Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations MintJulep on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Weight of Pressure Vessel F&D Head: 1
- Thread starter farhan007
- Start date
-
1
- #2
There is no mystery here (unlike for semiellipsoidal heads): the geometry is well-defined and is mathmetically tractable (unlike for those semiellipsoidal heads where you run into elliptic integrals, which are difficult to solve. Then again, I just got out of bed and maybe those SE heads aren't as bad as I am thinking at the moment...nope, they are that bad, just looked at my spreadsheets).
Anyway, F&D is simply another term for a torispherical head, which is comprised of the knuckle and the spherically dished top. You can derive an exact expression for the arc length of material along a cross section, then use Pappus’ theorem to find the volume, then use volume x density to find the weight. This is probably a good exercise is geometric layout (finding the angle of intersection, the centroid, etc) for a young engineer.
Then again, I found this thread in eng-tips by using Google a discussion about head weights. Although the expression given for weight of the torispherical head is approximate only and will not be as accurate as the one you will derive. Or you might try Google to locate more information. But I guarantee that deriving the formula on your own will have its own rewards.
Anyway, F&D is simply another term for a torispherical head, which is comprised of the knuckle and the spherically dished top. You can derive an exact expression for the arc length of material along a cross section, then use Pappus’ theorem to find the volume, then use volume x density to find the weight. This is probably a good exercise is geometric layout (finding the angle of intersection, the centroid, etc) for a young engineer.
Then again, I found this thread in eng-tips by using Google a discussion about head weights. Although the expression given for weight of the torispherical head is approximate only and will not be as accurate as the one you will derive. Or you might try Google to locate more information. But I guarantee that deriving the formula on your own will have its own rewards.
Another way and i think much easier one.
Almost every head manufacturer has formula for estimating "disc diameter"(which eventually became head after forming process). Calculate disc diameter then find it's weight. Plain, simple algebra
Antonius: KBS:
Almost every head manufacturer has formula for estimating "disc diameter"(which eventually became head after forming process). Calculate disc diameter then find it's weight. Plain, simple algebra
Antonius: KBS:
I was having the same issue with weights of F&D heads until I used the links posted above by Hakkik. Thanks
Wrote a excel and verified cals by Solidworks2010.
Here is the but.....
I assign the material in SW2010 as 316L(SG:8.0) which worked out the same as the excel, but if you are using material such as C22(SG:8.69) which has a density which is nearly 10% heavier then 316l grade on a large vessel need to consider the difference in density.
Any Suggestions??
Niall
Wrote a excel and verified cals by Solidworks2010.
Here is the but.....
I assign the material in SW2010 as 316L(SG:8.0) which worked out the same as the excel, but if you are using material such as C22(SG:8.69) which has a density which is nearly 10% heavier then 316l grade on a large vessel need to consider the difference in density.
Any Suggestions??
Niall
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question
