Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

  • Congratulations waross on being selected by the Eng-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!

I think I ended up in the wrong place, need help 7

Status
Not open for further replies.

anonfrustrated

Aerospace
Jun 30, 2008
3
US
I accepted a job offer not knowing a lot about the company I would be working for (secrecy of company), because the company of my choice didn't respond as soon as they said they would. Right before starting, the company of my choice called me for an in-person interview, but I had already accepted the alternative (they said to call back if anything came up). I was enthusiastic about the job though, being very closely related to my #1 choice.


I've been working there for a few months now, and it is my only experience in the field (though I have held several engineering internships before). It was soon that I realized many things were wrong with where I worked:

1- I was told that they hadn't fired anyone in the department. This is so untrue it's not funny.
2- There is NO QC on anything, even though we are designing and building things with the consequences of failure being death/serious injury. The only QC I have seen has been by drafters on drawings, but there is no process for checking design calcs, and things are frequently built before calculations or drawings are made.
3- No traceability on parts. There have been several instances of material being mislabeled as something else with different engineering qualities. Things are not built to drawing and nobody knows until the engineer that designed the product or some other engineer goes out and actually looks at the things and sees obvious mistakes.
4- Severe micromanagement by the boss's boss. One of them signs off on a drawing. Two weeks later after the part is built the other comes along and says that he wants a design change because of inadequacies of the design (even though no calculations were made by the criticizing management). An argument ensues that lasts hours with only guesswork and fumbling without numbers. In other cases, engineered parts are simply removed from designs because they look ugly, with no other justification or even asking the engineer if it will affect the intended use of the product, or its safety.
5- Severe apathy by everyone (this everyone is not an exaggeration for my department), even immediate managers. If you complain that some people are doing something excessively dangerous/stupid, they just comment on how they can't believe it and do absolutely nothing.
6- People with decades of experience in a specific area are treated as incompetent by managers, who believe they can design complex systems themselves without doing any engineering.


I could go on. The point is this place is as close to insane as I've experienced/heard of. I'd like to get back in touch with my #1 choice. My only concern is it will be damaging to my career, or it will somehow get out to my current employer that I am job hunting and I will get canned (they have fired for less). Most of the time I try to do damage control to make sure that nobody is going to get killed or hurt on designs that aren't mine (they were made by people who quit for some/all of the above reasons), without being seen as rocking the boat. In fact, management complained when it was pointed out that certain potentially dangerous things were wrong. They weren't complaining about the error, they complained that it was pointed out.

Is bailing ASAP the best option here?
 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

You might as well bail out. A junior engineer is not going to be able to introduce enough sanity into a place like that.

I don't think it'll damage your resume as much as staying and getting ground down would.

Cheers

Greg Locock

SIG:please see FAQ731-376 for tips on how to make the best use of Eng-Tips.
 
i worked in a place where things were being done incorrctly and i could see it going pear shaped. I hung on to long tbh but left in after two years ( i should have gone in three months). Within a year it was shut. No clients, bad reputation, no money. I suggest you get out before your reputation goes the same way by association.
 
As a younger person you may not realize it now, but there is plenty of time to recover from this. And you probably will be dismayed to discover that most organizations are chaotic, deceptive, inefficient, poorly managed, and wouldn't think twice of cutting you loose on a moment's notice (read up on what the "At Will" policy means).

Just make sure that your complaints are valid and are not a collision with your idealistic view of what engineering and work should be.

Now that you have a better idea of the questions that are important to you, I'd suggest calling the other company and get answers. If it suits you and they're agreeable, then blow that joint and move on. Purge it from your resume and make up a good excuse for the gap in time when you have to explain it for your next job.

TygerDawg
Blue Technik LLC
Virtuoso Robotics Engineering
 
My current position stared out similarily to yours, but had the advantage of being in a rapidly growing company. While issues were recognized, it was management-by-crisis. If a similar position were available in this industry in my area, I would have jumped at it. Things are improving, albeit slowly, and I am glad that I'm riding it out.
Your situation in that company, however, seems nearly hopeless. Unless there is a change in management on the horizon, I'd do as the others recommend, and contact the other company. Ask pertinent questions regarding issues that you have struggled with in your present position. If the opportunity is there, jump on it. If it isn't, quietly start your job search.
A few months there isn't going to hurt your resume much, especially if they have a reputation in the industry. Whatever you do, don't badmouth them to a potential employer. Find a diplomatic way of explaining your short employment there, and your eagerness to move on.

Believe it if you need it or leave it if you dare. - [small]Robert Hunter[/small]
 
One good phrase to use on future employers:

"I realized that my goals differed from that of <former employer> and decided that it would benefit both <former employer> and me to obtain a new job that more closely aligned with those goals." Do NOT badmout your curren/former employer.

