Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Clarification about moment formula for EN 1993-1-8

ViaParadise

Structural
Aug 22, 2024
2
I'm designing a pin connection where there will be a large clearance between the inner and outer plates to accomodate movement. However, it's now being solely controlled by the pin bending given the distance between supports (outside edges of outer plates). This is because the clearance between plates, c, is counted 4 times as opposed to twice. Does anyone know why the gap between plates is double counted? For reference the page is 37 (39 in the pdf linked).https://www.phd.eng.br/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/en.1993.1.8.2005-1.pdf 1736888201449.png
 
Solution
Summing moments about the center-
Loads are distributed along the thicknesses, not point loads.
So moment at the center is F/2*(b/2 + c + a/2)- F/2 * b/4 = F * (b/8 + c/2 + a/4) = F/8 * (b + 4c + 2a)
So they're not double-counting the gap, they just have the formula arranged in such a way that the coefficient happens to be 4.
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Summing moments about the center-
Loads are distributed along the thicknesses, not point loads.
So moment at the center is F/2*(b/2 + c + a/2)- F/2 * b/4 = F * (b/8 + c/2 + a/4) = F/8 * (b + 4c + 2a)
So they're not double-counting the gap, they just have the formula arranged in such a way that the coefficient happens to be 4.
 
Solution
Summing moments about the center-
Loads are distributed along the thicknesses, not point loads.
So moment at the center is F/2*(b/2 + c + a/2)- F/2 * b/4 = F * (b/8 + c/2 + a/4) = F/8 * (b + 4c + 2a)
So they're not double-counting the gap, they just have the formula arranged in such a way that the coefficient happens to be 4.
Thank you, I was making the mistake of assuming point loads centered on the plates. If anyone seeing this runs into the same issue confusing themselves, here's a convenient bending moment diagram I found online from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0143974X22006228
1736891919006.png
 

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor