Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations KootK on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Search results for query: *

  1. Craig_H

    Gable Frame w/o vertical

    Can you hang the ridge onto the wall-truss using a hanger? Perhaps a simlar to a Simpson CBH or the euro originals that it is a copy of? Regarding the frame and its connections, mortise & tenon connections can often work well. Below example was buried in the wall and is therefore PSL. I was...
  2. Craig_H

    Log cabin Roof Framing

    Wow. I can't say that I've ever engaged in the engineering discipline of "remove it, observe deflection, then add a support based upon that". I'm genuinely curious, how do you plan to size the new support columns without knowing the magnitude of load applied to them?
  3. Craig_H

    Log cabin Roof Framing

    I see a half-lap joint in the ridge beam directly above one of the 8x8s you plan on removing. I wouldn't be taking it out. Having designed these types of fire places, there are definitely cheaper ways to laterally brace the wood stud framing than by adding 8x8 columns. Your justification for...
  4. Craig_H

    LEDGERS ON ICF WALLS

    How much concrete is above your ledger? In the past, I've had the contractor cut out the foam at the interval of the ledger anchors, and form the face with plywood. Plywood can easily be made from scraps and screwed to the plastic webs in the ICF blocks. This left exposed concrete with...
  5. Craig_H

    Information for Wood Log Beams and Trusses

    Definitely a niche and very complicated. I've had the privilege of designing a few log buildings. General tips: [ol 1] I collaborated with the log craftsman. It's truly a craft and the craftsperson's style is likely to drive the truss form. I'm in Canada and my wood code (CSA O86) has...
  6. Craig_H

    Attic Truss - Floor Sheathing Flat Diaphragm

    I seem to remember asking the same question a while back. Recommended solution was to sheath the vertical webs and provide blocking at the web-to-top-chord joint. See this: https://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=475689, and KootK's excellent diagram copied below for convenience:
  7. Craig_H

    New Brunswick Structural Engineer Trouble

    I think that it's relatively safe to guess that this transfer slab is loaded to a UC of more than 1.04 (or whatever number you want to argue the semantics of). The regulator is using "serious deficiencies" in its statements, and I doubt that term is being swung around carelessly. Service level...
  8. Craig_H

    Lag Screw Withdrawal from Top of LVL

    If this is a multi-ply LVL that you are fastening to, could you not have a knife plate between the plies with dowels through the LVL? Knife gets stabbed into the column above. Not much fabrication apart from cutting a plate and drilling a few holes. That's about as concealed as you can get...
  9. Craig_H

    National Building Code of Canada - Noncombustible Construction vs Insulated Metal Panels

    Interesting find with the Kingspan K-roc. As it's filled with mineral wool, I'd be confident saying that's non-combustible. While it may be possible to argue that an insulated metal panel (with flammable foam inside) is non-combustible because of the steel wrap, I don't see it as following the...
  10. Craig_H

    Can you thermal isolate a concrete podium?

    We generally look at R-value per inch of wall thickness. In this case, I would imagine that one can consider the walls to also insulate in the vertical direction. Perhaps insulating the walls for the bottom portion would provide enough insulative value of the total assembly that your framing...
  11. Craig_H

    Residential Wood Frame Construction Partition Load

    That's my own calculation of a relatively small room size (walls 10' apart), intended to be slightly conservative so as to produce a floor pressure that I am confident won't be exceeded.
  12. Craig_H

    Residential Wood Frame Construction Partition Load

    For typical residential construction I use a partition dead weight of 0.3 kPa (studs, 1/2" drywall two sides), and assume that they are 8' tall and at 10' on center resulting in a floor pressure of 0.25 kPa which I spread over the entire floor area. That way the architect can rejig their floor...
  13. Craig_H

    Cable Guardrail Design

    Thanks Deker! Key quote for me: Seems children can effectively do a muscle-up from the top rail @ 42".
  14. Craig_H

    Cable Guardrail Design

    I'm still surprised that these are allowed. Not sure about in the US of A, but in Canada there are clear requirements about guards not being "climbable" (the intent being that children should not be able to easily climb up the guard). If the cables are tensioned enough to resist the 4" sphere...
  15. Craig_H

    Structural Drafting - Software Recommendations

    I also use BricsCAD and quite like it. I purchased standalone licenses for our office and I do pay for maintenance (upgrades and support). Their support is quite good and I find it worthwhile. The costs are quite reasonable. I have not tried their BIM product but am very curious how it would...
  16. Craig_H

    Saskatoon Hollow-Core Building Collapses during Construction

    Most interesting to me was that the failure precipitated a progressive collapse. Perhaps it makes sense if all the steel was hanging on its erection-only connections and hadn't been fully bolted up, and none of the lower stories had been grouted. Progressive type collapse is supposed to be...
  17. Craig_H

    Saskatoon Hollow-Core Building Collapses during Construction

    Link: CTV News Looks like a bit of confusion in the news about this one. The above article lists the building as "industrial", yet it looks a lot like an apartment to me. The video seems to show a failed connection between the stair/elevator core (tilt-up?) and a steel beam, which...
  18. Craig_H

    WTF is this roof framing?

    I've seen weirder in-situ framing, and have decided that for my own mental health, I am no longer going to try and understand the decisions or thought processes that have gone into the odd-ball wood framing that I come across. I am sure it made sense to someone, but it's often not me. Whatever...
  19. Craig_H

    Log wall building.

    I've done a few log projects with a local log builder. You will likely find that log construction is a true craft and that each contractor has strong preferences and style. Punched Openings: The contractor who I have worked with prefers to leave the settling allowance at the top of punched...

Part and Inventory Search