However, if you strongly feel that your current company is doing things that are going to cause serious death or injury you should consider making a complaint to OSHA or your state professional engineering organization. Be sure to document carefully, with specific examples. Instead of saying "In other cases, engineered parts are simply removed from designs because they look ugly, with no other justification or even asking the engineer if it will affect the intended use of the product, or its safety," you need to be able to say "On product xyz, part abc was removed without any calculations as to the final safety of the product." But be sure of what you're saying. Just because you don't know of the calculations, doesn't mean they weren't done.

Patricia Lougheed

Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of the Eng-Tips Forums.
 
you also need to be careful as a knowledgable person may be able to suppliment another part knowing it will work from experience without the need to check it. Frequently i know of drawings going out with out full calcs as its been done many times before and it gets justified later.
 
You cannot fit in to every place you work, one failed experiment on a cv would not harm your application in my books.

Look after yourself and go get the job you want before someone else does.
 
Bail out ;)

And I definitely agree with previous posters about not bad mouthing your current employer.

You have only been there a few months. You are not huritng your career at all by leaving.

But it does sound like most of the companies I have worked for ;) I worked for places like that where they tried to get the PE to sign off on some design the owner had oversaw. And without the PE crunching any numbers! The PE said "No!" of course. The PE was not there much longer because he was "uncooperative."


 
I think that you are wasting your time where you are. Its better to get out sooner rather than later, before you have to explain away the time you spend there. From the sound of it, their days are numbered. If its aerospace products that you are working on, its probably the Federal Government (FAA?) that has jurisdiction, not OSHA or the State Engineering Board. Be advised that "ratting out" your employer can sometimes result in you becoming "blackballed" from engineering, even when you are in the right. Choose carefully.
 
I understand your worries about your resume.

Just tell your next employer that you ended up working under some incompetent middle-level engineer and didn't think he was a good influence.

You'll find someone who is a better influence.

 
jeffcivil2 said:
Just tell your next employer that you ended up working under some incompetent middle-level engineer and didn't think he was a good influence.

Don't, under any circumstances, say that.

Always try to find the good (albeit small) influence that managers have had on you. The best way to phrase it, is as vpl did. Your goals didn't align with those of that company. Simple, concise, and true. Believe me, you will come off sounding more professional.

Good luck, whatever your decision.

V
 

I guess vc66 is correct in that "incompetent" isn't a word that a junior should throw around vocally. If you can explain to him solid proof of incompetence than I'm sure the interviewer will come to his own conclusion.

But you have to be honest because you don't want to work for this new company and find that the CEO is golfing buddies with the other company CEO.

 
All the more reason to not badmouth at all.

Believe it if you need it or leave it if you dare. - [small]Robert Hunter[/small]
 
Bail.

If asked at your next interview give a canned response to a canned question.
"Why did you leave your last position"
"No room for advancement" Next question please.
 
I've had a similar experience, albeit I was not a junior engineer at the time. I hung in there for 6 months during which my work ethic and confidence started to suffer. Things only got worse as time passed such that I quit with minimal notice. Just showed up, and told the manager that today would be my last day. I was escorted off the property shortly after that conversation.

The point of the above story is that while interviewing for other jobs after that, the question of my short employment would be raised. My answer was straight forward and to the point: "I had personal and professional/ethical conflicts with the Manager." Each of those hiring personnel accepted my answer without further questioning, and in each case, I was offered a position with the company.

I believe that you should tell it like it is/was, but avoid making statements which cast judgement on others. That behaviour reflects poorly on you.

jetmaker
 
Thank you for the suggestions, especially on not to rant about the current company. Would it be too much if I said that I had have a serious problem with their safety and quality control?
 
yes that would be too much.

Patricia Lougheed

Please see FAQ731-376: Eng-Tips.com Forum Policies for tips on how to make the best use of the Eng-Tips Forums.
 
There's all kinds of things that you can tell the next employer about the current employer (and your reasons for looking elsewhere) without bad-mouthing them. It's a skill that needs to be developed.

Here are some examples. Always make them diplomatic, never personal, and reference some abstract career notion, business condition, or higher purpose:

The business is in a downturn and the future looks grim.

They've gotten some new contracts, but I don't see where my skills fit. It makes me worry, so I'm exploring my options.

It's a great company, but I don't really see any opportunities for further development. I'm looking for a place where I can stretch and be challenged a bit.

I am trying to find work near here because of shorter commute / family issues / health issues.




TygerDawg
Blue Technik LLC
Virtuoso Robotics Engineering
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Part and Inventory Search

Sponsor

Back
Top