Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Does ANSI/ASME 31.3 and 31.8 have some thing like UCS 85

Status
Not open for further replies.

bmoorthy

Mechanical
May 29, 2003
457
I have to genrate some procurement specificaions for material.

Since i am more familiar with ASME sec VIII i tend to compare notes and find lots of situations are treated differently in Piping in comparision to vessel (Which is understandable). Having understood this, we do not want to miss out some thing critical (Yes we are sending few experienced people for 31.3 study). In the mean time we have procurement pressures and have to deliver few spec.

We do not want to mess things up which will have long term effect and involve testing, neither we want to use consultant for we will loose out the experience gained by this process.

Now for the situation

We have 10" sch 160 pipes API 5L X 60 grades and API 5 L X 65 grades and some A 333 Gr 6 and A 106 Gr b and some A 671 and A 672 of different sizes

Where as few Process lines require heat treatment by the virtue of thickness some do not have PWHT.

The API 5 L Grades are the tricky ones

We need to PWHT joints at 593 deg c. Some people have expressed concers that API 5L X grades physical properties alters after PWHT. hence this question.

Are there some provisions similar to UCS 56 In ANSI 31.3 or 31.8.



 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

I'm not a piping guy, but I am a consultant and your consultant comment caught my attention. If you feel that using a consultant will cause you to loose out on some learning experience... why don't you engage the consultant to teach you? Let the consultant help you get up the learning curve faster and without the possibility of making the typical rookie mistakes? You said you have time pressures, so that might be a reasonable approach to getting there more quickly. Consultants are not usually smarter than you are, but they have the advantage of having made most of their mistakes already and have learned from it.

Steve Braune
Tank Industry Consultants
 
bmoorthy;
I would agree with SteveBraune. You need to have outside expertise to provide guidance in drafting these material procurement specifications, and to work with your materials engineers regarding ASME B31.3/31.8.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor