BiPolarMoment
Mechanical
- Mar 28, 2006
- 625
There are instances where I would like to have multiple parts that originate from the same overall length dimensions. E.g. If I had a simple shaft[as attached] that is 90mm and I have 3 configurations (not necessarily configurations in a SW sense) where one is simply straight, and two are bent at 30* and 45*).
Due to limitations in solidworks I can't just bend the parts using the flex tool--and even if I did it would not dimension properly--so instead it is a swept solid. However, short of setting up an equation to define my overall length and driving the dimensions with further equations, the total length along the axis will be driven--best case scenario maybe use an arc length if I want to directly control the part length but this unnecessarily creates a tolerance stack to the total length along the axis of the part, or forces me to divvy up the total allowable tolerance if I want to maintain the same OAL.
In my attached picture I included a manual dimension where I summed the lengths and applied a tolerance in the text of the dimension--this is obviously not ideal as it has no relation to the model whatsoever and is confusing as it appears to be a linear dimension.
Does anyone have a suggestion for a dimensioning and modeling scheme where the overall length is a driving dimension on a "bent" part? Does solidworks allow you to create a "total sketch length" that incorporates multiple segments (i.e. in this case it would be an arc and two line segments summing to 90)?
Is this a crazy question? I've run into situations where I wanted to use something like this a few times now.
Due to limitations in solidworks I can't just bend the parts using the flex tool--and even if I did it would not dimension properly--so instead it is a swept solid. However, short of setting up an equation to define my overall length and driving the dimensions with further equations, the total length along the axis will be driven--best case scenario maybe use an arc length if I want to directly control the part length but this unnecessarily creates a tolerance stack to the total length along the axis of the part, or forces me to divvy up the total allowable tolerance if I want to maintain the same OAL.
In my attached picture I included a manual dimension where I summed the lengths and applied a tolerance in the text of the dimension--this is obviously not ideal as it has no relation to the model whatsoever and is confusing as it appears to be a linear dimension.
Does anyone have a suggestion for a dimensioning and modeling scheme where the overall length is a driving dimension on a "bent" part? Does solidworks allow you to create a "total sketch length" that incorporates multiple segments (i.e. in this case it would be an arc and two line segments summing to 90)?
Is this a crazy question? I've run into situations where I wanted to use something like this a few times now.