Huge Difference Between Free Meshing (AdvancingFront) and Structu

[Cansand]

I was testing the performance difference between Free Meshing and Structural Meshing techniques.
For the same very simple model (square) I use first Structural meshing
Then I used Free meshing technique (ADVANCING FRONT for the same model .Both meshes have the same type and very much almost the same Number of elements . The two meshes look topogically even identical.
Suprisingly each one give extremely different response from the other. The AdvancingFront Free one leads to much higher strain and displacement field than the structural one. That results shocked me. If you do not beleive Below are the inp files of each of two meshes . Please try and give a comment about that (Note the two input files are seperated by contiuous line)


*Heading
** Job name: Structural Model name: Model-1
*Preprint, echo=NO, model=NO, history=NO, contact=NO
**
** PARTS
**
*Part, name=Part-1
*Node
1, 0., 0.
2, 11.1111107, 0.
3, 22.2222214, 0.
4, 33.3333321, 0.
5, 44.4444427, 0.
6, 55.5555573, 0.
7, 66.6666641, 0.
8, 77.7777786, 0.
9, 88.8888855, 0.
10, 100., 0.
11, 111.111115, 0.
12, 122.222221, 0.
13, 133.333328, 0.
14, 144.444443, 0.
15, 155.555557, 0.
16, 166.666672, 0.
17, 177.777771, 0.
18, 188.888885, 0.
19, 200., 0.
20, 211.111115, 0.
21, 222.222229, 0.
22, 233.333328, 0.
23, 244.444443, 0.
24, 255.555557, 0.
25, 266.666656, 0.
26, 277.777771, 0.
27, 288.888885, 0.
28, 300., 0.
29, 311.111115, 0.
30, 322.222229, 0.
31, 333.333344, 0.
32, 344.444458, 0.
33, 355.555542, 0.
34, 366.666656, 0.
35, 377.777771, 0.
36, 388.888885, 0.
37, 400., 0.
38, 411.111115, 0.
39, 422.222229, 0.
40, 433.333344, 0.
41, 444.444458, 0.
42, 455.555542, 0.
43, 466.666656, 0.
44, 477.777771, 0.
45, 488.888885, 0.
46, 500., 0.
47, 511.111115, 0.
48, 522.222229, 0.
49, 533.333313, 0.
50, 544.444458, 0.
51, 555.555542, 0.
52, 566.666687, 0.
53, 577.777771, 0.
54, 588.888916, 0.
55, 600., 0.
56, 0., 11.1111107
57, 11.1111107, 11.1111107
58, 22.2222214, 11.1111107
59, 33.3333321, 11.1111107
60, 44.4444427, 11.1111107
61, 55.5555573, 11.1111107
62, 66.6666641, 11.1111107
63, 77.7777786, 11.1111107
64, 88.8888855, 11.1111107
65, 100., 11.1111107
66, 111.111115, 11.1111107
67, 122.222221, 11.1111107
68, 133.333328, 11.1111107
69, 144.444443, 11.1111107
70, 155.555557, 11.1111107
71, 166.666672, 11.1111107
72, 177.777771, 11.1111107
73, 188.888885, 11.1111107
74, 200., 11.1111107
75, 211.111115, 11.1111107
76, 222.222229, 11.1111107
77, 233.333328, 11.1111107
78, 244.444443, 11.1111107
79, 255.555557, 11.1111107
80, 266.666656, 11.1111107
81, 277.777771, 11.1111107
82, 288.888885, 11.1111107
83, 300., 11.1111107
84, 311.111115, 11.1111107
85, 322.222229, 11.1111107
86, 333.333344, 11.1111107
87, 344.444458, 11.1111107
88, 355.555542, 11.1111107
89, 366.666656, 11.1111107
90, 377.777771, 11.1111107
91, 388.888885, 11.1111107
92, 400., 11.1111107
93, 411.111115, 11.1111107
94, 422.222229, 11.1111107
95, 433.333344, 11.1111107
96, 444.444458, 11.1111107
97, 455.555542, 11.1111107
98, 466.666656, 11.1111107
99, 477.777771, 11.1111107
100, 488.888885, 11.1111107
101, 500., 11.1111107
102, 511.111115, 11.1111107
103, 522.222229, 11.1111107
104, 533.333313, 11.1111107
105, 544.444458, 11.1111107
106, 555.555542, 11.1111107
107, 566.666687, 11.1111107
108, 577.777771, 11.1111107
109, 588.888916, 11.1111107
110, 600., 11.1111107
111, 0., 22.2222214
112, 11.1111107, 22.2222214
113, 22.2222214, 22.2222214
114, 33.3333321, 22.2222214
115, 44.4444427, 22.2222214
116, 55.5555573, 22.2222214
117, 66.6666641, 22.2222214
118, 77.7777786, 22.2222214
119, 88.8888855, 22.2222214
120, 100., 22.2222214
121, 111.111115, 22.2222214
122, 122.222221, 22.2222214
123, 133.333328, 22.2222214
124, 144.444443, 22.2222214
125, 155.555557, 22.2222214
126, 166.666672, 22.2222214
127, 177.777771, 22.2222214
128, 188.888885, 22.2222214
129, 200., 22.2222214
130, 211.111115, 22.2222214
131, 222.222229, 22.2222214
132, 233.333328, 22.2222214
133, 244.444443, 22.2222214
134, 255.555557, 22.2222214
135, 266.666656, 22.2222214
136, 277.777771, 22.2222214
137, 288.888885, 22.2222214
138, 300., 22.2222214
139, 311.111115, 22.2222214
140, 322.222229, 22.2222214
141, 333.333344, 22.2222214
142, 344.444458, 22.2222214
143, 355.555542, 22.2222214
144, 366.666656, 22.2222214
145, 377.777771, 22.2222214
146, 388.888885, 22.2222214
147, 400., 22.2222214
148, 411.111115, 22.2222214
149, 422.222229, 22.2222214
150, 433.333344, 22.2222214
151, 444.444458, 22.2222214
152, 455.555542, 22.2222214
153, 466.666656, 22.2222214
154, 477.777771, 22.2222214
155, 488.888885, 22.2222214
156, 500., 22.2222214
157, 511.111115, 22.2222214
158, 522.222229, 22.2222214
159, 533.333313, 22.2222214
160, 544.444458, 22.2222214
161, 555.555542, 22.2222214
162, 566.666687, 22.2222214
163, 577.777771, 22.2222214
164, 588.888916, 22.2222214
165, 600., 22.2222214
166, 0., 33.3333321
167, 11.1111107, 33.3333321
168, 22.2222214, 33.3333321
169, 33.3333321, 33.3333321
170, 44.4444427, 33.3333321
171, 55.5555573, 33.3333321
172, 66.6666641, 33.3333321
173, 77.7777786, 33.3333321
174, 88.8888855, 33.3333321
175, 100., 33.3333321
176, 111.111115, 33.3333321
177, 122.222221, 33.3333321
178, 133.333328, 33.3333321
179, 144.444443, 33.3333321
180, 155.555557, 33.3333321
181, 166.666672, 33.3333321
182, 177.777771, 33.3333321
183, 188.888885, 33.3333321
184, 200., 33.3333321
185, 211.111115, 33.3333321
186, 222.222229, 33.3333321
187, 233.333328, 33.3333321
188, 244.444443, 33.3333321
189, 255.555557, 33.3333321
190, 266.666656, 33.3333321
191, 277.777771, 33.3333321
192, 288.888885, 33.3333321
193, 300., 33.3333321
194, 311.111115, 33.3333321
195, 322.222229, 33.3333321
196, 333.333344, 33.3333321
197, 344.444458, 33.3333321
198, 355.555542, 33.3333321
199, 366.666656, 33.3333321
200, 377.777771, 33.3333321
201, 388.888885, 33.3333321
202, 400., 33.3333321
203, 411.111115, 33.3333321
204, 422.222229, 33.3333321
205, 433.333344, 33.3333321
206, 444.444458, 33.3333321
207, 455.555542, 33.3333321
208, 466.666656, 33.3333321
209, 477.777771, 33.3333321
210, 488.888885, 33.3333321
211, 500., 33.3333321
212, 511.111115, 33.3333321
213, 522.222229, 33.3333321
214, 533.333313, 33.3333321
215, 544.444458, 33.3333321
216, 555.555542, 33.3333321
217, 566.666687, 33.3333321
218, 577.777771, 33.3333321
219, 588.888916, 33.3333321
220, 600., 33.3333321
221, 0., 44.4444427
222, 11.1111107, 44.4444427
223, 22.2222214, 44.4444427
224, 33.3333321, 44.4444427
225, 44.4444427, 44.4444427
226, 55.5555573, 44.4444427
227, 66.6666641, 44.4444427
228, 77.7777786, 44.4444427
229, 88.8888855, 44.4444427
230, 100., 44.4444427
231, 111.111115, 44.4444427
232, 122.222221, 44.4444427
233, 133.333328, 44.4444427
234, 144.444443, 44.4444427
235, 155.555557, 44.4444427
236, 166.666672, 44.4444427
237, 177.777771, 44.4444427
238, 188.888885, 44.4444427
239, 200., 44.4444427
240, 211.111115, 44.4444427
241, 222.222229, 44.4444427
242, 233.333328, 44.4444427
243, 244.444443, 44.4444427
244, 255.555557, 44.4444427
245, 266.666656, 44.4444427
246, 277.777771, 44.4444427
247, 288.888885, 44.4444427
248, 300., 44.4444427
249, 311.111115, 44.4444427
250, 322.222229, 44.4444427
251, 333.333344, 44.4444427
252, 344.444458, 44.4444427
253, 355.555542, 44.4444427
254, 366.666656, 44.4444427
255, 377.777771, 44.4444427
256, 388.888885, 44.4444427
257, 400., 44.4444427
258, 411.111115, 44.4444427
259, 422.222229, 44.4444427
260, 433.333344, 44.4444427
261, 444.444458, 44.4444427
262, 455.555542, 44.4444427
263, 466.666656, 44.4444427
264, 477.777771, 44.4444427
265, 488.888885, 44.4444427
266, 500., 44.4444427
267, 511.111115, 44.4444427
268, 522.222229, 44.4444427
269, 533.333313, 44.4444427
270, 544.444458, 44.4444427
271, 555.555542, 44.4444427
272, 566.666687, 44.4444427
273, 577.777771, 44.4444427
274, 588.888916, 44.4444427
275, 600., 44.4444427
276, 0., 55.5555573
277, 11.1111107, 55.5555573
278, 22.2222214, 55.5555573
279, 33.3333321, 55.5555573
280, 44.4444427, 55.5555573
281, 55.5555573, 55.5555573
282, 66.6666641, 55.5555573
283, 77.7777786, 55.5555573
284, 88.8888855, 55.5555573
285, 100., 55.5555573
286, 111.111115, 55.5555573
287, 122.222221, 55.5555573
288, 133.333328, 55.5555573
289, 144.444443, 55.5555573
290, 155.555557, 55.5555573
291, 166.666672, 55.5555573
292, 177.777771, 55.5555573
293, 188.888885, 55.5555573
294, 200., 55.5555573
295, 211.111115, 55.5555573
296, 222.222229, 55.5555573
297, 233.333328, 55.5555573
298, 244.444443, 55.5555573
299, 255.555557, 55.5555573
300, 266.666656, 55.5555573
301, 277.777771, 55.5555573
302, 288.888885, 55.5555573
303, 300., 55.5555573
304, 311.111115, 55.5555573
305, 322.222229, 55.5555573
306, 333.333344, 55.5555573
307, 344.444458, 55.5555573
308, 355.555542, 55.5555573
309, 366.666656, 55.5555573
310, 377.777771, 55.5555573
311, 388.888885, 55.5555573
312, 400., 55.5555573
313, 411.111115, 55.5555573
314, 422.222229, 55.5555573
315, 433.333344, 55.5555573
316, 444.444458, 55.5555573
317, 455.555542, 55.5555573
318, 466.666656, 55.5555573
319, 477.777771, 55.5555573
320, 488.888885, 55.5555573
321, 500., 55.5555573
322, 511.111115, 55.5555573
323, 522.222229, 55.5555573
324, 533.333313, 55.5555573
325, 544.444458, 55.5555573
326, 555.555542, 55.5555573
327, 566.666687, 55.5555573
328, 577.777771, 55.5555573
329, 588.888916, 55.5555573
330, 600., 55.5555573
331, 0., 66.6666641
332, 11.1111107, 66.6666641
333, 22.2222214, 66.6666641
334, 33.3333321, 66.6666641
335, 44.4444427, 66.6666641
336, 55.5555573, 66.6666641
337, 66.6666641, 66.6666641
338, 77.7777786, 66.6666641
339, 88.8888855, 66.6666641
340, 100., 66.6666641
341, 111.111115, 66.6666641
342, 122.222221, 66.6666641
343, 133.333328, 66.6666641
344, 144.444443, 66.6666641
345, 155.555557, 66.6666641
346, 166.666672, 66.6666641
347, 177.777771, 66.6666641
348, 188.888885, 66.6666641
349, 200., 66.6666641
350, 211.111115, 66.6666641
351, 222.222229, 66.6666641
352, 233.333328, 66.6666641
353, 244.444443, 66.6666641
354, 255.555557, 66.6666641
355, 266.666656, 66.6666641
356, 277.777771, 66.6666641
357, 288.888885, 66.6666641
358, 300., 66.6666641
359, 311.111115, 66.6666641
360, 322.222229, 66.6666641
361, 333.333344, 66.6666641
362, 344.444458, 66.6666641
363, 355.555542, 66.6666641
364, 366.666656, 66.6666641
365, 377.777771, 66.6666641
366, 388.888885, 66.6666641
367, 400., 66.6666641
368, 411.111115, 66.6666641
369, 422.222229, 66.6666641
370, 433.333344, 66.6666641
371, 444.444458, 66.6666641
372, 455.555542, 66.6666641
373, 466.666656, 66.6666641
374, 477.777771, 66.6666641
375, 488.888885, 66.6666641
376, 500., 66.6666641
377, 511.111115, 66.6666641
378, 522.222229, 66.6666641
379, 533.333313, 66.6666641
380, 544.444458, 66.6666641
381, 555.555542, 66.6666641
382, 566.666687, 66.6666641
383, 577.777771, 66.6666641
384, 588.888916, 66.6666641
385, 600., 66.6666641
386, 0., 77.7777786
387, 11.1111107, 77.7777786
388, 22.2222214, 77.7777786
389, 33.3333321, 77.7777786
390, 44.4444427, 77.7777786
391, 55.5555573, 77.7777786
392, 66.6666641, 77.7777786
393, 77.7777786, 77.7777786
394, 88.8888855, 77.7777786
395, 100., 77.7777786
396, 111.111115, 77.7777786
397, 122.222221, 77.7777786
398, 133.333328, 77.7777786
399, 144.444443, 77.7777786
400, 155.555557, 77.7777786
401, 166.666672, 77.7777786
402, 177.777771, 77.7777786
403, 188.888885, 77.7777786
404, 200., 77.7777786
405, 211.111115, 77.7777786
406, 222.222229, 77.7777786
407, 233.333328, 77.7777786
408, 244.444443, 77.7777786
409, 255.555557, 77.7777786
410, 266.666656, 77.7777786
411, 277.777771, 77.7777786
412, 288.888885, 77.7777786
413, 300., 77.7777786
414, 311.111115, 77.7777786
415, 322.222229, 77.7777786
416, 333.333344, 77.7777786
417, 344.444458, 77.7777786
418, 355.555542, 77.7777786
419, 366.666656, 77.7777786
420, 377.777771, 77.7777786
421, 388.888885, 77.7777786
422, 400., 77.7777786
423, 411.111115, 77.7777786
424, 422.222229, 77.7777786
425, 433.333344, 77.7777786
426, 444.444458, 77.7777786
427, 455.555542, 77.7777786
428, 466.666656, 77.7777786
429, 477.777771, 77.7777786
430, 488.888885, 77.7777786
431, 500., 77.7777786
432, 511.111115, 77.7777786
433, 522.222229, 77.7777786
434, 533.333313, 77.7777786
435, 544.444458, 77.7777786
436, 555.555542, 77.7777786
437, 566.666687, 77.7777786
438, 577.777771, 77.7777786
439, 588.888916, 77.7777786
440, 600., 77.7777786
441, 0., 88.8888855
442, 11.1111107, 88.8888855
443, 22.2222214, 88.8888855
444, 33.3333321, 88.8888855
445, 44.4444427, 88.8888855
446, 55.5555573, 88.8888855
447, 66.6666641, 88.8888855
448, 77.7777786, 88.8888855
449, 88.8888855, 88.8888855
450, 100., 88.8888855
451, 111.111115, 88.8888855
452, 122.222221, 88.8888855
453, 133.333328, 88.8888855
454, 144.444443, 88.8888855
455, 155.555557, 88.8888855
456, 166.666672, 88.8888855
457, 177.777771, 88.8888855
458, 188.888885, 88.8888855
459, 200., 88.8888855
460, 211.111115, 88.8888855
461, 222.222229, 88.8888855
462, 233.333328, 88.8888855
463, 244.444443, 88.8888855
464, 255.555557, 88.8888855
465, 266.666656, 88.8888855
466, 277.777771, 88.8888855
467, 288.888885, 88.8888855
468, 300., 88.8888855
469, 311.111115, 88.8888855
470, 322.222229, 88.8888855
471, 333.333344, 88.8888855
472, 344.444458, 88.8888855
473, 355.555542, 88.8888855
474, 366.666656, 88.8888855
475, 377.777771, 88.8888855
476, 388.888885, 88.8888855
477, 400., 88.8888855
478, 411.111115, 88.8888855
479, 422.222229, 88.8888855
480, 433.333344, 88.8888855
481, 444.444458, 88.8888855
482, 455.555542, 88.8888855
483, 466.666656, 88.8888855
484, 477.777771, 88.8888855
485, 488.888885, 88.8888855
486, 500., 88.8888855
487, 511.111115, 88.8888855
488, 522.222229, 88.8888855
489, 533.333313, 88.8888855
490, 544.444458, 88.8888855
491, 555.555542, 88.8888855
492, 566.666687, 88.8888855
493, 577.777771, 88.8888855
494, 588.888916, 88.8888855
495, 600., 88.8888855
496, 0., 100.
497, 11.1111107, 100.
498, 22.2222214, 100.
499, 33.3333321, 100.
500, 44.4444427, 100.
501, 55.5555573, 100.
502, 66.6666641, 100.
503, 77.7777786, 100.
504, 88.8888855, 100.
505, 100., 100.
506, 111.111115, 100.
507, 122.222221, 100.
508, 133.333328, 100.
509, 144.444443, 100.
510, 155.555557, 100.
511, 166.666672, 100.
512, 177.777771, 100.
513, 188.888885, 100.
514, 200., 100.
515, 211.111115, 100.
516, 222.222229, 100.
517, 233.333328, 100.
518, 244.444443, 100.
519, 255.555557, 100.
520, 266.666656, 100.
521, 277.777771, 100.
522, 288.888885, 100.
523, 300., 100.
524, 311.111115, 100.
525, 322.222229, 100.
526, 333.333344, 100.
527, 344.444458, 100.
528, 355.555542, 100.
529, 366.666656, 100.
530, 377.777771, 100.
531, 388.888885, 100.
532, 400., 100.
533, 411.111115, 100.
534, 422.222229, 100.
535, 433.333344, 100.
536, 444.444458, 100.
537, 455.555542, 100.
538, 466.666656, 100.
539, 477.777771, 100.
540, 488.888885, 100.
541, 500., 100.
542, 511.111115, 100.
543, 522.222229, 100.
544, 533.333313, 100.
545, 544.444458, 100.
546, 555.555542, 100.
547, 566.666687, 100.
548, 577.777771, 100.
549, 588.888916, 100.
550, 600., 100.
*Element, type=CPE4P
1, 1, 2, 57, 56
2, 2, 3, 58, 57
3, 3, 4, 59, 58
4, 4, 5, 60, 59
5, 5, 6, 61, 60
6, 6, 7, 62, 61
7, 7, 8, 63, 62
8, 8, 9, 64, 63
9, 9, 10, 65, 64
10, 10, 11, 66, 65
11, 11, 12, 67, 66
12, 12, 13, 68, 67
13, 13, 14, 69, 68
14, 14, 15, 70, 69
15, 15, 16, 71, 70
16, 16, 17, 72, 71
17, 17, 18, 73, 72
18, 18, 19, 74, 73
19, 19, 20, 75, 74
20, 20, 21, 76, 75
21, 21, 22, 77, 76
22, 22, 23, 78, 77
23, 23, 24, 79, 78
24, 24, 25, 80, 79
25, 25, 26, 81, 80
26, 26, 27, 82, 81
27, 27, 28, 83, 82
28, 28, 29, 84, 83
29, 29, 30, 85, 84
30, 30, 31, 86, 85
31, 31, 32, 87, 86
32, 32, 33, 88, 87
33, 33, 34, 89, 88
34, 34, 35, 90, 89
35, 35, 36, 91, 90
36, 36, 37, 92, 91
37, 37, 38, 93, 92
38, 38, 39, 94, 93
39, 39, 40, 95, 94
40, 40, 41, 96, 95
41, 41, 42, 97, 96
42, 42, 43, 98, 97
43, 43, 44, 99, 98
44, 44, 45, 100, 99
45, 45, 46, 101, 100
46, 46, 47, 102, 101
47, 47, 48, 103, 102
48, 48, 49, 104, 103
49, 49, 50, 105, 104
50, 50, 51, 106, 105
51, 51, 52, 107, 106
52, 52, 53, 108, 107
53, 53, 54, 109, 108
54, 54, 55, 110, 109
55, 56, 57, 112, 111
56, 57, 58, 113, 112
57, 58, 59, 114, 113
58, 59, 60, 115, 114
59, 60, 61, 116, 115
60, 61, 62, 117, 116
61, 62, 63, 118, 117
62, 63, 64, 119, 118
63, 64, 65, 120, 119
64, 65, 66, 121, 120
65, 66, 67, 122, 121
66, 67, 68, 123, 122
67, 68, 69, 124, 123
68, 69, 70, 125, 124
69, 70, 71, 126, 125
70, 71, 72, 127, 126
71, 72, 73, 128, 127
72, 73, 74, 129, 128
73, 74, 75, 130, 129
74, 75, 76, 131, 130
75, 76, 77, 132, 131
76, 77, 78, 133, 132
77, 78, 79, 134, 133
78, 79, 80, 135, 134
79, 80, 81, 136, 135
80, 81, 82, 137, 136
81, 82, 83, 138, 137
82, 83, 84, 139, 138
83, 84, 85, 140, 139
84, 85, 86, 141, 140
85, 86, 87, 142, 141
86, 87, 88, 143, 142
87, 88, 89, 144, 143
88, 89, 90, 145, 144
89, 90, 91, 146, 145
90, 91, 92, 147, 146
91, 92, 93, 148, 147
92, 93, 94, 149, 148
93, 94, 95, 150, 149
94, 95, 96, 151, 150
95, 96, 97, 152, 151
96, 97, 98, 153, 152
97, 98, 99, 154, 153
98, 99, 100, 155, 154
99, 100, 101, 156, 155
100, 101, 102, 157, 156
101, 102, 103, 158, 157
102, 103, 104, 159, 158
103, 104, 105, 160, 159
104, 105, 106, 161, 160
105, 106, 107, 162, 161
106, 107, 108, 163, 162
107, 108, 109, 164, 163
108, 109, 110, 165, 164
109, 111, 112, 167, 166
110, 112, 113, 168, 167
111, 113, 114, 169, 168
112, 114, 115, 170, 169
113, 115, 116, 171, 170
114, 116, 117, 172, 171
115, 117, 118, 173, 172
116, 118, 119, 174, 173
117, 119, 120, 175, 174
118, 120, 121, 176, 175
119, 121, 122, 177, 176
120, 122, 123, 178, 177
121, 123, 124, 179, 178
122, 124, 125, 180, 179
123, 125, 126, 181, 180
124, 126, 127, 182, 181
125, 127, 128, 183, 182
126, 128, 129, 184, 183
127, 129, 130, 185, 184
128, 130, 131, 186, 185
129, 131, 132, 187, 186
130, 132, 133, 188, 187
131, 133, 134, 189, 188
132, 134, 135, 190, 189
133, 135, 136, 191, 190
134, 136, 137, 192, 191
135, 137, 138, 193, 192
136, 138, 139, 194, 193
137, 139, 140, 195, 194
138, 140, 141, 196, 195
139, 141, 142, 197, 196
140, 142, 143, 198, 197
141, 143, 144, 199, 198
142, 144, 145, 200, 199
143, 145, 146, 201, 200
144, 146, 147, 202, 201
145, 147, 148, 203, 202
146, 148, 149, 204, 203
147, 149, 150, 205, 204
148, 150, 151, 206, 205
149, 151, 152, 207, 206
150, 152, 153, 208, 207
151, 153, 154, 209, 208
152, 154, 155, 210, 209
153, 155, 156, 211, 210
154, 156, 157, 212, 211
155, 157, 158, 213, 212
156, 158, 159, 214, 213
157, 159, 160, 215, 214
158, 160, 161, 216, 215
159, 161, 162, 217, 216
160, 162, 163, 218, 217
161, 163, 164, 219, 218
162, 164, 165, 220, 219
163, 166, 167, 222, 221
164, 167, 168, 223, 222
165, 168, 169, 224, 223
166, 169, 170, 225, 224
167, 170, 171, 226, 225
168, 171, 172, 227, 226
169, 172, 173, 228, 227
170, 173, 174, 229, 228
171, 174, 175, 230, 229
172, 175, 176, 231, 230
173, 176, 177, 232, 231
174, 177, 178, 233, 232
175, 178, 179, 234, 233
176, 179, 180, 235, 234
177, 180, 181, 236, 235
178, 181, 182, 237, 236
179, 182, 183, 238, 237
180, 183, 184, 239, 238
181, 184, 185, 240, 239
182, 185, 186, 241, 240
183, 186, 187, 242, 241
184, 187, 188, 243, 242
185, 188, 189, 244, 243
186, 189, 190, 245, 244
187, 190, 191, 246, 245
188, 191, 192, 247, 246
189, 192, 193, 248, 247
190, 193, 194, 249, 248
191, 194, 195, 250, 249
192, 195, 196, 251, 250
193, 196, 197, 252, 251
194, 197, 198, 253, 252
195, 198, 199, 254, 253
196, 199, 200, 255, 254
197, 200, 201, 256, 255
198, 201, 202, 257, 256
199, 202, 203, 258, 257
200, 203, 204, 259, 258
201, 204, 205, 260, 259
202, 205, 206, 261, 260
203, 206, 207, 262, 261
204, 207, 208, 263, 262
205, 208, 209, 264, 263
206, 209, 210, 265, 264
207, 210, 211, 266, 265
208, 211, 212, 267, 266
209, 212, 213, 268, 267
210, 213, 214, 269, 268
211, 214, 215, 270, 269
212, 215, 216, 271, 270
213, 216, 217, 272, 271
214, 217, 218, 273, 272
215, 218, 219, 274, 273
216, 219, 220, 275, 274
217, 221, 222, 277, 276
218, 222, 223, 278, 277
219, 223, 224, 279, 278
220, 224, 225, 280, 279
221, 225, 226, 281, 280
222, 226, 227, 282, 281
223, 227, 228, 283, 282
224, 228, 229, 284, 283
225, 229, 230, 285, 284
226, 230, 231, 286, 285
227, 231, 232, 287, 286
228, 232, 233, 288, 287
229, 233, 234, 289, 288
230, 234, 235, 290, 289
231, 235, 236, 291, 290
232, 236, 237, 292, 291
233, 237, 238, 293, 292
234, 238, 239, 294, 293
235, 239, 240, 295, 294
236, 240, 241, 296, 295
237, 241, 242, 297, 296
238, 242, 243, 298, 297
239, 243, 244, 299, 298
240, 244, 245, 300, 299
241, 245, 246, 301, 300
242, 246, 247, 302, 301
243, 247, 248, 303, 302
244, 248, 249, 304, 303
245, 249, 250, 305, 304
246, 250, 251, 306, 305
247, 251, 252, 307, 306
248, 252, 253, 308, 307
249, 253, 254, 309, 308
250, 254, 255, 310, 309
251, 255, 256, 311, 310
252, 256, 257, 312, 311
253, 257, 258, 313, 312
254, 258, 259, 314, 313
255, 259, 260, 315, 314
256, 260, 261, 316, 315
257, 261, 262, 317, 316
258, 262, 263, 318, 317
259, 263, 264, 319, 318
260, 264, 265, 320, 319
261, 265, 266, 321, 320
262, 266, 267, 322, 321
263, 267, 268, 323, 322
264, 268, 269, 324, 323
265, 269, 270, 325, 324
266, 270, 271, 326, 325
267, 271, 272, 327, 326
268, 272, 273, 328, 327
269, 273, 274, 329, 328
270, 274, 275, 330, 329
271, 276, 277, 332, 331
272, 277, 278, 333, 332
273, 278, 279, 334, 333
274, 279, 280, 335, 334
275, 280, 281, 336, 335
276, 281, 282, 337, 336
277, 282, 283, 338, 337
278, 283, 284, 339, 338
279, 284, 285, 340, 339
280, 285, 286, 341, 340
281, 286, 287, 342, 341
282, 287, 288, 343, 342
283, 288, 289, 344, 343
284, 289, 290, 345, 344
285, 290, 291, 346, 345
286, 291, 292, 347, 346
287, 292, 293, 348, 347
288, 293, 294, 349, 348
289, 294, 295, 350, 349
290, 295, 296, 351, 350
291, 296, 297, 352, 351
292, 297, 298, 353, 352
293, 298, 299, 354, 353
294, 299, 300, 355, 354
295, 300, 301, 356, 355
296, 301, 302, 357, 356
297, 302, 303, 358, 357
298, 303, 304, 359, 358
299, 304, 305, 360, 359
300, 305, 306, 361, 360
301, 306, 307, 362, 361
302, 307, 308, 363, 362
303, 308, 309, 364, 363
304, 309, 310, 365, 364
305, 310, 311, 366, 365
306, 311, 312, 367, 366
307, 312, 313, 368, 367
308, 313, 314, 369, 368
309, 314, 315, 370, 369
310, 315, 316, 371, 370
311, 316, 317, 372, 371
312, 317, 318, 373, 372
313, 318, 319, 374, 373
314, 319, 320, 375, 374
315, 320, 321, 376, 375
316, 321, 322, 377, 376
317, 322, 323, 378, 377
318, 323, 324, 379, 378
319, 324, 325, 380, 379
320, 325, 326, 381, 380
321, 326, 327, 382, 381
322, 327, 328, 383, 382
323, 328, 329, 384, 383
324, 329, 330, 385, 384
325, 331, 332, 387, 386
326, 332, 333, 388, 387
327, 333, 334, 389, 388
328, 334, 335, 390, 389
329, 335, 336, 391, 390
330, 336, 337, 392, 391
331, 337, 338, 393, 392
332, 338, 339, 394, 393
333, 339, 340, 395, 394
334, 340, 341, 396, 395
335, 341, 342, 397, 396
336, 342, 343, 398, 397
337, 343, 344, 399, 398
338, 344, 345, 400, 399
339, 345, 346, 401, 400
340, 346, 347, 402, 401
341, 347, 348, 403, 402
342, 348, 349, 404, 403
343, 349, 350, 405, 404
344, 350, 351, 406, 405
345, 351, 352, 407, 406
346, 352, 353, 408, 407
347, 353, 354, 409, 408
348, 354, 355, 410, 409
349, 355, 356, 411, 410
350, 356, 357, 412, 411
351, 357, 358, 413, 412
352, 358, 359, 414, 413
353, 359, 360, 415, 414
354, 360, 361, 416, 415
355, 361, 362, 417, 416
356, 362, 363, 418, 417
357, 363, 364, 419, 418
358, 364, 365, 420, 419
359, 365, 366, 421, 420
360, 366, 367, 422, 421
361, 367, 368, 423, 422
362, 368, 369, 424, 423
363, 369, 370, 425, 424
364, 370, 371, 426, 425
365, 371, 372, 427, 426
366, 372, 373, 428, 427
367, 373, 374, 429, 428
368, 374, 375, 430, 429
369, 375, 376, 431, 430
370, 376, 377, 432, 431
371, 377, 378, 433, 432
372, 378, 379, 434, 433
373, 379, 380, 435, 434
374, 380, 381, 436, 435
375, 381, 382, 437, 436
376, 382, 383, 438, 437
377, 383, 384, 439, 438
378, 384, 385, 440, 439
379, 386, 387, 442, 441
380, 387, 388, 443, 442
381, 388, 389, 444, 443
382, 389, 390, 445, 444
383, 390, 391, 446, 445
384, 391, 392, 447, 446
385, 392, 393, 448, 447
386, 393, 394, 449, 448
387, 394, 395, 450, 449
388, 395, 396, 451, 450
389, 396, 397, 452, 451
390, 397, 398, 453, 452
391, 398, 399, 454, 453
392, 399, 400, 455, 454
393, 400, 401, 456, 455
394, 401, 402, 457, 456
395, 402, 403, 458, 457
396, 403, 404, 459, 458
397, 404, 405, 460, 459
398, 405, 406, 461, 460
399, 406, 407, 462, 461
400, 407, 408, 463, 462
401, 408, 409, 464, 463
402, 409, 410, 465, 464
403, 410, 411, 466, 465
404, 411, 412, 467, 466
405, 412, 413, 468, 467
406, 413, 414, 469, 468
407, 414, 415, 470, 469
408, 415, 416, 471, 470
409, 416, 417, 472, 471
410, 417, 418, 473, 472
411, 418, 419, 474, 473
412, 419, 420, 475, 474
413, 420, 421, 476, 475
414, 421, 422, 477, 476
415, 422, 423, 478, 477
416, 423, 424, 479, 478
417, 424, 425, 480, 479
418, 425, 426, 481, 480
419, 426, 427, 482, 481
420, 427, 428, 483, 482
421, 428, 429, 484, 483
422, 429, 430, 485, 484
423, 430, 431, 486, 485
424, 431, 432, 487, 486
425, 432, 433, 488, 487
426, 433, 434, 489, 488
427, 434, 435, 490, 489
428, 435, 436, 491, 490
429, 436, 437, 492, 491
430, 437, 438, 493, 492
431, 438, 439, 494, 493
432, 439, 440, 495, 494
433, 441, 442, 497, 496
434, 442, 443, 498, 497
435, 443, 444, 499, 498
436, 444, 445, 500, 499
437, 445, 446, 501, 500
438, 446, 447, 502, 501
439, 447, 448, 503, 502
440, 448, 449, 504, 503
441, 449, 450, 505, 504
442, 450, 451, 506, 505
443, 451, 452, 507, 506
444, 452, 453, 508, 507
445, 453, 454, 509, 508
446, 454, 455, 510, 509
447, 455, 456, 511, 510
448, 456, 457, 512, 511
449, 457, 458, 513, 512
450, 458, 459, 514, 513
451, 459, 460, 515, 514
452, 460, 461, 516, 515
453, 461, 462, 517, 516
454, 462, 463, 518, 517
455, 463, 464, 519, 518
456, 464, 465, 520, 519
457, 465, 466, 521, 520
458, 466, 467, 522, 521
459, 467, 468, 523, 522
460, 468, 469, 524, 523
461, 469, 470, 525, 524
462, 470, 471, 526, 525
463, 471, 472, 527, 526
464, 472, 473, 528, 527
465, 473, 474, 529, 528
466, 474, 475, 530, 529
467, 475, 476, 531, 530
468, 476, 477, 532, 531
469, 477, 478, 533, 532
470, 478, 479, 534, 533
471, 479, 480, 535, 534
472, 480, 481, 536, 535
473, 481, 482, 537, 536
474, 482, 483, 538, 537
475, 483, 484, 539, 538
476, 484, 485, 540, 539
477, 485, 486, 541, 540
478, 486, 487, 542, 541
479, 487, 488, 543, 542
480, 488, 489, 544, 543
481, 489, 490, 545, 544
482, 490, 491, 546, 545
483, 491, 492, 547, 546
484, 492, 493, 548, 547
485, 493, 494, 549, 548
486, 494, 495, 550, 549
*Nset, nset=_PickedSet2, internal, generate
1, 550, 1
*Elset, elset=_PickedSet2, internal, generate
1, 486, 1
** Region: (Section-1icked)
*Elset, elset=_PickedSet2, internal, generate
1, 486, 1
** Section: Section-1
*Solid Section, elset=_PickedSet2, material=Material-1
1.,
*End Part
**
**
** ASSEMBLY
**
*Assembly, name=Assembly
**
*Instance, name=Part-1-1, part=Part-1
*End Instance
**
*Nset, nset=_PickedSet4, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 55, 1
*Elset, elset=_PickedSet4, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 54, 1
*Nset, nset=_PickedSet5, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
55, 550, 55
*Elset, elset=_PickedSet5, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
54, 486, 54
*Nset, nset=_PickedSet6, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 496, 55
*Elset, elset=_PickedSet6, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 433, 54
*Nset, nset=_PickedSet7, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 550, 1
*Elset, elset=_PickedSet7, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 486, 1
*Nset, nset=ALL, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 550, 1
*Elset, elset=ALL, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 486, 1
*Nset, nset=ALLN, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 550, 1
*Elset, elset=ALLN, instance=Part-1-1, generate
1, 486, 1
*Nset, nset=_PickedSet11, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
496, 550, 1
*Elset, elset=_PickedSet11, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
433, 486, 1
*Nset, nset=_PickedSet11_PP_, internal, instance=Part-1-1, generate
496, 550, 1
*End Assembly
**
** MATERIALS
**
*Material, name=Material-1
*Density
2066.,
*Elastic
1e+07, 0.28
*Permeability, specific=10000.
2.4e-06, 0.6
**
** BOUNDARY CONDITIONS
**
** Name: BC-1 Type: Displacement/Rotation
*Boundary
_PickedSet4, 1, 1
_PickedSet4, 2, 2
_PickedSet4, 6, 6
** Name: BC-2 Type: Displacement/Rotation
*Boundary
_PickedSet5, 1, 1
** Name: BC-3 Type: Displacement/Rotation
*Boundary
_PickedSet6, 1, 1
_PickedSet6, 2, 2
_PickedSet6, 6, 6
*Initial Condition,Type= Stress, Geostatic
ALL,-1296769,0,0,100, 0.30, 0.30
*Initial Condition,Type=Ratio
ALL,0.3
*Initial Condition, Type=Pore Pressure
ALL,0,100,1000000,0
** ----------------------------------------------------------------
**
** STEP: Step-1
**
*Step, name=Step-1
Geostatic
*Geostatic
**
** BOUNDARY CONDITIONS
**
** Name: BC-4 Type: Pore pressure
*Boundary
_PickedSet11_PP_, 8, 8
**
** LOADS
**
** Name: Load-1 Type: Gravity
*Dload
_PickedSet7, GRAV, 10., 0., -1.
**
** OUTPUT REQUESTS
**
*Restart, write, frequency=0
**
** FIELD OUTPUT: F-Output-1
**
*Output, field, variable=PRESELECT
**
** HISTORY OUTPUT: H-Output-1
**
*Output, history, variable=PRESELECT
*End Step
___________________________________________________________
*Heading
** Job name: FreeAdvancingFront Model name: Model-1
*Preprint, echo=NO, model=NO, history=NO, contact=NO
**
** PARTS
**
*Part, name=Part-1
*Node
1, 0., 0.
2, 600., 0.
3, 600., 100.
4, 0., 100.
5, 11.1111107, 0.
6, 22.2222214, 0.
7, 33.3333321, 0.
8, 44.4444427, 0.
9, 55.5555573, 0.
10, 66.6666641, 0.
11, 77.7777786, 0.
12, 88.8888855, 0.
13, 100., 0.
14, 111.111115, 0.
15, 122.222221, 0.
16, 133.333328, 0.
17, 144.444443, 0.
18, 155.555557, 0.
19, 166.666672, 0.
20, 177.777771, 0.
21, 188.888885, 0.
22, 200., 0.
23, 211.111115, 0.
24, 222.222229, 0.
25, 233.333328, 0.
26, 244.444443, 0.
27, 255.555557, 0.
28, 266.666656, 0.
29, 277.777771, 0.
30, 288.888885, 0.
31, 300., 0.
32, 311.111115, 0.
33, 322.222229, 0.
34, 333.333344, 0.
35, 344.444458, 0.
36, 355.555542, 0.
37, 366.666656, 0.
38, 377.777771, 0.
39, 388.888885, 0.
40, 400., 0.
41, 411.111115, 0.
42, 422.222229, 0.
43, 433.333344, 0.
44, 444.444458, 0.
45, 455.555542, 0.
46, 466.666656, 0.
47, 477.777771, 0.
48, 488.888885, 0.
49, 500., 0.
50, 511.111115, 0.
51, 522.222229, 0.
52, 533.333313, 0.
53, 544.444458, 0.
54, 555.555542, 0.
55, 566.666687, 0.
56, 577.777771, 0.
57, 588.888916, 0.
58, 600., 11.1111107
59, 600., 22.2222214
60, 600., 33.3333321
61, 600., 44.4444427
62, 600., 55.5555573
63, 600., 66.6666641
64, 600., 77.7777786
65, 600., 88.8888855
66, 588.461548, 100.
67, 576.923096, 100.
68, 565.384644, 100.
69, 553.84613, 100.
70, 542.307678, 100.
71, 530.769226, 100.
72, 519.230774, 100.
73, 507.692322, 100.
74, 496.153839, 100.
75, 484.615387, 100.
76, 473.076935, 100.
77, 461.538452, 100.
78, 450., 100.
79, 438.461548, 100.
80, 426.923065, 100.
81, 415.384613, 100.
82, 403.846161, 100.
83, 392.307678, 100.
84, 380.769226, 100.
85, 369.230774, 100.
86, 357.692322, 100.
87, 346.153839, 100.
88, 334.615387, 100.
89, 323.076935, 100.
90, 311.538452, 100.
91, 300., 100.
92, 288.461548, 100.
93, 276.923065, 100.
94, 265.384613, 100.
95, 253.846161, 100.
96, 242.307693, 100.
97, 230.769226, 100.
98, 219.230774, 100.
99, 207.692307, 100.
100, 196.153839, 100.
101, 184.615387, 100.
102, 173.07692, 100.
103, 161.538467, 100.
104, 150., 100.
105, 138.461533, 100.
106, 126.92308, 100.
107, 115.384613, 100.
108, 103.846153, 100.
109, 92.3076935, 100.
110, 80.7692337, 100.
111, 69.2307663, 100.
112, 57.6923065, 100.
113, 46.1538467, 100.
114, 34.6153831, 100.
115, 23.0769234, 100.
116, 11.5384617, 100.
117, 0., 88.8888855
118, 0., 77.7777786
119, 0., 66.6666641
120, 0., 55.5555573
121, 0., 44.4444427
122, 0., 33.3333321
123, 0., 22.2222214
124, 0., 11.1111107
125, 11.2718477, 89.0921631
126, 10.8924732, 66.9372559
127, 45.2704124, 89.1032257
128, 77.2444153, 10.7467422
129, 80.3759384, 88.7601089
130, 110.848495, 10.5819044
131, 116.395599, 89.2189484
132, 144.102905, 10.4507618
133, 151.454102, 89.4722366
134, 177.328552, 10.4547443
135, 188.478058, 10.4726534
136, 197.58815, 89.6588058
137, 221.700058, 10.6425066
138, 232.187607, 89.6567688
139, 255.147934, 10.6664095
140, 266.749634, 89.65625
141, 288.646973, 10.6108828
142, 301.256714, 89.6211395
143, 312.762756, 89.6560822
144, 324.250671, 89.6968918
145, 355.530304, 10.5694904
146, 358.797363, 89.6434021
147, 388.971344, 10.5442801
148, 393.370453, 89.5797043
149, 422.349091, 10.4520912
150, 428.092346, 89.4084167
151, 439.558441, 89.4264755
152, 455.620483, 10.4068623
153, 450.954559, 89.4585495
154, 466.752411, 10.3984337
155, 462.346985, 89.4704666
156, 477.848907, 10.3816624
157, 473.754669, 89.4557114
158, 488.955414, 10.3396711
159, 485.24054, 89.3796387
160, 500.0961, 10.3303881
161, 496.85788, 89.2404709
162, 511.290558, 10.3707609
163, 508.552551, 89.1758118
164, 522.458069, 10.4434423
165, 520.237366, 89.4141846
166, 533.60321, 10.5388155
167, 531.77594, 89.791214
168, 544.735657, 10.6344919
169, 543.200562, 89.9452591
170, 554.371399, 89.5534592
171, 565.687927, 89.1940079
172, 588.975586, 44.3625526
173, 589.023193, 33.143013
174, 589.052673, 21.9916
175, 589.013855, 10.9484921
176, 566.973267, 10.7341042
177, 555.87146, 10.7072945
178, 588.902283, 55.6026535
179, 588.788147, 66.7682495
180, 577.128479, 89.0407104
181, 444.578552, 10.3735228
182, 433.577271, 10.3686514
183, 416.484894, 89.5167236
184, 404.862305, 89.5998688
185, 411.305939, 10.4544859
186, 400.234619, 10.4753666
187, 381.790588, 89.6519852
188, 370.254913, 89.7017593
189, 377.901978, 10.5245132
190, 366.809631, 10.5235367
191, 347.259155, 89.6983109
192, 335.699921, 89.7480469
193, 344.448761, 10.5423679
194, 333.317627, 10.5511351
195, 322.146484, 10.5548563
196, 311.037109, 10.5473013
197, 299.897552, 10.5562696
198, 289.722198, 89.6853256
199, 278.156067, 89.7268906
200, 277.528046, 10.6024046
201, 266.430695, 10.6031132
202, 255.221725, 89.6780548
203, 243.666168, 89.7066422
204, 244.055588, 10.6351433
205, 232.956711, 10.6128092
206, 220.649475, 89.7029037
207, 209.086609, 89.7240448
208, 210.648392, 10.5606699
209, 199.60199, 10.488102
210, 186.080902, 89.6379166
211, 174.535095, 89.5920258
212, 162.974976, 89.5642624
213, 166.280853, 10.4127598
214, 155.220581, 10.409193
215, 139.828629, 89.4717712
216, 128.130493, 89.4192123
217, 133.030624, 10.4925995
218, 121.957649, 10.5126734
219, 104.398125, 88.9441452
220, 92.3644562, 88.7268906
221, 99.7022095, 10.6458359
222, 88.4936295, 10.7288227
223, 68.4524994, 88.9126358
224, 56.7647514, 89.040184
225, 66.0441284, 10.4418697
226, 54.833992, 10.2543621
227, 33.9156609, 89.1959915
228, 11.0683613, 78.0642548
229, 10.8000937, 55.7507896
230, 44.0022469, 10.5877476
231, 10.8306465, 44.5221062
232, 33.087883, 10.9011374
233, 10.920373, 33.3563728
234, 22.0513992, 11.0267992
235, 21.7961578, 67.1463318
236, 132.755463, 20.8754177
237, 187.269089, 79.5381317
238, 277.693054, 20.9429111
239, 322.492523, 20.8686447
240, 356.02002, 20.8551941
241, 389.596436, 20.8176079
242, 423.054382, 20.659708
243, 445.193542, 20.5769196
244, 456.323975, 20.5259438
245, 467.37442, 20.4515858
246, 478.400024, 20.3208675
247, 489.402161, 20.1398659
248, 500.364288, 20.0351219
249, 511.326416, 20.1697197
250, 522.435852, 20.5826302
251, 532.961243, 80.0959854
252, 533.550293, 21.008215
253, 578.112427, 21.7932835
254, 567.103149, 21.6625977
255, 555.972595, 21.5510693
256, 543.80835, 80.5171661
257, 577.609802, 55.611393
258, 588.678162, 77.8796387
259, 440.046265, 79.2123718
260, 411.972473, 20.7174664
261, 378.466278, 20.8336105
262, 344.906555, 20.8440247
263, 333.757172, 20.8334637
264, 288.917023, 20.8970642
265, 267.698273, 79.6116028
266, 255.213516, 21.0021858
267, 244.078445, 20.9800949
268, 221.628784, 20.9875107
269, 210.532333, 20.9164124
270, 166.070724, 20.7628193
271, 143.85791, 20.8065186
272, 117.341797, 79.0321426
273, 99.592514, 20.9199295
274, 44.4599686, 78.3260803
275, 65.2858124, 20.4001675
276, 33.2894287, 78.3193512
277, 44.2307587, 21.3599796
278, 33.2883072, 22.1141415
279, 22.0501118, 22.2242336
280, 22.5837555, 89.1879807
281, 325.032593, 79.6205139
282, 451.300476, 79.2152176
283, 462.583435, 79.18853
284, 473.900635, 79.1312943
285, 485.394043, 78.94561
286, 497.286621, 78.6449585
287, 509.403778, 78.5701447
288, 521.487976, 79.2467499
289, 554.183838, 78.9091949
290, 544.721802, 21.3482018
291, 578.057251, 32.9622421
292, 577.982849, 10.8450756
293, 577.842102, 44.2776184
294, 565.55481, 78.0725174
295, 577.285767, 66.7829666
296, 577.158447, 77.9187012
297, 428.522034, 79.3398666
298, 434.278534, 20.5542698
299, 416.993469, 79.4471207
300, 405.39624, 79.5101318
301, 393.864807, 79.5510101
302, 400.880249, 20.7385654
303, 382.317932, 79.6100998
304, 370.874054, 79.6259308
305, 359.38327, 79.6317978
306, 367.336273, 20.8122616
307, 347.897919, 79.6781311
308, 336.412903, 79.6938553
309, 313.552887, 79.6226654
310, 300.159912, 20.8596096
311, 311.371063, 20.8464642
312, 302.028656, 79.6325836
313, 290.555634, 79.6585541
314, 279.009033, 79.6797791
315, 266.565094, 20.9308071
316, 256.19751, 79.6331635
317, 244.67659, 79.6380157
318, 232.941422, 20.9442654
319, 233.1595, 79.6590958
320, 221.692352, 79.6874161
321, 210.168518, 79.6749039
322, 198.634125, 79.6551361
323, 199.458466, 20.8341637
324, 177.184784, 20.7710361
325, 188.384033, 20.7660046
326, 175.70607, 79.4729691
327, 164.180664, 79.404747
328, 154.993881, 20.7599239
329, 152.604645, 79.3640518
330, 140.947479, 79.3732529
331, 129.196991, 79.3153534
332, 121.711258, 20.8564663
333, 110.696518, 20.791975
334, 92.3624268, 77.7878418
335, 105.005676, 78.4581604
336, 79.7713318, 78.1823044
337, 88.2223587, 21.182745
338, 76.6117172, 21.3451385
339, 55.8730469, 78.4078979
340, 67.6115341, 78.4668045
341, 54.4065437, 19.8286133
342, 22.1695118, 78.2331696
343, 21.6935501, 55.9458199
344, 21.8658123, 44.6436386
345, 22.1087971, 33.4262772
346, 10.9980555, 22.2216225
347, 416.933441, 69.5995712
348, 446.363892, 30.5057049
349, 566.593872, 44.1123848
350, 551.281616, 66.858696
351, 428.29715, 69.508934
352, 435.357147, 30.5460815
353, 401.816925, 30.82481
354, 368.134247, 30.8958225
355, 177.229553, 30.8654556
356, 92.2158432, 66.4815369
357, 334.4422, 30.90135
358, 468.523346, 30.2912636
359, 532.945557, 31.4093018
360, 534.732849, 70.8952713
361, 405.325684, 69.6886063
362, 370.968658, 69.7795258
363, 336.712128, 69.7875977
364, 313.867462, 69.7836456
365, 290.946259, 69.791748
366, 255.630966, 31.022543
367, 256.705658, 69.7788467
368, 245.206924, 69.8114319
369, 222.341949, 69.8304672
370, 165.055756, 69.5663147
371, 154.855972, 30.9244766
372, 78.6912003, 68.4636078
373, 55.268734, 68.135582
374, 457.54306, 30.3765278
375, 439.707977, 69.3787231
376, 450.934296, 69.2834625
377, 462.183136, 69.2004318
378, 473.439941, 69.1091995
379, 485.054688, 68.9361877
380, 510.269043, 68.1272888
381, 521.826111, 30.3114738
382, 566.930908, 32.8073273
383, 544.252686, 32.0969582
384, 555.663696, 32.564682
385, 413.032959, 30.7342415
386, 379.378021, 30.8807259
387, 348.039948, 69.8124084
388, 266.986267, 30.9553261
389, 44.0359192, 67.6811981
390, 32.8144455, 56.2651329
391, 33.3041649, 44.9415092
392, 479.546539, 29.9894161
393, 490.294098, 29.6018314
394, 500.745575, 29.2842999
395, 497.231232, 68.5039215
396, 511.129272, 29.3376484
397, 523.151917, 69.3950653
398, 543.271179, 73.079483
399, 565.801758, 55.5381927
400, 565.08136, 66.7671585
401, 424.234955, 30.6056213
402, 393.826385, 69.7398758
403, 382.271088, 69.7953033
404, 390.626526, 30.8266411
405, 359.450867, 69.81073
406, 356.889404, 30.8848896
407, 345.697968, 30.874855
408, 325.189209, 69.8077087
409, 302.31424, 69.8094025
410, 311.950958, 30.9182186
411, 323.216736, 30.8772736
412, 300.732697, 30.9042835
413, 289.483917, 30.9046154
414, 268.12085, 69.7781677
415, 279.403778, 69.8246155
416, 278.25415, 30.9036102
417, 233.662384, 69.8505859
418, 244.419464, 31.0168419
419, 233.182312, 31.0066395
420, 221.920242, 30.9964676
421, 210.829468, 69.8294754
422, 188.041672, 69.7014236
423, 199.32016, 69.814888
424, 210.720993, 30.975666
425, 176.470734, 69.6738663
426, 199.576477, 30.9207745
427, 188.464935, 30.8476887
428, 153.475861, 69.5698013
429, 166.059967, 30.851284
430, 141.819046, 69.6259689
431, 143.632294, 30.9830379
432, 118.32238, 69.3904724
433, 130.11261, 69.6164627
434, 132.455063, 30.9940701
435, 121.409004, 30.8948689
436, 106.036171, 68.6654053
437, 110.565529, 30.6313419
438, 88.5322647, 30.9055634
439, 99.7528534, 30.4461746
440, 54.9063339, 27.4560776
441, 66.803566, 68.6477737
442, 75.704216, 32.6959114
443, 63.619751, 29.8206844
444, 32.9521866, 67.3710709
445, 47.0622177, 33.5299263
446, 33.8909492, 33.5469856
447, 447.766571, 40.2207565
448, 436.616272, 40.3260078
449, 313.706573, 60.0626717
450, 438.894196, 59.6356544
451, 393.342438, 60.0417442
452, 402.925354, 40.6358032
453, 336.452484, 60.0658455
454, 256.134003, 40.776619
455, 154.078583, 59.9623795
456, 458.932068, 40.1237984
457, 554.900208, 43.7306404
458, 324.966492, 60.0912132
459, 55.297718, 58.050621
460, 470.049561, 40.0281219
461, 481.087616, 39.7807808
462, 491.733521, 39.3209457
463, 538.155029, 62.3898659
464, 359.177094, 60.0632477
465, 346.507477, 40.7029953
466, 302.239288, 60.0793877
467, 312.670929, 40.7133789
468, 301.367645, 40.7197609
469, 267.507263, 40.718441
470, 222.541473, 60.1154747
471, 233.525665, 40.8070526
472, 188.41069, 60.0304832
473, 199.740402, 40.7642937
474, 154.715759, 40.7698212
475, 119.385628, 59.9080505
476, 120.992508, 40.6526108
477, 108.083496, 59.1973076
478, 45.0217972, 45.7911263
479, 76.7126617, 59.4225998
480, 543.018738, 42.8120537
481, 416.267456, 59.8852234
482, 414.226624, 40.5146027
483, 245.326309, 60.1065407
484, 86.0452271, 57.6570091
485, 427.514526, 59.7967224
486, 461.330414, 59.4256439
487, 472.594635, 59.4471397
488, 531.390564, 41.3898354
489, 404.719391, 60.0016022
490, 370.545837, 60.0672607
491, 347.712616, 60.0888557
492, 484.146667, 59.3922081
493, 501.705353, 38.3710976
494, 510.934601, 57.0621223
495, 496.306946, 58.9165001
496, 520.559387, 39.3887672
497, 510.942017, 37.7754707
498, 525.487366, 60.1925163
499, 425.448761, 40.3979988
500, 380.361206, 40.6894569
501, 381.833466, 60.0851784
502, 391.648529, 40.655098
503, 369.087952, 40.6808624
504, 357.78833, 40.68787
505, 335.242004, 40.6927109
506, 290.833527, 60.0889969
507, 323.940643, 40.6864929
508, 290.065765, 40.7087402
509, 268.15744, 60.0506134
510, 256.67627, 60.0989609
511, 279.398834, 60.0998459
512, 278.789856, 40.689743
513, 233.810822, 60.1415558
514, 244.84317, 40.7835999
515, 222.25238, 40.789711
516, 211.083679, 60.1299934
517, 199.644791, 60.1165581
518, 210.971863, 40.7789574
519, 165.5466, 59.9688606
520, 188.557037, 40.705265
521, 176.908615, 60.0257988
522, 177.273331, 40.6883163
523, 166.009079, 40.6935501
524, 142.456635, 60.0574875
525, 143.339554, 40.8304367
526, 130.884384, 60.0660667
527, 132.070068, 40.7715836
528, 110.303566, 40.1248817
529, 98.0004807, 57.3159523
530, 90.102623, 39.8139381
531, 100.045937, 39.5499344
532, 91.2656479, 47.9638138
533, 75.2399826, 44.7636757
534, 69.0338974, 41.5182686
535, 81.1296082, 41.5780258
536, 66.2530136, 59.2448425
537, 449.066284, 49.8516273
538, 369.875305, 50.3827896
539, 44.2129784, 56.944088
540, 460.207153, 49.8058167
541, 335.884094, 50.3984032
542, 313.233002, 50.4020233
543, 222.438049, 50.4747086
544, 245.124741, 50.4649277
545, 188.509552, 50.4095879
546, 154.427307, 50.4153519
547, 120.333939, 50.2338409
548, 109.607315, 49.5141068
549, 415.284363, 50.2167702
550, 59.2158508, 38.4649963
551, 426.517517, 50.1161308
552, 471.426971, 49.8168182
553, 528.762024, 51.0169792
554, 553.410461, 54.9445992
555, 510.907135, 44.6173515
556, 540.897217, 52.9952621
557, 381.15387, 50.3981895
558, 358.517303, 50.400341
559, 301.841919, 50.4209747
560, 267.873993, 50.4019356
561, 211.066666, 50.4833641
562, 131.539825, 50.4247398
563, 142.919159, 50.4639015
564, 99.8745422, 48.3599434
565, 66.6294556, 50.2412338
566, 403.871277, 50.3285065
567, 256.437347, 50.4463654
568, 324.491547, 50.4081917
569, 279.147034, 50.409729
570, 75.514122, 51.1762505
571, 482.692352, 49.74403
572, 517.729126, 48.1517105
573, 347.14151, 50.4108925
574, 493.910553, 49.3023109
575, 392.502716, 50.3777847
576, 290.462769, 50.4254723
577, 233.706268, 50.4843025
578, 199.726273, 50.4598999
579, 165.807037, 50.3836555
580, 83.4995728, 49.5841217
581, 56.4439964, 48.0636978
582, 437.761627, 50.0161781
583, 177.115662, 50.3996582
584, 11.0438356, 11.0734539
585, 588.576355, 88.9701767
586, 450.038757, 59.5478821
587, 504.437805, 47.5540237
588, 91.7460709, 54.3675041
*Element, type=CPE4P
1, 229, 120, 121, 231
2, 125, 117, 118, 228
3, 228, 126, 235, 342
4, 223, 129, 110, 111
5, 12, 13, 221, 222
6, 219, 131, 107, 108
7, 236, 217, 132, 271
8, 134, 213, 19, 20
9, 18, 19, 213, 214
10, 21, 22, 209, 135
11, 326, 211, 212, 327
12, 22, 23, 208, 209
13, 139, 204, 26, 27
14, 25, 26, 204, 205
15, 141, 200, 29, 30
16, 238, 200, 141, 264
17, 195, 196, 32, 33
18, 239, 195, 194, 263
19, 142, 143, 90, 91
20, 89, 90, 143, 144
21, 191, 307, 305, 146
22, 37, 38, 189, 190
23, 148, 301, 300, 184
24, 40, 41, 185, 186
25, 299, 300, 361, 347
26, 43, 44, 181, 182
27, 150, 151, 79, 80
28, 46, 47, 156, 154
29, 78, 79, 151, 153
30, 481, 485, 351, 347
31, 77, 78, 153, 155
32, 245, 154, 156, 246
33, 76, 77, 155, 157
34, 152, 244, 243, 181
35, 75, 76, 157, 159
36, 154, 245, 244, 152
37, 74, 75, 159, 161
38, 73, 74, 161, 163
39, 158, 247, 246, 156
40, 72, 73, 163, 165
41, 160, 248, 247, 158
42, 71, 72, 165, 167
43, 162, 249, 248, 160
44, 70, 71, 167, 169
45, 161, 286, 287, 163
46, 69, 70, 169, 170
47, 170, 171, 68, 69
48, 164, 250, 249, 162
49, 61, 172, 173, 60
50, 60, 173, 174, 59
51, 59, 174, 175, 58
52, 175, 174, 253, 292
53, 57, 2, 58, 175
54, 254, 176, 292, 253
55, 291, 293, 349, 382
56, 178, 62, 63, 179
57, 167, 251, 256, 169
58, 294, 289, 350, 400
59, 171, 180, 67, 68
60, 180, 296, 258, 585
61, 3, 66, 585, 65
62, 347, 351, 297, 299
63, 152, 181, 44, 45
64, 183, 150, 80, 81
65, 148, 184, 82, 83
66, 348, 447, 448, 352
67, 149, 185, 41, 42
68, 187, 148, 83, 84
69, 146, 188, 85, 86
70, 302, 260, 385, 353
71, 147, 189, 38, 39
72, 191, 146, 86, 87
73, 88, 89, 144, 192
74, 306, 261, 386, 354
75, 145, 240, 262, 193
76, 34, 35, 193, 194
77, 33, 34, 194, 195
78, 310, 197, 196, 311
79, 198, 142, 91, 92
80, 140, 199, 93, 94
81, 317, 203, 138, 319
82, 201, 315, 266, 139
83, 202, 140, 94, 95
84, 138, 203, 96, 97
85, 139, 266, 267, 204
86, 205, 318, 268, 137
87, 206, 138, 97, 98
88, 136, 207, 99, 100
89, 137, 268, 269, 208
90, 135, 134, 20, 21
91, 210, 136, 100, 101
92, 211, 210, 101, 102
93, 133, 212, 103, 104
94, 425, 422, 237, 326
95, 213, 270, 328, 214
96, 215, 133, 104, 105
97, 131, 216, 106, 107
98, 218, 332, 333, 130
99, 132, 217, 16, 17
100, 108, 109, 220, 219
101, 129, 220, 109, 110
102, 335, 334, 356, 436
103, 130, 221, 13, 14
104, 111, 112, 224, 223
105, 127, 224, 112, 113
106, 127, 227, 276, 274
107, 129, 336, 334, 220
108, 115, 280, 227, 114
109, 117, 125, 116, 4
110, 126, 119, 120, 229
111, 280, 125, 228, 342
112, 231, 121, 122, 233
113, 8, 9, 226, 230
114, 341, 226, 225, 275
115, 230, 232, 7, 8
116, 277, 278, 232, 230
117, 232, 234, 6, 7
118, 278, 279, 234, 232
119, 1, 5, 584, 124
120, 116, 125, 280, 115
121, 119, 126, 228, 118
122, 9, 10, 225, 226
123, 113, 114, 227, 127
124, 128, 225, 10, 11
125, 11, 12, 222, 128
126, 14, 15, 218, 130
127, 17, 18, 214, 132
128, 137, 208, 23, 24
129, 24, 25, 205, 137
130, 27, 28, 201, 139
131, 30, 31, 197, 141
132, 145, 193, 35, 36
133, 408, 364, 449, 458
134, 36, 37, 190, 145
135, 39, 40, 186, 147
136, 42, 43, 182, 149
137, 168, 166, 52, 53
138, 45, 46, 154, 152
139, 151, 259, 282, 153
140, 47, 48, 158, 156
141, 540, 456, 460, 552
142, 48, 49, 160, 158
143, 49, 50, 162, 160
144, 283, 155, 153, 282
145, 50, 51, 164, 162
146, 284, 157, 155, 283
147, 51, 52, 166, 164
148, 285, 159, 157, 284
149, 286, 161, 159, 285
150, 53, 54, 177, 168
151, 62, 178, 172, 61
152, 54, 55, 176, 177
153, 398, 256, 251, 360
154, 292, 176, 55, 56
155, 57, 175, 292, 56
156, 380, 397, 288, 287
157, 179, 63, 64, 258
158, 170, 289, 294, 171
159, 65, 585, 258, 64
160, 295, 179, 258, 296
161, 66, 67, 180, 585
162, 171, 294, 296, 180
163, 299, 183, 184, 300
164, 184, 183, 81, 82
165, 183, 299, 297, 150
166, 402, 403, 501, 451
167, 149, 242, 260, 185
168, 188, 187, 84, 85
169, 187, 303, 301, 148
170, 490, 501, 403, 362
171, 188, 304, 303, 187
172, 147, 241, 261, 189
173, 192, 191, 87, 88
174, 144, 281, 308, 192
175, 538, 503, 500, 557
176, 365, 409, 312, 313
177, 197, 310, 264, 141
178, 195, 239, 311, 196
179, 196, 197, 31, 32
180, 314, 199, 140, 265
181, 199, 198, 92, 93
182, 142, 312, 309, 143
183, 313, 314, 415, 365
184, 200, 238, 315, 201
185, 28, 29, 200, 201
186, 203, 202, 95, 96
187, 368, 367, 316, 317
188, 203, 317, 316, 202
189, 469, 388, 416, 512
190, 207, 206, 98, 99
191, 369, 417, 319, 320
192, 322, 136, 210, 237
193, 320, 321, 421, 369
194, 209, 323, 325, 135
195, 212, 211, 102, 103
196, 327, 212, 133, 329
197, 430, 428, 329, 330
198, 214, 328, 271, 132
199, 216, 215, 105, 106
200, 331, 216, 131, 272
201, 355, 522, 523, 429
202, 217, 236, 332, 218
203, 15, 16, 217, 218
204, 340, 223, 224, 339
205, 356, 334, 336, 372
206, 221, 273, 337, 222
207, 127, 274, 339, 224
208, 338, 442, 443, 275
209, 344, 343, 229, 231
210, 345, 344, 231, 233
211, 233, 122, 123, 346
212, 234, 279, 346, 584
213, 124, 584, 346, 123
214, 5, 6, 234, 584
215, 126, 229, 343, 235
216, 323, 209, 208, 269
217, 237, 210, 211, 326
218, 263, 194, 193, 262
219, 312, 142, 198, 313
220, 240, 145, 190, 306
221, 306, 190, 189, 261
222, 241, 147, 186, 302
223, 302, 186, 185, 260
224, 242, 149, 182, 298
225, 298, 182, 181, 243
226, 244, 245, 358, 374
227, 351, 375, 259, 297
228, 358, 460, 456, 374
229, 376, 377, 283, 282
230, 377, 378, 284, 283
231, 250, 164, 166, 252
232, 378, 379, 285, 284
233, 252, 166, 168, 290
234, 290, 168, 177, 255
235, 252, 359, 381, 250
236, 251, 167, 165, 288
237, 288, 165, 163, 287
238, 177, 176, 254, 255
239, 174, 173, 291, 253
240, 257, 293, 172, 178
241, 253, 291, 382, 254
242, 290, 383, 359, 252
243, 178, 179, 295, 257
244, 256, 289, 170, 169
245, 349, 457, 384, 382
246, 259, 151, 150, 297
247, 143, 309, 281, 144
248, 265, 140, 202, 316
249, 238, 264, 413, 416
250, 204, 267, 318, 205
251, 206, 320, 319, 138
252, 270, 213, 134, 324
253, 324, 134, 135, 325
254, 272, 131, 219, 335
255, 335, 219, 220, 334
256, 273, 221, 130, 333
257, 276, 444, 389, 274
258, 275, 225, 128, 338
259, 338, 128, 222, 337
260, 227, 280, 342, 276
261, 390, 343, 344, 391
262, 539, 389, 444, 390
263, 230, 226, 341, 277
264, 233, 346, 279, 345
265, 393, 392, 246, 247
266, 456, 540, 537, 447
267, 392, 461, 460, 358
268, 393, 462, 461, 392
269, 379, 395, 286, 285
270, 396, 394, 248, 249
271, 397, 380, 494, 498
272, 293, 291, 173, 172
273, 457, 554, 556, 480
274, 400, 350, 554, 399
275, 400, 399, 257, 295
276, 352, 401, 242, 298
277, 403, 402, 301, 303
278, 304, 188, 146, 305
279, 405, 387, 491, 464
280, 353, 404, 241, 302
281, 305, 307, 387, 405
282, 307, 191, 192, 308
283, 354, 406, 240, 306
284, 573, 465, 504, 558
285, 364, 408, 281, 309
286, 313, 198, 199, 314
287, 466, 449, 364, 409
288, 568, 507, 505, 541
289, 357, 411, 239, 263
290, 410, 467, 468, 412
291, 412, 413, 2

 

[xerf]

Please, DO NOT cut&paste the whole input file in the post.

1.As you can see the post is cut after a certain number of lines.
2.If you want to share the .inp files with people potentially interested you can pack them in an archive and upload it to a file sharing web-site, then post only the link.

 

[xerf]

1. My guess without looking at input files is that your mesh was not refined enough regardless the meshing technique you used.
2. Since the mesh was not identical, technically you cannot compare the strains at same integration points.

 

[Cansand]

xerf
Thank you for your reply . About 2. "upload it to a file sharing web-site, then post only the link" I never done that before. If you have a moment please teach me

-Anyway as I said refining is not a reason for this discrepancy I ultimately refine both and found the difference (almost three order) didnot change.
AM not comparing a spicific point to a specific point but I am looking at the average results obtained from both >
Anyhow if you are a member in Yahoo ABAQUS group. Today I posted the same question over there under " On Meshin Technique" and both input files are there plesae look at them and you see what I am talking about

 

[corus]

The meshing technique will have no effect on the results as the input file doesn't know which technqiue was used to generate the mesh. As xerf says it must be the mesh refinement or some other error in the input.

corus

 

[bassmanjax]

Helppoorpeople,

Be nice to know which elements you used - element choice and formulation would have a significant effect on the results aswell.

Also, like Xerf says, it's not a good idea to post entire input decks. There are sites like

http://www.yousendit.com

that are ideal for remotely hosting files for sharing.

Regards

Martin

 

[Cansand]

Dear martin and Corus

Please note that although both meshes have the same type and very much almost the same Number of elements and look even topogically the same, how the Advancing Free mesh leads to much higher displacement (three order almost) and resultes in localized displacement (strain) response while structural gives uniform

http://download.yousendit.com/E97E1EC942616B17

P.S :I put both input files for this very simple model in one file as the site doesnot allow me to upload more than one file at a time.



Thanks