pipe surge analysis software

[ceseng]

I know Benley Hammer and H20 Surge, do you guys have any idea, which one is better?

I know H2O Surge is AutoCAD based, which makes model building easier. While Bentley Hammer is stand alone.

any comments are welcome.

 

[RWF7437]

http://hhwq.blogspot.com/

 

[stanier]

I have used AFT's Impulse for many years and find the support second to none.

You might like to read the attached file and then check out the two programs nominated. I am not a fan of Hammer as it did not model check valves or air valves very well when i last looked at it.