Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations IDS on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

asme & tema

Status
Not open for further replies.

cmsvessel

Mechanical
Nov 3, 2005
34
Why two standards for hx-some one asks for ASME VIII and TEMA "C"? what if diffrent results from these two codes?
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

ASME covers the pressure vessel requirements and TEMA the heat exchanger standard design ond performance requirements.

 
TEMA covers the design, fabriaction, installation and maitenance of HX. ASME UHX also regualte HX design.
 
TEMA stands for Tubular Exchanger Manufacturers Ass'n.

rmw
 
Dangit I love it when a plan comes together unclesyd!!!!

rmw
 
Note that as of 2004, ASME is the primary design code for heat exchangers. TEMA is no longer valid for new construction. TEMA is approved for use on repair of existing vessels/HTX under the rules of R stamp.

 
Tankman650: Yes and no,as UHX does not apply to everything. You could still use TEMA under U-2(g).
 
you can use asme sec viii for some part of heatexchenger such as tubesheet or sylinder of hex under pressure
otherwise TEMA is only for the shell and tube hex.
 
TEMA also has some very helpful information such as suggested good practice for the design of saddle supports for horizontal exchangers, how to adjust flange calculations to include the pass partition gaskets, etc.
 
cmsmeng,

Please find the related thread.

LOST in UHX Tubesheet Calc!!!!
thread292-97171

- In the refinery, I always refer to TEMA type R.
- Code Case 2429 was expired. I do not know the updated information for the subject.
 
cmsmerg,

The design of tubesheet in accordance with ASME is very economical compared to TEMA. TEMA calls for minimum tubesheet thickness based on size of tubes, where in case of ASME this requirement is not mandatory.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor