Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

How is this item made?

Status
Not open for further replies.

alex00

Civil/Environmental
Feb 25, 2017
4
0
0
US
pic1_drbuvi.jpg


Is this made with injection molding or some thermoplastic process? I am completely new to plastics manufacturing and it doesn't seem possible that this part is made with injection molding because of the different appearance of the clear display window, vs the marbled resin looking edges. This is a piece made by a previous supplier of ours who went out of business, and we are looking to replace it. Thank you
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

How big is it? A ruler in the photo might have helped a little.

Cut it in half with a hand hacksaw using a Rem-Grit blade.
Capture the shavings/ dust that falls off, separately for the rim and for the transparency.
Describe how it smells as you cut each.
Burn the shavings/dust, separately for the rim and the transparency.
Describe how difficult it is to light, and whether it wants to stay lit.
Do it again, and try to dissolve the shavings in various solvents.
Those simple tests will help you figure out what general type of plastics are involved, if not the exact formulation.

Before you invest that much sweat in it, chat up your former supplier's principals, and see if they will reveal the materials and processes, and sell you the tooling. Offer them a limited consultancy to help you get set up for manufacture in your facility, etc.







Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
 
The part may be injection molded, the "marbled" look would be a texture applied to the mold surfaces; the "clear" portion would have highly polished mold surfaces. Texture may be applied for appearance only or sometimes to help the part stick to the right part of the mold to make part removal consistent/easier. If it is injection molded, the texture might be there to help hide the ejector pin marks.
 
It is indeed injection molded, I was able to locate a mark on the bottom of the casing, I forgot the term, it may be ejector pin or something else, but it's obvious.

I sent the casing to a plastic supplier in my area to find out what it's made of. I was able to do some lighter tests, if I leave the flame on for 5 or so seconds it will ignite, and it turns an ugly greyish/black once ignited. The only solvent I have laying around is Acetone which greatly affected the items, made them develop a white texture which I am not able to remove.

Our ultimate goal is to reproduce these items, and I've been looking into some CAD designers who I could send the product to, although they will need to touch the 3D scan up because the cases we have now are a little damaged from being pryed apart, which are they not designed to do (like you see in the photo).

If I can't find someone for that service, I will likely get some high quality scans and try sending them to someone on fiverr to develop the 3D files. Our budget for these service/s is very large, in case anyone is interested in assisting me. Thank you for the responses
 
Imho it is not really difficult part to reproduce if you don't expect TOO low tolerances. An experienced moulder can model it even by manuel measurement. You can just find a plastic moulder in your area.
 
High Impact Polystyrene seems correct, thank you for that. When you say find a plastic molder, what exactly am I looking for? I see a lot of websites such as but there's no mention of shipping items to them to be duplicated, or 3D CAD services. So I guess my issue is I don't know if I am looking for someone to create a 3D file, or a molder who can duplicate it without that. I haven't had much luck finding a "ship us your physical item we will turn it into a 3D file" services, but my assumption was once I had that file I could go to mostly any injection molding company, like protolabs, and get the item made.
 
Get on the phone, and chat up LOCAL molders listed in your area's Yellow Pages.

Not all of them will be interested, of course, but when you have a short list, go IN PERSON and get acquainted with what they do and how they do it.

Molding issues tend to be corrected sooner and cheaper with a local partner than with some outfit about which you know nothing, on the other side of the country, or the world.





Mike Halloran
Pembroke Pines, FL, USA
 
General-purpose polystyrene is clear, hard, and rather brittle according to wikipedia.

So that fits what it looks like at least (for example cd case fronts is made of this and they are very clear)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top