idly123
Structural
- Jun 12, 2002
- 96
Hi all,
i have a a 3 member frame an open rectangle(like a building frame).
In modelling the columns( vertical members) i use beam elements. one intresting thing is that , i can use only one beam element with 2 Dofs pernode( total of 2 nodes per element) to modell this . and thereby i can get the end moments. so total DOfs=2*2=4.
The same vertical memeber i can model using 10 beam elements with total Dofs=10*2=20.
although there is a refinement made i get the same value of the ened moments and reactions in modelling a vertical column frame member using beam elements.
1)why is it that we do not realize the effect of refinement in such a case??
2)does this always happen in a beam element. can u tell me a situation where in the effect of refinement is realized in the improved solution while using a beam element.
thanks for responses
regards
raj Raj
i have a a 3 member frame an open rectangle(like a building frame).
In modelling the columns( vertical members) i use beam elements. one intresting thing is that , i can use only one beam element with 2 Dofs pernode( total of 2 nodes per element) to modell this . and thereby i can get the end moments. so total DOfs=2*2=4.
The same vertical memeber i can model using 10 beam elements with total Dofs=10*2=20.
although there is a refinement made i get the same value of the ened moments and reactions in modelling a vertical column frame member using beam elements.
1)why is it that we do not realize the effect of refinement in such a case??
2)does this always happen in a beam element. can u tell me a situation where in the effect of refinement is realized in the improved solution while using a beam element.
thanks for responses
regards
raj Raj