Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

How old is this quote?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I found a passage is a book I've been reading that is a perfect example of "the more things change the more they stay the same." Anybody want to venture a guess as to how old this passage might be?

In recent years the complexity of relay problems has increased immeasurably with the expansion and interconnection of power systems. Many large companies have found it necessary to revise completely their major relay systems. To meet the more involved operating conditions, relays must be fundamentally more accurate; applications by the method of complete short-circuit studies for steady state and, in special cases, transient conditions must be made. Field tests must be carefully made, and attention must be given to the characteristics of auxiliary devices, current transformers, potential devices, etc. In brief, all errors entering into the operation of the relays should be thoroughly understood and corrected, or allowance made where complete correction is not practical.
 
davidbeach
I'll guess 30 years!
I particularly find the very last statement interesting:
"or allowance made where complete correction is not practical."
Yikes! what kind of allowances can you make for relay errors, oh ya! add more relays...

interesting post

pennpoint
 
I'm guessing either around 1954 or around 1966...
 
This sounds like fun!

I'll guess 1920

TTFN
 
I'll stake a pint on it dating from sometime in the 1930's.
 
ScottyUK, you did well. The quote is from "Relay Systems" by Monseth and Robinson, (c) 1935. The first two sentences of the Preface of the book reads: "This volume has been developed from a series of articles in the Electric Journal written by the authors in 1930, 1931, and 1932. The original presentation has been completely rewritten, expanded, and rearranged to include a complete treatise on the theory and application of relay systems.

So whether from the 1930 - 32 work or from the 1935 rewrite, the quote is about 70 years old.

How far back do the CO and IAC relays go? Was the complete revision of relaying systems mentioned the original application of the those relays?
 
Wow! I was really off.
Ok ScottyUK! I owe you a pint but you'll have to come to So. California to collect.

L8R
 
Suggestion: It appears that the relays at the question are protective relays.
Some telephone exchanges used to have millions of telephone switching relays. Perhaps, the London, England, telephone exchange (main?) had many millions of relays. There was a book written about those relays covering just the relay contact theory and practice.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor