USFEngineer
Structural
- Dec 12, 2006
- 33
I have discussed this question with other engineers in my office and I can't seem to get a reasonable answer that sits well with me.
So I figured that many of you could provide me with a logically answer that has proof to it other than this is the way I have been doing it for years.
I recently was designing a masonry screenwall to go around some mechanical equipment outside. In ASCE 7-05 provisions for screenwalls and signs there is one equation for a force (F) in lbs. What is the purpose of calculating that Force when in the equation F = q(h)*G*C(f)*A(s) you are first finding the uniform velocity pressure. From a design perspective it makes sense to calculate a uniform velocity pressure q(h) or q(z) in psf [and from my understanding q(h)=q(z)] to find the moment to design it as a cantilevered wall. Once you have the moment then you are able to design the foundation for overturning.
I am not seeing why there is a need to find a Force (F) in lbs when you could have an infinite length of screen wall. So that would mean you would have an infinite area A(s).
What good does it do? I am probably missing something here so any help would be greatful. It is Sunday morning and this has been bothering me since Friday.
Thanks in advance.
Andrew.
So I figured that many of you could provide me with a logically answer that has proof to it other than this is the way I have been doing it for years.
I recently was designing a masonry screenwall to go around some mechanical equipment outside. In ASCE 7-05 provisions for screenwalls and signs there is one equation for a force (F) in lbs. What is the purpose of calculating that Force when in the equation F = q(h)*G*C(f)*A(s) you are first finding the uniform velocity pressure. From a design perspective it makes sense to calculate a uniform velocity pressure q(h) or q(z) in psf [and from my understanding q(h)=q(z)] to find the moment to design it as a cantilevered wall. Once you have the moment then you are able to design the foundation for overturning.
I am not seeing why there is a need to find a Force (F) in lbs when you could have an infinite length of screen wall. So that would mean you would have an infinite area A(s).
What good does it do? I am probably missing something here so any help would be greatful. It is Sunday morning and this has been bothering me since Friday.
Thanks in advance.
Andrew.