I've recently had a client claim that the efflorescence from a beam was dripping onto cars in their parking garage and removing the paint on the tenants cars. I've never heard that before and as a young structural engineer was under the impression that other than helping me locate cracks, these calcium deposits are purely an aesthetic concern. Any care to educate me a little more on this specifically and efflorescence in general? Thanks.
Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations cowski on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
A Discussion on Efflorescence 1
- Thread starter umrce
- Start date
The water coming through the concrete (and leaving the efflorescence would potentially have "ingredients" that could harm car paint.
Here's an article that describes some of the chemical composition of the process.
These are soluble salts in the water.
Check out Eng-Tips Forum's Policies here:
faq731-376
Here's an article that describes some of the chemical composition of the process.
http://www.concreteconstruction.net/concrete/what-causes-efflorescence-and-how-do-you-remove-it.aspx
These are soluble salts in the water.
Check out Eng-Tips Forum's Policies here:
faq731-376
- Thread starter
- #3
-JAE
Thanks. While it could have the "ingredients" it seems likes parking garages would be excellent places for efflorescence to occur and cause this problem with cars however I've never heard of this problem before. Do you think this would be a more unique circumstance? I've never heard of this before which makes me believe this is not a routine problem.
Thanks. While it could have the "ingredients" it seems likes parking garages would be excellent places for efflorescence to occur and cause this problem with cars however I've never heard of this problem before. Do you think this would be a more unique circumstance? I've never heard of this before which makes me believe this is not a routine problem.
-
1
- #4
Efflorescence is common. It occurs in/on any cementitious material that water migrates into and then out of. As water goes into the cementitious material (mortar, grout, stucco, concrete, etc.), the calcium constituent of the cementitious material is so plentiful (generally over half of the compounds in cement contain calcium) that the water takes some of the calcium in solution. When it comes to the surface of the concrete it dehydrates and reacts with carbon dioxide at the same time,creating calcium carbonate...the white stuff. The chemistry can be a bit more complex and contain other compounds as well, but that's the basic stuff.
Can it damage paint on a car? Sure. Most auto paints are acrylics of some sort. They are solvent based. Even though they are "shiny" they are porous to some degree. Further, the efflorescent compounds can be abrasive as well. Further, if the efflorescence imbibes some pollutants such as petroleum products, it can clearly damage paint.
Can it damage paint on a car? Sure. Most auto paints are acrylics of some sort. They are solvent based. Even though they are "shiny" they are porous to some degree. Further, the efflorescent compounds can be abrasive as well. Further, if the efflorescence imbibes some pollutants such as petroleum products, it can clearly damage paint.
darthsoilsguy2
Geotechnical
you could look to see if there is a way to reduce the amount of water accumulating and dripping. don't know what floor the problem is on but some ideas.... sealing penetrations, creating tooled drip edges at non-parking spots to prevent water from traveling across a member and dripping on a car, adding a drip edge feature or strip at good spots to break the plane and prevent that accumulation, concrete crack sealing, putting a traffic coat down on the top floor....
If it is really bad, you should be able to see the evidence in the worse spots on the structure above. also, i'm sure the client will let you know which tenants are giving him grief.
If it is really bad, you should be able to see the evidence in the worse spots on the structure above. also, i'm sure the client will let you know which tenants are giving him grief.
Leakage through parking decks is unfortunately common, due to lack of a membrane and/or adequate crack control reinforcement. And yes, it does damage the paint of automobiles. The problem frequently goes unnoticed or not addressed in transient parking decks, but in residential or office parking where cars sit in the same spot each day, it can be a big issue.
- Thread starter
- #10
darthsoilsguy2
Geotechnical
My buddy sent me this link and it reminded me of this thread. lots of photos...
darthsoilsguy2
Geotechnical
But Hokie, the photo caption says the garage was "generally usable and acceptable".... what else could you want in a garage?.... I'm just hoping it isn't the EXACT example of what we've been talking about.
- Status
Similar threads
- Question
- Question
- Locked
- Question
