Greg,
Do you have information on the mechanical properties-- yield strength, tensile strength, impact, hardness, etc.? I can give you some estimates for SAE 4340, which is similar to EN24 (817M40). EN26 (826M40) should be tougher for a given strength/hardness level, due to its higher Ni content: 2.30-2.80 vs. 1.30-1.70.