Jajosk
Civil/Environmental
- Mar 21, 2012
- 21
Took a dig at exporting a fictional river reach modeled in Cvil 3D 2011 to HEC RAS. As the attachment will show something went wrong somewhere as indicated by a discrepancy between geometric editor and the reach length table in HEC RAS:
Flow direction in Civil 3D is from 0+12.94 (U/S) to 0+116.6 (D/S) (Fig 1). Flow direction arrow in the drawing in HEC-RAS geometric editor (Fig 3) seems to be consistent with Civil 3D (left to right, 0+12.94 (U/S) to 0+116.6 (D/S)). However, the stationing seems to be reflecting the Civil 3D set up which is awkward for HEC-RAS given the flow n HEC-RAS is always from higher stationing to lower. The issue is more than just cosmetic - table for reach length confirms that the most upstream station is 116.6 and the most downstream is 12.94, which is in contradiction with the reach arrow in the drawing.
I have tried to reverse the alignment stationing in Civil 3D (Fig 2), and created a new .geo file but the drawing and table data in HEC RAS are unchanged. I have also tried to manually change the statioing of the XSs in the .geo file. That was disastrous as in the table, there was no value between the top row 116.6 and the next downstream XS, and there was a value for the bottom row 12.94. Any thoughts as to how to get the HEC RAS model to show 116.6 as the most U/S and 12.94 as the most D/S XS in both the drawing and the table?
Thanks!
Flow direction in Civil 3D is from 0+12.94 (U/S) to 0+116.6 (D/S) (Fig 1). Flow direction arrow in the drawing in HEC-RAS geometric editor (Fig 3) seems to be consistent with Civil 3D (left to right, 0+12.94 (U/S) to 0+116.6 (D/S)). However, the stationing seems to be reflecting the Civil 3D set up which is awkward for HEC-RAS given the flow n HEC-RAS is always from higher stationing to lower. The issue is more than just cosmetic - table for reach length confirms that the most upstream station is 116.6 and the most downstream is 12.94, which is in contradiction with the reach arrow in the drawing.
I have tried to reverse the alignment stationing in Civil 3D (Fig 2), and created a new .geo file but the drawing and table data in HEC RAS are unchanged. I have also tried to manually change the statioing of the XSs in the .geo file. That was disastrous as in the table, there was no value between the top row 116.6 and the next downstream XS, and there was a value for the bottom row 12.94. Any thoughts as to how to get the HEC RAS model to show 116.6 as the most U/S and 12.94 as the most D/S XS in both the drawing and the table?
Thanks!