Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Top-down design in catia 3

Status
Not open for further replies.

loki3000

Mechanical
Sep 29, 2009
652
How is it done?
at college we've learned only about the traditional way of doing things - part -> asm

I'd like the kind of modelling where you build parts similar to the solidworks philosophy - in-context or the dimensions of a part are dependent (or not necesseraly - at least the same) then those of the part next to it...

so, i open a product and insert a base part. then what?
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

I think top down and bottom up are one of those things invented by academics. In reality people use a combination of both strategies, making some parts in isolation and some in the context of other parts.

In CATIA you have the freedom to do whatever best suits your requirements. You can build all your parts in isolation and then assemble them. Or you can build parts in an assembly where you just use the other parts as scenery and build around them. Or you can build parts in an assembly where you import isolated pieces of geometry from the other part in the assembly and don't maintain any links, relying on the replace functions to update when required. Or you can work fully contexturally where geometry is imported and maintains associativity with the source geometry. Or you can mix an match.

For example I might start bottom up and make the basic form of a couple of major components, prehaps a skelton. Place them in an assembly so I have some context for the mating parts. I then build a number of other components in my assembly but don't have any associativity. I might then add a sub product, include the skeleton again and build some associative parts but limit the context to the sub product (in context associativity works well where the design intent is clear, I use it for hoses (a hose goes from a->b and never does anything else))

To work in context in a product, just double click on the part object in the tree. link creation is determined by the options you have set (tools->options->infrastructure->Part infrastructure). I also strongly recommend understanding and using publications before creating links. I also recommend you find out about the skeleton method as this is an excelent way of structuring your model and managing the links between objects (avoid the spiders web of links it will cause you pain and be slow. Be very careful adding constraint to contexturally driven parts - you cannot position something where its position is defined contexturally)

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor