Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Moving into management too quickly?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Guest0527211403

Mechanical
Apr 24, 2004
1,125
For a backgrounder, see my post thread732-255928

More background info:
I graduated with my BSME last April, and I'm at around 8 months into my first post-graduate engineering position. Prior to that, I sustained myself through university as a CAD designer/drafter, with the career plan that I would mature into a qualified design engineer.

Fast forward to the present. The bids we were working on a few months ago both came through and ended up in the company's largest contracts to date. Very good news for all of us.

Now that we are into the contracts, I'm now in a position where all I do is write reports that go back to the client. This is due in part to the fact that all of the other engineers come from a non-english speaking background, and I'm one of the few at the company who has demonstrated the ability to write technical documents.

I do like the experience that I'm getting, as it's exposing me to a new side of engineering that is outside of the regular "nuts and bolts" type work that I was focused on as a student. In terms of management, I'm learning quite a lot about dealing with people on a variety of levels, be it professionally or personally.

However, the work that I'm presently doing for 40+ hours a week is completely outside of the "design and development" activities here. I'm spending most of my time interpreting the reports of the other engineers and churning them out in proper english. I'm not being given any opportunities to develop my own designs. This is largely due to the fact that I'm overloaded with writing tasks and (I'm told) that learning the finer details of the work that we do is "not an effective use of my time".

In a recent planning meeting, it was made clear that my role for the forseeable future is one of report writing only. I'm shut out of concept and design meetings because I have "other tasks". When I try to communicate with and learn from the other staff who are involved in the design, the language barrier between us makes it very difficult for them to transfer the technical knowledge necessary to make me a better engineer.

So now I'm finding myself in an awkward position. As a recent grad, I know that I have a lot to learn about the technical aspects of the work that we do, and that the only way to really gain this knowledge is to be involved in the design cycle. I have full intentions of becoming a P.Eng, so I'm worried that what I'm doing now is not putting me on the right track. I've tried to raise these concerns with my supervising engineer (who is also the company owner), and he refuses to talk to me about the matter, citing the fact that I have other work to be doing.

Has anyone been in a similar position before? I'm still waiting for my boss to give me a chance to sit down with him and discuss. Until then, I'd like to get some fresh perspectives on the situation.

Thanks in advance
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Does this writing phase have an end?

How are you supposed to write an accurate report without tie-in to what you're writing about?

I wouldn't call this "moving into management". I'd call this "being turned into a tech writer".

I turned myself into a tech writer on purpose for a while (because the PTB weren't smart enough to see that one was needed), but that was for a project with a defined endpoint. (And I was still expected to keep up with normal engineering duties.)

I'd tell you get the hell out to a place that recognizes your skill and your value and your need for professional development, but weren't you already told that in the other thread?

Hg

Eng-Tips policies: faq731-376
 
They are not concerned about your future, but you should be. Consequently, don't be concerned about them either.

Look elsewhere without telling them (present economy considered here), and jump at the chance to practice actual engineering at another firm, gaining experience that will qualify you toward your PE.

Expect a tantrum when you give your notice. Just smile and tell the boss to grow up as you walk away. He probably will not understand what you mean.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto: KISS
Motivation: Don't ask
 
Oh, and FYI...

You arepresently not in management or anything close to it. They are just using your technical writing skills in English and have pigeonholed you...permanently if you let them.

It's a dead end job. Pitty the person that replaces you.

Mike McCann
MMC Engineering
Motto: KISS
Motivation: Don't ask
 
Admittedly, the thread title is misleading. The company owner equates "report writing" with "management" because that is what he used to do, so somehow I've developed the same association in my mind.

Hg said:
I'd tell you get the hell out to a place that recognizes your skill and your value and your need for professional development, but weren't you already told that in the other thread?

Indeed, and I've been sending my resume out ever since. Until something better comes along, I want to do everything in my power to improve my current situation.
 
Your situation won't improve as long as you are the only native English writer/speaker there that can think. You've only been there for 8 months, I wouldn't think of it as a dead end job, especially for your first stint of employment. Just know the chances of you getting into anything similar to design and engineering is not going to happen, this doesn't mean that you aren't gaining valuable experience now. Keep the resumes flowing and leave when the opportunity arises.

"Art without engineering is dreaming; Engineering without art is calculating."

Have you read faq731-376 to make the best use of these Forums?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor