Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations Toost on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Underground VS Overhead Transmission lines

Status
Not open for further replies.

patrick7

Electrical
Jan 13, 2006
36
Differences in protection systems and practices of the protection on overhead vs undergroud transmission lines.

any thought anyone.
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Protection systems are identical except for auto reclose, you dont auto reclose on a u/g system as cables dont suffer from transient faults
 
In my experience, overhead systems use a combination of fast reclosers and slower sectionalizers as protection and to isolate faults. The reclosers auto reclose as the sectionalizers wait to see if the fault clears. If the fault doesnt clear, then the sectionalizer, then operates and isolates the system.

Underground switchgear is very different in design from the type that is mounted on a pole. In my experience the underground devices did not auto reclose. I'm not sure if they ever communicated with sectionalizers or not.
 
For a given fault value, would overhead or underground suffer more damage? If the cables travel in a common pipe, maybe protection would need to be faster so you don't damage nearby cables?
 
Turbinegen
Reclosers & sectionalisers are typically used on distribution lines were as a delayed auto reclose DAR 15-30second is used on transmission lines. Speed of protection operation on both ug & o/h systems is fast providing the fault is in zone, this minimises system disturbance
 
thank you all so much for your replies.
 
Fault in cables is a permanent fault, which means you have to dig and repair the cable. Fault in OH lines can be transient faults, that's why it is worth to attempt to reclose automatically.
On the other end, faults on cables are more rare.

HV cables are generally much shorter than OH lines, this means that often people use differential relays to protect them, instead of distance protection.
But statistics are statistics... everything should be analyzed for itself.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor