Eng-Tips is the largest engineering community on the Internet

Intelligent Work Forums for Engineering Professionals

In the early eighties, I worked wit

Status
Not open for further replies.

slick1

Aerospace
Feb 20, 2002
2
0
0
US
In the early eighties, I worked with a prostock
motorcycle race team. During that time I got to see
the inner workings of the race world.The individuals
bikes that we worked on had there cranks sent to a company called Falicon, there forte is high revving cranks .
To make a long story short, has anyone taken a v-8 crank
and placed needle bearings at the main journals . Of course
the harmonics of balance would be critical.

 
Replies continue below

Recommended for you

Roller bearing cranks have been tried over and over. At one stage they were popular in hotrodded VW beetles.

The pro's and cons are

The crank must be pulled appart to replace the bearings, or a special split bearing shell must be used.
Rollers can survive with very poor lubrication, hence thair use in 2 stroke engines.
Roller bearings are expensive.
Roller bearings do not tollerate shock loadings as well as a plain bearing.
A well designed and lubricated plain adds very little to the total friction in an engine, so even large improvements here make little difference to the overal friction of the engine.
Plain bearings have less friction than most people think. Unfortunately I cannot find any hard data as it is 30 years since I looked into it last.


Regards
pat
 
Besides the items Pat listed, I think there'd be very little return on your investment. On a V8, even if we had nearly frictionless main journals (lubricated with liquid helium at a few degrees Kelvin), there's still only 5 of them. While we have 8 connecting rod journals, at least 24 piston rings, a minimum of 16 valves, camshaft, and so on, all contributing to the total frictional losses. On smaller inline engines, where main bearing friction makes up a greater percentage of the whole, then use of ball, roller, or needle bearings may seem more attractive.

BC


 
I am amused by the trouble some will subject themselves to. There are a few clients of mine that insist on running cams on needle bearings. It's expensive, it's a pain, and it is worth very very little. I preach and sell cost effective power. Plain and simple. However, I would love to be made of so much Money that the extra cost didn't matter. But then, most of us who are made or WERE made of money like me won't get it back unless we pinch our way back.

Shaun TiedeULTRADYNE Arl,TX(stiede@ev1.net)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top