Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Polypropylene Failure, Used in Field Joint 1

Status
Not open for further replies.

LiamBlair

Petroleum
Dec 2, 2003
8
*Need Brains to Pick*
Currently i am investigating the failure of Injected moulded polypropylene used as a field joint for an offshore pipeline. The assembly process at the end of the 'stalks' of pipeline, i.e. where the 'factory' coating ends, is as follows (neglecting contaminents):
(1)Steel is heated to application temperature of fusion bonded epoxy powder(FBE is for corrosion reasons)
(2)At a particular cure time, a Copolymer adhesive is used to promote crosslinking/a good bond strength between FBE and.....
(3)Polyproylene is injected with a chemical blowing agent to form a polymer of particular density and thermal properties.

During this process, the 'factory' applied coating is fused with the 'field' applied coating by heating up the chamfered edges before the injection process takes place.

(4)After polypropylene is crsytallizing, mould is removed and water flowed across it to cool and solidify.(since time=money)

Heres the problem:

During the reeling of this pipeline, round a drum in very cold temperatures and after a particular cooldown time, the field joint produced cracking at 45 degrees to bending stress (critical path angle due to shear stresses), white stressing (overstressed plastic) and loud bangs suspected of being the FBE disbonding from the metal. I am assuming all application procedures were followed correctly and would like to know of any similar problems anyone has had relating to Polyproylene and cold temperatures effets. Does thermal shock (rate of temperature change) have a big enough influence to effectively raise the Tg of the material through the effects of strain rate polymer dependence? Manufacturers claim the film coefficient of their cooldown graphs are neglible compared to conduction through the metal pipe (obviously) and are not considered in design stage, yet surely this effects the real life actual value of the polyprop during water flowing? any advice or direction pointing would help a lot! thanking in advance.
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Is the PP homo or co polymer. They have different embitterment points.

Rapid cooling by quenching will induce some frozen in stress, but it will also reduce the level of crystallisation,.

Higher crystallisation will reduce elongation at break and impact strength.

Foamed mouldings are not so prone to frozen in stress.

Co polymer is tougher at low temperatures

Regards
pat pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.
 
Thanks for the attention P.
The first layer is an FBE, 2nd layer is copolymer adheseive to join the (difficult to bond) FBE to the 3rd layer of PP foam. I think the PP is homogeneous in nature if thats what you are asking. What does 'embitterment' point mean? i'm new to this stuff. (i have mechanical background!) So for the problem in hand, with very cold environmental temps,would you agree that by quenching with, say, warmer water, the level of crystallanity can be improved (compared to cold water quenching in very cold environments), thus elongation before yield can be increased, and brittleness reduced??
 
Liam

Sorry, I presumed you had more knowledge of polymers than seems evident.

By pp homo I meant homopolymer.

Plastics are not truly solid, but super high viscosity liquids like lead, tar or glass. They go through a number of second order phase changes, including one from a glass like brittle state to a more malleable but still apparently solid state, and from this state to a rubber like state and from that to a dough like state.

For some plastics this transition is sudden, but for others it is gradual, depending on molecular shape, and spacing and strength of various bonds.

When we say crystalline in plastics we actually mean semi crystalline, as with "crystalline" plastics, the crystals actually form in a section of a molecule with amorphous bits between. These crystals always float in an amorphous matrix. Also crystals are defined as more ordered regions vs less ordered. They never form highly ordered consistent crystals like water or carbon.

Raw materials suppliers should be able to provide data on elongation vs temperature for various grades that they supply. Although these tests will be done on perfect mouldings, and often are not achievable in the real world, they are still a good guide, especially if done to the CAMPUS standards, which restricts the scope to adjust test conditions toward best results.

PP copolymer is less crystalline, and is more resistant to stress whitening, has a lower embroilment temperature, and higher elongation at break, as well as lower tensile strength and and flex modulus.

Cooling rate will effect crystalinity, but to reduce stress whitening it in foam, it is a double edged sword.

Quicker quenching will give a less crystalline material with smaller less ordered crystals. This will give a tougher material with greater elongation. Slow cooling gives more crystalinity and larger more ordered crystals.

Quick cooling gives a greater difference in crystalinity between the surface and the core of the moulding, as the core still cools slowly due to the insulating properties of the foamed polymer. The greater difference in crystalinity also means a difference in mould shrinkage through the moulding, resulting in internal stresses that use up some of the potential strength and elongation of the moulding.

From what you say, my money is on using co polymer and quenching it as quickly as possible

Regards
pat pprimmer@acay.com.au
eng-tips, by professional engineers for professional engineers
Please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips Fora.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor