Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Recent content by SEJohn

  1. SEJohn

    SS reference block to calibrate for CS

    Hi All, Structural Engineer here. Every so often I need a thickness measurement on existing structural steel (carbon steel). I have access to a Olympus 45MG, but it only has a 303 SS reference block. I am usually measuring material that is .1" to 1" thick and I would like to be within a few...
  2. SEJohn

    ASCE 7-10 section 4.5.3 Vehicle Barrier

    You may want to check out this article from Structure Magazine on the topic. https://www.structuremag.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/08/C-StructuralPractices-Iqbal-Oct081.pdf
  3. SEJohn

    Is a Staked X brace the same as a K Brace

    Your logic agrees with the commentary with AISC 341. Thanks for the response.
  4. SEJohn

    Is a Staked X brace the same as a K Brace

    In single story pre-engineered metal buidlings, you sometimes see a stacked X-brace with tension rods. This would look like a two story X-brace systems, but in a single story building. Where the two levels of X-bracing come together, you effectively have a K-brace condition, except there is a...
  5. SEJohn

    Dome Roof Rolling Practice

    Thanks for your responses. IFRs - you are right, when I run the #s, I get a 1/4" pl at dome and 3/8" at cone (assuming a 4.5:12 slope which produces similar total roof height). A cone may be more economical. JStephen - in the API 650 Roof Definitions - it says 'A self-supporting dome roof is a...
  6. SEJohn

    Dome Roof Rolling Practice

    I have a 40' diameter atmospheric tank designed per API 650. The roof needs to be self supported, so I am anticipating a dome roof. I am owners rep and will be specing the tank and assisting in the owner in purchasing and construction. I am unclear on how these are typically built. To make a...
  7. SEJohn

    Wood Truss

    Looks like an arch. Better make sure you either account for lateral kickout forces at the top of your bearing wall or detail to not allow these forces to develop. And make sure that you are on the same page with the truss mfr on lateral deflections/forces at bearing wall.
  8. SEJohn

    Appendix D - Breakout in Shear

    bookowski - are you confusing Avc with Avco? Avc is calculated based on geometry of actual condition. Fig RD.6.2.1(b) is reflecting Avc calculation. Avco is an idealized condition for a single anchor - this term will end up in the denominator of equation D-31.
  9. SEJohn

    Anchor Chair Re-Pad

    In thread809-180411, the OP asked for a reference guide for Re-pad design at the anchor chair - I am looking for the same. I see that in some software, the shell stresses are checked with the combined thickness of shell and re-pad. This seems potentially un-conservative. What might be more...
  10. SEJohn

    Drain through floor-wall joint at sloped bottom tank

    Thanks for the response. When you say to "noted on the name plate", is this done by "API 650 (Modified)" or is there a better way. Thanks for your input.
  11. SEJohn

    Drain through floor-wall joint at sloped bottom tank

    I have seen many tanks with a planar sloped bottom (aka shovel bottom) and a drain at the low point of the slope. This drain might be a 6" pipe vertically centered on the wall to bottom plate joint and then run in to the tank a few feet (I have attached at detail from an existing tank). The...
  12. SEJohn

    Re-rate of very thin tank

    JStephen, thank you for your response - it is very helpful. Thicknesses given are all wall thicknesses. Shell is welded. I am currently using the lowest API 650 SS stress values and a joint efficiency of 0.7. The tank has already been moved from one industrial plant to another and is currently...
  13. SEJohn

    Re-rate of very thin tank

    I am a Structural Engineer doing foundation and anchorage design for the relocation of an existing tank. The existing tank is 14' dia x 44' tall. Material is unknown SS and wall thicknesses are 0.140", 0.109" and 0.078" from top to bottom. The thicknesses are very consistant, so I don't think...
  14. SEJohn

    SS Nozzle on Carbon Steel Tank

    I am specifying a tank for 93% sulfuric acid following NACE SP0294-2006. The document recommends using carbon steel for the tank but appears to be recommending stainless steel for the nozzles. Is this normal? It seems like there would be a corrosion problem at interface of the stainless and...
  15. SEJohn

    Stainless Steel Nozzle on Carbon Steel Tank

    I am specifying a tank for 93% sulfuric acid following NACE SP0294-2006. The document recommends using carbon steel for the tank but appears to be recommending stainless steel for the nozzles. Is this normal? It seems like there would be a corrosion problem at interface of the stainless and...

Part and Inventory Search