Continue to Site

Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations KootK on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

Can a bevel gearbox be used with rotation of housing as well ? 4

sh3rlock.holmes

Mechanical
Sep 24, 2024
8
Hello Engineers,

My first post here. We are in the process of designing a custom machine, in which power from a motor has to be distributed to 4 shafts, while the axis of the shafts themselves rotate around a central axis. I hope it is clear from the picture attached.

20240924_173512_twpbyt.jpg



For this purpose, we need a suitable gearbox. At the present moment, we are looking at a 4-way bevel gearbox, (again attached as picture). From the theory I know, this should theoretically work, since the housing of the gearbox can rotate in the central axis, and the shafts can rotate in their axes.

20240924_173559_uyteaa.jpg



But I think the gearboxes are not designed with such an application in mind. The usual use case is to fix/mount the housing to a stationary body.
So my question is, first of all, do you see any problems with this application, and are there other/special gearboxes that are designed specifically for this purpose?

EDIT : OK I forgot to add a key point. As mentioned before, the 4 shafts and the gearbox housing should rotate about a central axis. THIS ROTATION IS EXTERNALLY POWERED BY A DIFFERENT MOTOR. So basically, the housing of the bevel gearbox will be made to rotate at a constant speed via a different motor, and the initial motor whose input shaft is shown in the picture is used to supply torque to the 4 shafts. This torque control must be independent of the overall rotation, hence we are using 2 separate motors.
Thanks to everyone who commented so far. I'm sorry I forgot to mention this key point.
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

"One of my other colleague suggested that we do a multibody-dynamic simulation of the gearbox."

Uh, the math isn't that hard.

A spreadsheet would do fine.
 
From the simulation I was informed that we can see the bearing loads and other things as well. There is also an option to integrate the motor control system to the simulation to see if the whole system works...We think in that case it might be worth it to go with a simulation rather than basic kinematic analysis.
 

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor