where the vessel will be installed has different certification requirements."

This sounds like a good opportunity to discuss whether or not Div 2 vessels (or even pressure vessels in general) should be certified by a registered professional engineer. Thoughts?

One thing that I will take from this definition is that if you are in Canada or the US, you will have to be an RPE if you want to certify a MDR (on the basis of the second statement saying that engineer shall comply with the requirements of the location to practice engineering where that report is prepared). So in Canada or the US, there is legislation dictating who can practice engineering - only RPEs.
 
The common practice for vessel (Div 1) manufacturers in the US is to perform designs using staff personnel, few of which are PEs. The advent of slick ASME pressure vessel design programs now allows non-PEs to perform far more sophistcated engineering analysis of non-pressure loadings than ever before. Regardless what the PE laws state, they have hardly ever been applied to the design of Div 1 vessels.

Joe Tank
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor