Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Parts wont rebuild 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

LesPaul82

Mechanical
Oct 3, 2003
109
6 parts in my assembly will not rebuild. They were built in the assembly (the edges are dimensioned from other parts) and always have the rebuild symbol beside them. I can't open the drawing for it either. When loading it gets stuck right at the end but it doesn't lock up my computer. The task manager shows Solidworks as 'running'. I've tried it on other computers but it still doesn't work.

Sean Nutley
Carmanah Design and Manufacturing
Vancouver, BC, Canada
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

If you have not saved the parts, save them now. Open each part in SolidWorks, then open your assembly and do a reload.
I am just throwing out ideas.
Hope this helps. Good luck.


Bradley
 
Thanks. Actually I just suppressed the parts then opened the drawing. That worked but the parts still need to be reloaded.

Sean Nutley
Carmanah Design and Manufacturing
Vancouver, BC, Canada
 
If a Ctrl-Q doesn't work (per Tick's Suggestion) Then to me, it sounds like you have circular reference of in-contexted geometry. The only fix is to break the links or some of the links and redo your in-contexted geometry. But this time pay close attetion to what is incontexted and how many times you in-context what. In the past I used to put a piece of paper next to me on my desk and write down what I in-contexted so that a way I don't get confused later.

Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP [borg2]
CSWP.jpg

faq731-376
 
Good idea. Thanks that worked. I just broke the part down to its original sketch then re-did the extrude.

Sean Nutley
Carmanah Design and Manufacturing
Vancouver, BC, Canada
 
Not to be critical of anybody's way of doing CAD, but this seems to be a clear cut case of how Top Down Modeling can cause problems when design parameters are not set.

I'm currently using Pro/E which provides an option called Skeleton Models. These Skeleton Models are critical design interfaces which control design intent especially in Top-Down assembly techniques.

I use to only adhere to the Bottoms-up approach until I started using Pro/E. Because I encountered some sloppy modeling techniques by a previous engineer, which corrupted a lot of data taking weeks to recover. I guess I can't stress capturing design intent from the beginning of a project. In my humble opinion Healthy MCAD data can only be achieved when strict design guidlines are followed anything less you're asking for trouble.


 
I have used Top-Down in SW for years. you have to have clear idea of what you want to do with before you begin. I have posted my Assembly best practices at my website. Most of what is posted there is from my experiences with Top-down in SW.


Regards,

Scott Baugh, CSWP [borg2]
CSWP.jpg

faq731-376
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor