Overlay weld on tubesheet of a heat exchanger 1

[kyong]

In Section VIII Div 2 Part UCL, the Code reads rules in UCL shall apply to vessel which has over lay weld.
If the tubesheet of a heat exchanger is going to be over lay welded to enhance seal weld reliability of tube to tubesheet joint, is the Part UCL still governing?

 

[prex]

Why should not? Can you be more specific on your concerns?
The rules in UCL are specific for cladding fabrication and examination, all the rest of design and fabrication rules remains applicable.
Also note that you are referring to Div.1, not Div.2.

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com

Online tools for structural design

See

http://www.xcalcs.com/docs/symbolinfo.htm

if you want to use symbols on these forums

 

[kyong]

Thank you, prex.
Yes, you are right. It is Div 1, not Div 2.
And I feel my question was a little out of my intention.
What I want know is that isn't there any ground to escape from rules in UCL. After all, we want to weld over lay not in accordance with ASME Section IX, still keeping ASME conformance of the heat exchanger, if ever possible.

 

[prex]

Can't see how you could justify that.
After all the main requirements for a non resistant weld overlay cladding are intended at checking that the weld overlay does not impair the resistance of the base material, and of course you can't escape this issue.

prex

http://www.xcalcs.com

Online tools for structural design

See

http://www.xcalcs.com/docs/symbolinfo.htm

if you want to use symbols on these fora

 

[deanc]

kyong

You state you wish to comply with the Code. You must observe it ALL,you are not permitted to pick and choose.

Read U-2(b),UW-28,UW-29,UCL-30,UCL-40

 

[kyong]

Thank you, prex and deanc.
I agree with you guys. I think I have to give up trying to justify not following part UCL.

kyong