Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by canadiancastor

  1. canadiancastor

    Structural theory behind Design Strips in two-way slabs (as per CSI-SAFE)

    I've been using CSI SAFE and other software that allows the integration of design moments along a strip of a fixed width for my two-way slab design for over 10 years. Someone has asked me today what theory / reference this practice is based on, and to my surprise I was not able to find anything...
  2. canadiancastor

    Stirrups as punching shear reinforcement over columns

    I've used stud rails before and it was a good experience, though maybe a bit expensive. Does anyone have any experience specifying stirrups as punching shear reinforcement above columns? I know the both ACI and CSA standards allow it, but I'm wondering if it the additional bars make the column...
  3. canadiancastor

    Anyone using external FRP reinforcement for concrete retrofit in the USA or Canada?

    The last time I had a look was about 10 years ago, external FRP reinforcement was next to useless because of the fire requirements in buildings (from memory, for flexure some percentage of service level loads needed to be maintained while ignoring the FRP reinforcement, which did not allow for...
  4. canadiancastor

    Missing anchor rods in new Ottawa bridge?

    Friend sent me this one, not sure what to make of it. Anyone know what kind of product this might be? Or are the anchor rods cut flush to the top of the nuts? I believe this is a new pedestrian bridge in Ottawa, Canada.
  5. canadiancastor

    Neglecting eccentricity due to beam heights

    I've come across a simple (almost shameful) question that has me stumped. The initial question is whether we should "offset" all of the beams in our FEA models of steel structures so that the top of the beams all is level, which is how it's going to be in practice. I've never done this, but...
  6. canadiancastor

    Trying to explain to non-engineers that it may be OVERKILL, but it is NECESSARY

    @matty54 At my last job I was lucky enough to have the support and respect of the big boss, which was crucial, but that did not translate into having support from anyone else in the business. Getting "regular" people on-board with trying to get things better organised and approved was my long...
  7. canadiancastor

    Trying to explain to non-engineers that it may be OVERKILL, but it is NECESSARY

    I guess something that's not discussed often is how hiring an engineer is a double edged sword for businesses. Sure, you can get better insight into how things work and get things approved, but it's by no means a simple or easy process. It will take time and effort, and you will lose some of the...
  8. canadiancastor

    Trying to explain to non-engineers that it may be OVERKILL, but it is NECESSARY

    @matty54 I've found myself in your situation at my last job, and I was thankful that I had some experience under my belt. Being less experienced would probably have lead me to take on work that I was not prepared for and would have lead me down a road of problematic ethics. There are some jobs...
  9. canadiancastor

    FEA modelling of beam vs slab (in SAFE for example)

    Trying to explain this to someone else, I found out there is a gap in my knowledge. I can't find any information about it in SAFE documentation, but it's really a quite simple question. When beams are modelled in SAFE, there must be an area where the beam and the slab are overlapping? How does...
  10. canadiancastor

    Deflections under seismic loading - Part 2

    Following up on this thread: https://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=450445 It's my understanding that 4.1.8.11.3) d) v) allows us to use a larger period specifically to check seismic deflections. This means I'll have a different base shear than my regular elastic analysis, so I always run a...
  11. canadiancastor

    FEA Theory: Element stress vs nodal force

    @Celt83 I'm not sure I understand how the Gauss points relate to all of this yet (where are gauss points in the original pages that I posted? Is it complexity that is brushed over?), but this makes sense with the results that I'm seeing. If I consider the lever arm for the moment to be from the...
  12. canadiancastor

    FEA Theory: Element stress vs nodal force

    @rb1957 I've been practicing for about 10 years. I ran into this issue trying to integrate axial membrane loads at the bottom of a shear wall made of plates. When integrating at the "bottom" of the wall, that is, right next to the supports, and multiplying by the lever arm, I'm getting 2-5% less...
  13. canadiancastor

    FEA Theory: Element stress vs nodal force

    Thanks for the insights guys. I guess I'm still wondering how I would go about going from nodal values to plate internal stresses or the other way around? Is it a matrix calculation that I have to do all at once? Does it depend on my plate porperties and dimensions?
  14. canadiancastor

    FEA Theory: Element stress vs nodal force

    I'm trying to understand an example in Bathe's Finite Element procedures, but there is something I'm missing. He goes from elements stress to equivalent nodal point forces (he says "in the virtual work sense"), but I don't understand he's doing the transition. Can the forces at element nodal...
  15. canadiancastor

    How to select worst case loads in non-symmetric beams

    @Smoulder What you are saying make a lot of sense. Maybe I am just not familiar with the relevant clauses, but my impression was that the Canadian Standards are always doing member checks. Splitting all checks into these two categories is a great idea: I can loop through the whole section for...

Part and Inventory Search