Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Rotating shaft seal for keeping the sea water out at 10m depth

Status
Not open for further replies.

reconvolution

Bioengineer
Jun 6, 2010
11
Colleagues,

What are the techniques for sealing a small shaft like this one against water?
For a sense of scale, the outside diameter of the metal cylinder is around 50mm.
The purpose of this shaft is to turn a wiper that's attached directly to the shaft. (The photo doesn't show the wiper.)
The purpose of the seal is more to keep the sea out than to keep the grease in.

McVan_Analite_Turbidity_Probe_NEP9504G_a7wcya.jpg


I’m designing something similar. The diameter of the shaft will be between 3mm and 8mm (and can be designed larger if that would help with sealing). The rotation will be 120rpm. The pressure outside of the seal will be around 10m of water (15psi). Operating temperature between 0C and +40C. 8 months between replacement of seals desirable.

What sort of part would be used for a shaft seal in that situation?

Cheers,
- Nick
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Your life expectancy is reasonably short. I would investigate the type of seals used in gas spring applications. Pressurize you container to high pressure if possible and use the seal to keep the gas in. The gas pressure will keep the water out.

You'll need to find one without exposed metal backing.

They aren't designed for rotation but your surface speeds are very low so you'll likely be able to get away with it.
 
Here's a sketch for a dual O-ring seal and a sleeve bearing. Is this a sensible approach?

Assem1_20230904_wdjo3d.png
 
Is there a reason you insist on o-rings over lip seals?
 
TugboatEng said:
Is there a reason you insist on o-rings over lip seals?

I drew O-rings only because they seem to be easier for me to find. I'm not insisting on O-rings for fundamental technical reasons. Nor am I attached to O-rings emotionally.

Lip seals would be fine. I’m in the US, and I should have first world access to parts. But I have a hard time finding lip seals for 6mm [0.25 inch] shaft diameters or smaller.

I looked into your link to the SKF gas spring seals. There are small gas springs with my kind of shaft diameters, so there should be small enough gas spring seals. But I couldn’t find the SKF’s catalog with their standard sizes. I’ve e-mailed them, but haven’t heard back from them. Maybe they aren’t interested in working with me, because I’m not a high volume customer.

Meanwhile, the classic Parker Hannifin text on O-rings has a chapter on dynamic applications. That’s how I’ve defaulted to O-rings.
 
Bearing Egineering is local for me too (you and I must be both living in Northern California). They said that they can provide any SKF part if I give them part number or dimensions. Do you know how to look-up part numbers for the SKF's gas spring seals? Their brochure doesn't have part numbers or sizes. Does SKF have a size table somewhere? Are there industry-standard sizes, and SKF makes those sizes?
 
Hmm, I was hoping they would be more helpful.

The Chicago Rawhide catalog is here but it doesn't have any profiles that I think would be appropriate.


You need a fully rubberized seal without garter spring, you don't want to be buying inconel springs.

The HM1 profile would be acceptable for your application if lipped for outwards pressure. They are available in 4.78 and 7.95mm shaft diameter... odd.

Screenshot_20230906-191348_jpjsxy.png
 
I haven't drawn-up a variant with the HM1 profile, yet. I was drawing a variant with a different kind of lip seal which I found on McMaster: seal, sleeve bearing.

What do you think?

Assem1_20230908_e68qdd.png


TugboatEng said:
Hmm, I was hoping they would be more helpful.

Maybe it varies from one location to another. I was calling their warehouse in SF.

TugboatEng said:
They are available in 4.78 and 7.95mm shaft diameter... odd.

I suspect that's 3/16 and 5/16 inch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor