Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Skirt material for stainless steel vertical vessel 2

Status
Not open for further replies.

sksmechanical

Mechanical
Feb 18, 2010
36
Looking for advice on what material to specify for skirt for SA-376 TP304 vessel in cold service.
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

I specify that structural materials that are welded to the pressure containing envelop shall be fabricated of materials that essentially the same as the head or shell to which they are attached. Consequently, I'd use SA240 Grade 304 plate material.

Regardless, you would want to make sure that whatever material you used, that the skirt material was suitable for the MDMT of the vessel for at least a distance equal to that which it could be affected by the vessel temperature. Figuring out this distance could be a bit of a problem so it's probably just easier to use 304 plate for the whole thing.
 
I have seen SS vessels with a ring of the same material welded to the bottom head, to form the top of the skirt, and CS plate used below that. Depends on the size, number, as to whether that's economical or not, and whether long term corrosion protection is an issue.
 
low temp a333 is the worst case. you could use a333 for a foot or two then switch to a105 or grade B pipe for pipe diameter vessels if you believe the insulation is poor.
 
What's your definition of Cold service (-45 C, -101 C or colder) ? A333 is rated to -45 C.
 
SKS....

What is the pressure vessel size ?

Is a skirt really necessary? Its usually expensive and only commonly used on tall distilation columns where there is no other choice.

I have always viewed a skirt design as inferior to a multiple leg design.

Additionally, implementation of load cells in the deign is very difficult when compared th a legged design,

Good discussion on legged design for vertical axis pressure vessels in the Bednar text (Pressure Vessel Design Handbook)

My opinion only

-MJC

 
Petrochemical and Oil & Gas has always had a preference for skirt designs. If you look at the Process Industry Practices (PIP) they allow leg designs under only certain limited situations if I recall correctly.
 
PIP specify that the support should be SS for the portion of 2*(Rt)^0.5 but not less than 300 mm (12"). The lower portion can then be CS or low-alloy steel.
 
I didn't realize PIP had specified a distance for the SS portion. Good to know.
 
Unless the skirts get very long, we generally just make the whole skirt stainless to keep from painting the carbon steel portion of skirt.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor