Is there an order to go in when constructing sheet metal parts? I get my part modeled and then have problems when I get to the drawing view and spend a long time folding/undfolding creating unfolds, watching my hole patterns or mirrors not function any longer. It has something to do with the patterns referencing the flat pattern and then it not being there when folded but I have to have it flat to dimension holes.
Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet
Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals
-
Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Procedure for sheet metal
- Thread starter EaZiE
- Start date
CorBlimeyLimey
Mechanical
Basically ...
Create the formed shape
Unfold (only where necessary)
Add the holes
Fold
Can you post a problem part for review?
Create the formed shape
Unfold (only where necessary)
Add the holes
Fold
Can you post a problem part for review?
- Thread starter
- #3
I was working on a u-shaped part and was patterning holes from one side to the other in flat, then when I folded it they would dissapear w/ errors. Anyway, I found a workaround by just keeping it in fold and extending the first hole through both walls - so it's basically one hole. For some reason SW likes that as it works in flat as well. I don't think it likes when you reference and edge in flat that will eventually be folded (it will be missing). Sheet metal feature seems very finicky.
EaZiE,
Usually, I start off my sheet metal parts are regular parts. There always is the possibility I will convert it to a machined part. At the end of the design, I rip the corners and convert to sheet metal.
On the drawing, I do not unfold the part unless I have to. The flat layout is the fabricator's job.
--
JHG
Usually, I start off my sheet metal parts are regular parts. There always is the possibility I will convert it to a machined part. At the end of the design, I rip the corners and convert to sheet metal.
On the drawing, I do not unfold the part unless I have to. The flat layout is the fabricator's job.
--
JHG
^This.
For sheet metal specifically, I build a block model of the shape I want and the use the "Convert to Sheet metal" Option; choosing a base-line-face. and then the corresponding corners for folds. Doing it this way
gives you very tight dimensioning and quickly letting you switch from inside to outside dimensioning. Mark all holes on the this model and let Solidworks do the work for unfolding.
For sheet metal specifically, I build a block model of the shape I want and the use the "Convert to Sheet metal" Option; choosing a base-line-face. and then the corresponding corners for folds. Doing it this way
gives you very tight dimensioning and quickly letting you switch from inside to outside dimensioning. Mark all holes on the this model and let Solidworks do the work for unfolding.
As I have been learning here lately Sheet metal designing is a science. Anyone can make it in Solidworks, but what get in the real world it's not always the same thing. We have been using Bend tables to control the Bending K-factor to get the parts in SW to real world components. If that's not an issue then what we do is we usually make it in a partial formed shape either in a U shape or and L shape and added Edge Flanges as needed. When I need to add hole and varying on the requirement I will usually flatten the SM part using the Unfold icon. When done I will use the Fold icon and re fold the part. Whatever you do not build any features after the Flat-Pattern feature, because when you flatten the part your features will be suppressed, which I assume is what is happening for you.
Other times I will use the Convert To Sheet metal. I think there is a time and a place for either "Convert to SM" and/or "Base Flange". When place your model in the drawing that is when you get your Flat-pattern configuration in the part... strange I know and agree, but its been like this for years. When you place a view into the drawing you get the option on the right and on the left to select Flat Pattern. Drag that view into the drawing and that is how you get the Flat Pattern Config.
Folding and unfolding is simple when you find the Fold and unfold SM features. I have showed this to a former employer and they thought it like God gave them a special gift... haha.
Anyway I hope that helps,
Scott Baugh, CSWP![[pc2]](/data/assets/smilies/pc2.gif "[pc2] [pc2]")
Gryphon Environmental
Other times I will use the Convert To Sheet metal. I think there is a time and a place for either "Convert to SM" and/or "Base Flange". When place your model in the drawing that is when you get your Flat-pattern configuration in the part... strange I know and agree, but its been like this for years. When you place a view into the drawing you get the option on the right and on the left to select Flat Pattern. Drag that view into the drawing and that is how you get the Flat Pattern Config.
Folding and unfolding is simple when you find the Fold and unfold SM features. I have showed this to a former employer and they thought it like God gave them a special gift... haha.
Anyway I hope that helps,
Scott Baugh, CSWP
Gryphon Environmental
faq731-376
DiegoLGraves
Mechanical
I start with a base flange feature, either the primary profile of the part or the primary face. Then add edge flanges or other features using the sheet metal tools. Many of the needed hole features can be included in the edge flanges and remain well behaved when revising material, thickness, bend radii, etc. My back ground is primarily sheet metal fabrication so the SW tools makes sense functionally, and I have been modelling sheet metal in SW for 17 years. The software tools are robust when used as intended. If you find yourself having to add too many steps in the feature tree, or lookind for work-rounds you may want to review the help files for the sheet metal tools. I'm in that same situation when working with swoopy parts using surfaces, having to go back and review the standard tools and not add features just to tweak something.
Diego
Diego
- Thread starter
- #9
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question