JISG3131 SPHC VS ASTM A36

[dursosono]

Does material JISG3131-SPHC and ASTM A36 are equivalent?
Here, equivalent is limited to mechanical properties, chemical composition and others testing requirements not for Code or Standard judgment

 

[metengr]

For your intentions, you need to obtain a copy of the JIS G3131 and compare to a copy of ASTM A 36.

 

[dursosono]

meterng,

I have tried to compare both of them, but I can't find both are "typical" material based on chem analysis & mech properties. There some properties different to much.
Can you help me to determined both are "equivalent"

 

[metengr]

dursosono;
What is the application where you want to substitute the A36 for G3131? The attachment you provided is not complete with the necessary information.

 

[JoeTank]

If your inquiry is for API-650 tank construction, please refer to Section 4.2.5 and Table 4-2. Your answer lies there.

Joe Tank