ferguson22
Civil/Environmental
Is it possible to use hydraulic ram pumps to divert stormwater up and over a levee? Army corp of engineers will not let us alter the levee at all (ie. bore through levee to install culvert)
Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Hydraulic Ram pump for stormwater drainage 1
- Thread starter ferguson22
- Start date
- Status
-
1
- #2
btrueblood
Mechanical
If you have sufficient velocity head to operate the ram, then yes, it is possible for a ram pump to deliver almost any desired head. Obviously, the flow rate will diminish as the head required increases.
- Thread starter
- #4
ferguson22
Civil/Environmental
yes ordinary pumps would be the best possible alternative but our funding is limited. My idea is to collect the stormwater into a vertical drainage pipe and use the head created to power ram pumps. I am having some trouble figuring out how deep these vertical collection pipes would need to be in order to pump the water over the levee
btrueblood
Mechanical
Contact pump manufacturers.
One basic problem is that a ram pump bypasses more water than it pumps, so if you are thinking of dewatering the area behind the levee...well, you'll pump some fraction of the inflowing storm water, but you won't pump all of it, without an external power source.
One basic problem is that a ram pump bypasses more water than it pumps, so if you are thinking of dewatering the area behind the levee...well, you'll pump some fraction of the inflowing storm water, but you won't pump all of it, without an external power source.
What you need is a "water mover"; drainage pumps are typically very high flow, very low head. There are entire classes of pumps designed exactly for this application.
These have high specific speed impellers and depending on the head will either be of axial or mixed-flow design. Usually if the head is under 15 or so feet, you would use an axial flow, or propeller pump. There are designs to accommodate flows up to several 100K gpm. They are essentially a propeller spinning inside the discharge pipe.
The very expensive types have cast iron bowls with liners and cast impellers and are only made by a handfull of manufacturers: Cascade, Johnston (now Sulzer-Johnston), Floway, Flowserve, and maybe one or two more.
If you are on low budget (as all municipal apps are), there are several companies that make "fabricated" pumps of this style. This simply means that the bowl and impeller are fabricated/welded using carbon steel as stock. These are much cheaper and quicker to deliver (no patterns, no castings, no huge machinery to machine castings, etc.).
The design element of these pumps that is most crucial is the bearing arrangement and how they are sealed from the sand/abrasives that they will see. Everyone does it different and this is what the Corps will want to look at for design approval.
DOn't know if they're still around, but LoLift used to make a very good fabbed prop pump for this service. There are several smaller shops that will build these to suit custom applications.
Just google propeller pumps or axial flow pumps and see what comes up.
I am not aware of hydraulic ram design pumps used for this service.
These have high specific speed impellers and depending on the head will either be of axial or mixed-flow design. Usually if the head is under 15 or so feet, you would use an axial flow, or propeller pump. There are designs to accommodate flows up to several 100K gpm. They are essentially a propeller spinning inside the discharge pipe.
The very expensive types have cast iron bowls with liners and cast impellers and are only made by a handfull of manufacturers: Cascade, Johnston (now Sulzer-Johnston), Floway, Flowserve, and maybe one or two more.
If you are on low budget (as all municipal apps are), there are several companies that make "fabricated" pumps of this style. This simply means that the bowl and impeller are fabricated/welded using carbon steel as stock. These are much cheaper and quicker to deliver (no patterns, no castings, no huge machinery to machine castings, etc.).
The design element of these pumps that is most crucial is the bearing arrangement and how they are sealed from the sand/abrasives that they will see. Everyone does it different and this is what the Corps will want to look at for design approval.
DOn't know if they're still around, but LoLift used to make a very good fabbed prop pump for this service. There are several smaller shops that will build these to suit custom applications.
Just google propeller pumps or axial flow pumps and see what comes up.
I am not aware of hydraulic ram design pumps used for this service.
- Status
Similar threads