jtseng123
Mechanical
- Jun 6, 2012
- 530
Dear all,
We have many CS equipment will undergo auto-refrigeration with pressure down to 0 psig and the temp can drop to -150F.
The “Basic MDMT” from Table UCS-66 will be calculated based on the nominal noncorroded thickness. Then the reduction from Fig UCS-66.1 will be subtracted from the Basic MDMT to become the Adjusted MDMT.
My question is: If material is impact tested at -49F, will the “basic MDMT” becomes -49F instead of value from Table UCS-66 ?
One case we have, 2.25” thick SA-516-70N impact tested at MDMT = -49F. The reduction from Fig UCS-66.1 is 140F during auto-refrigeration:
(1)Using basic MDMT per Table UCS-66, it will be 0F, the adjusted MDMT = 0-140 = -140F.
(2)However, it is impact tested at -49F. If basic MDMT can be treated as -49F, then adjusted MDMT = -49-140= -189F but not to be lower than -155F per UCS-160. So the final adjusted MDMT will be -155F.
Which of the above calculation is the correct interpretation of the code ?
We have many CS equipment will undergo auto-refrigeration with pressure down to 0 psig and the temp can drop to -150F.
The “Basic MDMT” from Table UCS-66 will be calculated based on the nominal noncorroded thickness. Then the reduction from Fig UCS-66.1 will be subtracted from the Basic MDMT to become the Adjusted MDMT.
My question is: If material is impact tested at -49F, will the “basic MDMT” becomes -49F instead of value from Table UCS-66 ?
One case we have, 2.25” thick SA-516-70N impact tested at MDMT = -49F. The reduction from Fig UCS-66.1 is 140F during auto-refrigeration:
(1)Using basic MDMT per Table UCS-66, it will be 0F, the adjusted MDMT = 0-140 = -140F.
(2)However, it is impact tested at -49F. If basic MDMT can be treated as -49F, then adjusted MDMT = -49-140= -189F but not to be lower than -155F per UCS-160. So the final adjusted MDMT will be -155F.
Which of the above calculation is the correct interpretation of the code ?