Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations GregLocock on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

What valve brand do you recommend ?????

Status
Not open for further replies.

xtal01

Mechanical
Mar 15, 2012
143
So I ordered my "Brand Hydraulics" flow valve.

I now need to order three more hydraulic valves ( plus a couple of check valve and such ). They need to be spool type solenoid valves ( two port, two position ... blocked and flow ), 24 VDC ... two N.O and one N.C. I am going to flow about 15 GPM max.

I went to the "Hydraulic Force" web site .... just because I had used them a few years back ... and looked up a cartridge valve with a manifold ( I thought I bought them as one last time but it looks like I must buy the two parts separately ).

I was very surprised to read the "internal leak rate: 25 cu in / min @ 3500 psi"

Is this normal????

First, what is meant by "internal leak rate"? I am assuming this is the amount of oil that will leak from the "high" side to the "low" side.

To me this means that if I have a cylinder with an area of 7 sq inches, it will drop just over 3" in 1 minute????

I know I won't have 3500 psi on it when it is up holding a load ( I am thinking it will be more like 1500 psi ), I still want a minimum leak so the load will drop the minimum possible over time.

Is there a better brand ( that is still "reasonable" priced ) I should look at or a different type of valve?

I have attached the hydraulic circuit.

Thanks .... Mike
 
 http://files.engineering.com/getfile.aspx?folder=acd2d049-a6e6-48d8-b93a-8283004d6ae7&file=LIFT_HYDR_FLOW_PATH.pdf
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Awesome!

Looking at the lock valve, they are designed for a double acting cylinder.

Since I have a single acting cylinder (using gravity to lower my lift), how can I hook this up in my circuit?

They mention a single lock but don't show an example of it or how it would hook up.

Thanks ..... Mike
 
Search for pilot operated check valve.
Compact Controls, Hydraforce, Sun Hydraulics, for example

Ted
 
I understand how the pilot check will work on a double acting cylinder. The "pressure" side will release the check on the side now connected to the tank. With no pressure on both sides, both sides are held by a check valve.

On my single acting cylinder, I am a bit confused.

I "load check" will hold fluid from going back through the circuit on the "power" side.

Because there is gravity down, there is nothing to release a piloted check on the lowering circuit.

In fact, I was going to go with a "poppet" type solenoid valve. They have an incredibly low leak rate ... 3 drops per min.

The only place this will not work is on the valve shown to the left of the circuit. It would work when the system is not energized ... so it would hold the load. I am worried that when lifting there will be higher pressure on the bottom of the valve and then it could bypass the flow control valve and flow directly to the cylinder.

Might be a dumb question but can I put two of these solenoid valves back to back with the check portion pointing in opposite directions?????

I'm sure others make very similar models but here is the ones I was looking at:
Thanks again ..... Mike
 
Kiwitom235 ....

Sorry didn't see your post, you must have been typing the same time I was.

This is exactly what I was looking for!

The valve I was worried about only has to flow in one direction ( during the lowering cycle ) but needs to block in both.

Fantastic!

Thanks so very much .... my wife says if I just had you guys move in for a week or two I could get caught up on all my projects!

Thanks again .... Mike

Just FYI .... Motion Industries quoted me almost $400 for the flow valve with 3-4 weeks delivery. The factory sent me to Brand Power Fluid ( their sister company ) .... $300 and in stock.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor