phamENG
Structural
- Feb 6, 2015
- 7,623
So I'm 99% sure this is a bad idea, but I like this client and want to make sure I leave no stone un-turned.
House is a slab on grade, but they want a brick skirt. Unfortunately, the owner doesn't like thin brick - something about not wanting the fake stuff (as I spent my morning assessing a 120 year old building with 20" brick walls, the irony of thinking 4" veneer is some how the "real" stuff is not lost on me). So this is the detail the architect gave me and is insisting they've used it before. Even showed me the engineer's detail to match. (I wasn't impressed and I'm pretty sure the proprietary anchor they used violated a few manufacturer's installation restrictions.) We end up with a single wythe of brick veneer and one of 8" CMU with a shoe block and a slab. Well the anchor bolts are going to end up somewhere very close to the collar joint between the brick and the block - probably more in the brick.
A quick check of the most common adhesive anchors for unreinforced brick - Hilti HIT-HY 270 and Simpson ET-HP, everything is about anchorage into the face of the wall. Hilti specifically says it has to be in the face; Simpson seems to imply it at least - there may be a specific note buried in there somewhere that I'm not seeing.
So...does anyone think this is salvageable? I don't, but like I said, figured I'd cast a wider net and see if anyone can pull a rabbit from their hat.
House is a slab on grade, but they want a brick skirt. Unfortunately, the owner doesn't like thin brick - something about not wanting the fake stuff (as I spent my morning assessing a 120 year old building with 20" brick walls, the irony of thinking 4" veneer is some how the "real" stuff is not lost on me). So this is the detail the architect gave me and is insisting they've used it before. Even showed me the engineer's detail to match. (I wasn't impressed and I'm pretty sure the proprietary anchor they used violated a few manufacturer's installation restrictions.) We end up with a single wythe of brick veneer and one of 8" CMU with a shoe block and a slab. Well the anchor bolts are going to end up somewhere very close to the collar joint between the brick and the block - probably more in the brick.
A quick check of the most common adhesive anchors for unreinforced brick - Hilti HIT-HY 270 and Simpson ET-HP, everything is about anchorage into the face of the wall. Hilti specifically says it has to be in the face; Simpson seems to imply it at least - there may be a specific note buried in there somewhere that I'm not seeing.
So...does anyone think this is salvageable? I don't, but like I said, figured I'd cast a wider net and see if anyone can pull a rabbit from their hat.
