Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Search results for query: *

  1. tngolfer

    Foundation tie beams - monolithic or separate placement?

    I've usually detailed the tie beam to be cast monolithically with the slab on grade. My rationale was that one concrete placement would be cheaper. The owner of the building I'm currently working on has required us to provide contraction joints on 45-60 degree angles to the column lines so fork...
  2. tngolfer

    At-rest soil loads on a cantilever retaining wall?

    The bay that is being retained (all 4 sides since the infill in on the interior side) is 37'x64'. I'm leaning towards bracing the wall which will allow me to more efficiently place my steel in the wall for both the construction and final conditions which will be similar. It would be nice for...
  3. tngolfer

    At-rest soil loads on a cantilever retaining wall?

    I am designing an exterior wall of a water treatment plant. The plant floor will be higher than exterior grade (backfilled side is the interior). The liquid-supporting slab-on-grade floor slab will be placed roughly 18 ft. above exterior grade. The design will have to be a multi-step design: 1...
  4. tngolfer

    JAE - Question about an old durability post

    If I'm checking my design capacity ratio (SdMu / Phi Mn), won't it always be 1.0 between fs,min and fs,max? Sd*Mu = (fy/fs)Ms = (fy/fs)As*fs*(d-a/2), fs in numerator and denominator cancel eachother out leaving = As*fy*(d-a/2) Phi*Mn = Phi*As*fy*(d-a/2) phi=1.0 therefore...
  5. tngolfer

    JAE - Question about an old durability post

    Sorry for beating a dead horse here. but I want to clarify this for others that are reading this sometime in the future. I think we are on the same page but you have me confused. Maybe it was a typo. Two posts up you say: Sd x Mu (which I agree with. ) The post above says: Sd x Ms. (I think...
  6. tngolfer

    JAE - Question about an old durability post

    So Step 9 should be Sd x gamma x Ms? Am I doing two checks for each section? 1. Service level check against fs 2. Ultimate level check using fy Thanks for your help.
  7. tngolfer

    JAE - Question about an old durability post

    JAE, I have a question about a post you made a couple of years ago. It is now closed so I can't put this question there. Can you help me understand your reasoning in Step 9 below on multiplying Sd x Ms and not fy/fs x Ms while using Phi=1? This has me hung up as I try to understand ACI 350 and...
  8. tngolfer

    Service Load Combinations for ACI 350-06

    JedClampett, thanks for the answer to Q2. I agree it's the State of the Art literature on designing environmental structures and why not use it. I was just curious if anyone references it to make it legally adopted. Reason I was asking is that I read an article in one of my engineering magazines...
  9. tngolfer

    Service Load Combinations for ACI 350-06

    Q1: What load combinations do you all use when checking foundations for structures at a water treatment plant or waste water treatment plant? ACI 350 only lists ultimate load combinations in 9.2.1 and 2006/2009 IBC does not list F loads in Eq. 16-14 or 16-15 where the dead load is reduced. For...
  10. tngolfer

    Flood Zone impact and hydrostatic forces

    I think I answered my own question - FEMA 55, Coastal Construction Manual, gives a couple of load cases: 1. Breaking wave load on every pile/column + impact load on corner or critical pile/column 2. breaking wave on front row of piles/columns + hydrodynamic load on all others + impact load on...
  11. tngolfer

    Punching shear at edge column with slab overhang

    I've considered the same question before. I tried to tell myself that the crack has to extend to the edge of the slab, thereby increasing my perimeter. (I'm still not convinced it isn't the case.) CSi's SAFE computer program stops the perimeter as if the slab edge is closer which will give you...
  12. tngolfer

    Effect of Bracing on Deflection of Beam

    What's supporting the transoms? How would they "support" the mullion? I think the mullion span is 3.65 m.
  13. tngolfer

    Flood Zone impact and hydrostatic forces

    I'm in a High Hazard Flood Zone Class VE on the Gulf of Mexico. The project is a public pavilion approximately 70 ft. x 140 ft. with columns and bowstring trusses. The columns are spaced roughly 11'-9" on center along each side of the building with the trusses spanning the function area. I'm...
  14. tngolfer

    Soil on concrete structure, DL or LL?

    Loss = load. (autoincorrect)
  15. tngolfer

    Soil on concrete structure, DL or LL?

    My original thought was H also but that is defined as lateral loss due to soil.
  16. tngolfer

    Soil on concrete structure, DL or LL?

    I have a soccer field on top of a prestressed concrete parking garage. Is the soil DL or LL?
  17. tngolfer

    How to determine if a slab is restrained for fire cover requirements

    I was taught that a restrained system is capable of allowing rigid member arching - capable of supporting the thrust forces applied by the rigid member. I don't think anyone would argue that a column is unrestrained, but where is the line and how to do I figure out what it is? Does a 12" wall...
  18. tngolfer

    How to determine if a slab is restrained for fire cover requirements

    2006 IBC, Tables 721.2.3(1)-(5) deal with the increased cover requirements for fire protection. The tables provide separate requirements depending if your slab is restrained or unrestrained. My case is a 7 span, two-way flat plate analysis. The end span is 30'-10" but is supported by a full...
  19. tngolfer

    ADAPT Builder vs. SAFE V12 PT

    Our company is looking to purchase a 3D PT modeler. We currently have 2D ADAPT-PT and SAFE V8 and are happy with both of them. We have sat through 3 online demonstrations (2 from ADAPT and 1 from SAFE) showing the capabilities of each program. They both seem pretty similar and both are going to...
  20. tngolfer

    Temperature effects on lumber

    frv, PostFrameSE didn't say anywhere in his OP it was the bottom chord of the trusses. Actually he said the trusses and purlins which won't be affected by attic loading so thanks for the common sense comment which made no sense.
Back
Top