Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!

Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!

  • Congratulations TugboatEng on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

quiz - no-load losses, load-varying losses, and location of peak effic

Status
Not open for further replies.

electricpete

Electrical
Joined
May 4, 2001
Messages
16,774
Location
US
This question is just for fun.

Assuming that motor losses L can be expressed as Total losses L = A + BX^2
where:
- A is a component which is constant with respect to load (no-load losses)
- B*X^2 = a load-varying component which varies according to load squared
- X=load expressed as fraction of rated load
- B = the value of load-varying losses when load is at rated load.

Let's say I tell you that the peak efficiency for a motor occurs at rated load, can you tell me the ratio of A/B?

What if the peak efficiency for a motor occurs at 80% rated load, can you tell me the ratio of A/B?

I will share the answer if no-one responds. I just thought it would be more fun to challenge you guys to figure it out. It does give a small insight into the significance of location of peak power and its relationship to no-load and load varying losses (within the bounds of the assumption).

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
 
Phew! Quite a long time since I differentiated a quotient of two functions...

Setting Efficiency = P/(P+L), differentiating and solving for zero gives me A = Bx^2. And that tells me A has to be equal to B if the relation shall hold for all x. So, I guess that A/B = 1.

It is close to midnight over here. So I leave the other part for toworrow. (Hoping for someone else to do it over night).
 
I agree with Skosgurra, the maximum efficiency is when A=Bx^2

since x = motor current and assuming Ifl = 1.0 pu

For 100% current: A=B or A/B=1
for 80% current: A=B*.8^2 and A/B=0.64
 
Good morning!

Thanks aolalde. Yes, of course.

In the light of the new day, I see that I should not have said "hold for all x" but rather have plugged in a "1" for x. The consequence of "all x" would have been A/B = 0, which is wrong.
 
Yup, I should have known it would be easy for you guys.

I thought it was an interesting result.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
 
Out of curiosity I tried out the formula using an example motor:


From the 0% load point: A = sqrt(3)*v*i*pf = sqrt(3)*460*32.2*0.0737 = 1891 watts

From the 100% load point: B = Pelec - Pout = sqrt(3)*v*i*pf - 100hp
B = (sqrt(3)*460*114*0.873) watts - (100hp * 745.7) w / hp = 4723.5 watts

As solved above:
A = B*Xpeak^2
Xpeak = sqrt(A/B) = sqrt(1891/4723) = 63%

Page 1 gives efficiency at 25,50,75,100 and 125%. Page 2 (curve 3) gives a curve of efficiency. Looking at these curves I would say peak efficiency is probably somewhat higher than 63%. It must either be an error in my calculations or deviation from the assumed form of the loss curve. Is there any error you guys can see?

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
 
I saw one error already.

B = Pelec-Pout-A

Let me try to recalculate it with Pa

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
 
B=Pelec - Pout-A
B=(sqrt(3)*460*114*0.873)watts-(100hp*745.7wattts/hp)-1891watts
B =2832. watts

Xpeak = sqrt(A/B) = sqrt(1891/2832)=82%

This looks more consistent with the efficiency curve and tabulated data.


=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
 
Interesting and refreshing excersise, pete.

A friend asked me about the general shape of the efficiency vs load curve last week. All I could say was that I thought that the peak efficiency probably was at about three quarter load. I will see that guy tomorrow - and I will inform him till he wishes he never asked... And I will bring those data sheets from Rockwell, too!
 
For posterity, I will write out the way I solved it.

Start with skogsgurra's maximize efficiency = P/(P+L)
where P = Pout =X*P100 and where P100 is rated output power

This should be the same as minimizing the inverse.
ie. minimize 1/effic. = (L+P)/P = L/P + P/P = L/P+1
The 1 is a constant and doesnt affect the minimization.
=> minimize L/P

minimize: L/P = [A + B*X^2] / [X * P100%] = [A/X + B*X] / P100
Since P100 is a constant with respect to X, it doesn't affect the minimization.
=> minimize [A/X + B*X]

Set derivative =0
d/dx{[A/X + B*X]} = [-A*X^-2 + B] = 0
A*X^-2 = B
A = BX^2
Xpeak=sqrt(A/B)

I didn't bother to check 2nd derivative since we already know the shape of the curve.
OK, back to some real work now. Thanks for listening.

=====================================
Eng-tips forums: The best place on the web for engineering discussions.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top